Death penalty for leaving Islam discussion.

[MeemWawMeemNoon]

No need to kill the apostate, he already kills his fate and destiny by rejecting and leaving true pathway of life, islam.

Quoted for truth!

[Muslimah]

This is such a "hot" topic. I really enjoy it all. But brothers, please stay civil. Allah swt does not like the ummah fighting with one another! tsk tsk...please talk nicely or agree to disagree.

But, I mean, why would we want a lot of fake Muslims? If we are blackmailing them to stay, and they stay only by force, that makes for some pretty crappy Muslims around, huh? But if we let them leave (because they're morons and didn't do their research), whose business is it to us? Allah swt knows all, and He will be the one giving them their destiny. Why remove them from this earth and expedite their voyage to Hellfire? Why not make them suffer longer on earth, then suffer eternity in Hellfire?

This reminds me of when countries give death sentence to murders. Don't you think thats the easy way out? I mean, sitting, rotting in a prison sell is a heck of a lot worse than a painless death by injection.

[شمله ور خراساني]

Sangar, Do you not think this is blackmailing?

No.

[Muslimah]

^ Why not?

[شمله ور خراساني]

^ Why not?

If we would label this as black-mail, then chopping the hand of a thief or stoning an adulterer could also be labeled as blackmail.

[شمله ور خراساني]

^But it is blackmailing we are telling them you leave we kill you.

Yes, and telling people if you fornicate and cheat on your wife, we kill you also blackmailing?

[Mr.Niazi]

Who ever leave Islam and convert to different religion he or she should be killed..

[Muslimah]

But who are you to decide that? You're not God...
I would rather ridicule them and laugh at them for being stupid enough to leave. Their loss.

[Muslimah]

Death penalty is only used in special cases. I am on Sangar's side.

What are these "special cases"? It seems here that some say everyone should die that leaves Islam.

I would rather have them gone, than to blackmail them into being poor Muslims.

[Azmatullah]

I wonder too.

[MeemWawMeemNoon]

Yes, and telling people if you fornicate and cheat on your wife, we kill you also blackmailing?

You are comparing apples and oranges.

Plus, you are not killed in Islam for fornication or adultery.

[شمله ور خراساني]

You are comparing apples and oranges.

Plus, you are not killed in Islam for fornication or adultery.

Oh really?


EDIT: Inappropriate picture.

[Muslimah]

^ Gimme a hadith or aya that says that...not a picture...
Thats cultural..
AND disgusting

[شمله ور خراساني]

^ Gimme a hadith or aya that says that...not a picture...
Thats cultural..
AND disgusting

Go ask your imam. I'm sure he will be able to provide you with sources on how the prophet saww ordered to have adulterers stoned.

[Muslimah]

Why dont you spare me and everyone else time and show me yourself? Then everyone may agree with you.

I don't like going to places where men gather....aka the mosque.