Stoning to Death

[MostafaM]

So you do not believe in Islam then right? Lets not mince words about these issues being my religious concepts. They are primary religious edicts that I did not reveal.

Right.

I am an agnostic.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Who said those standards are valid ?

who said they weren't?

[ScimitarXEdge]

Right.

I am an agnostic.

which would get you filled with bullet holes in Afghanistan.

[BarakzaiAbdali]

And the connection to Afghanistan, the Taliban and them giving refuge to every islamist terrorist group in the world is?

I told you open another thread for this topic. I prefer to keep us on topic here. Please elucidate your opinion on your disagreement with Muhammad (S). Does that mean you do not accept his revelation as divine?

[MostafaM]

The problem with Your argument is it assumes America had an intrinsic right of entitlement to begin with.


Part of being a grown up is recognizing who has a valid justification and who doesn't. Perhaps you should grow up and realize just because you're in the direction of the guy shooting you doesn't mean it's his right to do so.

Your question is already answered, European terrorists have been doing just as you described for about the last 500 years. I think we can see where the balance stands

Do we agree that 9/11 happened and that Al Qaida was responsible?

[BarakzaiAbdali]

Right.

I am an agnostic.

Enough said. All your above arguments taken in light of that single statement shows how you understand next to nothing about the Afghan people. You are in a sense, chromosomeless.

[MostafaM]

which would get you filled with bullet holes in Afghanistan.

That´s what you assume.

[BarakzaiAbdali]

Do we agree that 9/11 happened and that Al Qaida was responsible?

Open another thread. You merely proved here for all to see that

1) You disavow Islam.
2) You claim to speak for the Afghans in other matters

Now, people know exactly where you stand.
So the folks reading your arguments will have tomake a choice. Muhammad (S) versus Mostafa 1919. Who will they pick?

[ScimitarXEdge]

the problem with Mostafa is that he thinks that america have an intrinsic right in this matter; that they are automatically entitled.


man the Mangals who role up against the Briitish even though they knew the British would retaliate against them for doing so would be turning in their grave

It was the Mangal tribe that fought for everything we're trying to uphold now and now one of their one shuns all that and betrays it for the other side.

[ScimitarXEdge]

That´s what you assume.

No I know you would you'd be killed....the ones like you live in hiding or keep their opinions secret

[randolph85]

being a pacifist will not make ur enemies pacifists as well. they will take advantage of ur weakness and wipe u out, leaving no trace of ur life, and writing history as they see fit.

2:216

Fighting is prescribed for you, and ye dislike it. But it is possible that ye dislike a thing which is good for you, and that ye love a thing which is bad for you. But Allah knoweth, and ye know not.

[MostafaM]

Enough said. All your above arguments taken in light of that single statement shows how you understand next to nothing about the Afghan people. You are in a sense, chromosomeless.

Well, I am Afghan and I know many Afghans who share my point of view and alot who do not.

Is Afghan sociaty for an ideal and homogen entity where everyone is as muslim as you?

[ScimitarXEdge]

Do we agree that 9/11 happened and that Al Qaida was responsible?

do we agree that America and it's Imperial kin have been interfering and creating problems in the Middle East for several centuries?

[randolph85]

Do we agree that 9/11 happened and that Al Qaida was responsible?

not to take sides with the salafis, which i am not, but the war began decades before 9/11, even centuries before if we are to count the western world into the whole 9/11 spectrum. as it was not just america who invaded and occupied iraq and afghanistan, but nations who have been involved in the occupation and destabilization of muslim lands for hundreds of years.

[MostafaM]

Open another thread. You merely proved here for all to see that

1) You disavow Islam.
2) You claim to speak for the Afghans in other matters

Now, people know exactly where you stand.
So the folks reading your arguments will have tomake a choice. Muhammad (S) versus Mostafa 1919. Who will they pick?

I claim to speak for me.

And it´s not me against Mohammed, it´s everyone´s own consciouns vs what Mohammed teaches.

Your propaganda is childish.