Were their any famous Pashtun philosophers or mathematicians

[RevolutionThroughReason]

You know Ghilzai's are R1A like Durranis.....right? Your absurd theory was debunked by Khushal a long time ago.

Not necessarily

Q-M242 origininated in Asia, and is widely distributed there.[2] It has been reported that Q-M242 is found in the Altai people,[13] India,[14] Tibet,[15] Pakistan,[14] China,[16][17] Vietnam,[18] Mongolia,[19] Tuvans,[20] and Uyghurs.[19] It was found in 9 out of 49 specimens (18%) in a Y-Haplogroup study of Pashtuns in Kabul the Capital of Afghanistan.[21]

Khushal responded yes; but debunked no; never assume someone responding means they debunk something. That's faulty logic

to debunk something you have to show thie actual claim is incorrect not what one assumes the claim to be is incorrect; this is what Khushal did and why my statement remains undebunked.

[Kushan Prince]

Jamaladin al Afghani
Khushal Khan Khattak
Ahmed Shah Abdali
Wazir Akbar Khan
Omar Hotak
The Lodhi dynasties had great philosophers

If people think that Ghandi was a philosopher, then you have to count Khan Abdur Ghaffur Khan in that category since he walked the walk instead of talking the talk like ghandi did.

Those are the top of my head. but there are more.

Other then Al Afghani, the rest on your list are more poet-warriors then actual philosophers. Great list though!

[Kushan Prince]

Not necessarily


Khushal responded yes; but debunked no; never assume someone responding means they debunk something. That's faulty logic

to debunk something you have to show thie actual claim and not is incorrect not what one assumes the claim to be is incorrect; this is what Khushal did and why my statement remains undebunked.

Your quote doesn't mention Pashtuns of what tribe that carry that halogroup so its not really specific. Your way of coining that with the Ghilzai's fails not to mention there aren't that much Ghilzai's in Kabul.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Your quote doesn't mention Pashtuns of what tribe that carry that halogroup so its not really specific. Your way of coining that with the Ghilzai's fails not to mention there aren't that much Ghilzai's in Kabul.

Right it doesn't but that's my point; you're assuming that Ghilzais don't have Turkic ancestry; but of all the Pashtun groups Ghilzais are the only ones who have a historical connection to Turks; this is what leads us to evidence; The evidence points to Ghilzais as having Turkic origins; the genetics indicates that some Pashtuns have Turkic blood.

If you actually are from a Pashtun family you'd know Ghilzai Pashtuns dominate several districts in Kabul: Paghman , Chahar Asyab and Surobi

check it out

http://www.nps.edu/programs/ccs/Docs/PDF%20Maps/KabulTribalMap07.pdf

[Kushan Prince]

Right it doesn't but that's my point; you're assuming that Ghilzais don't have Turkic ancestry; but of all the Pashtun groups Ghilzais are the only ones who have a historical connection to Turks; this is what leads us to evidence; The evidence points to Ghilzais as having Turkic origins; the genetics indicates that some Pashtuns have Turkic blood.

If you actually are from a Pashtun family you'd know Ghilzai Pashtuns dominate several districts in Kabul: Paghman , Chahar Asyab and Surobi

check it out
http://www.nps.edu/programs/ccs/Docs...ribalMap07.pdf

Ghilzai's are mostly concentrated in Kandahar (where they originate from) and ghazni. I'm not say they AREN'T any in Kabul but not as much as other pashtun tribes. Kabul is mostly dominated with Durranis. I'm not even going to bother arguing with you about your Turkish fetish.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Ghilzai's are mostly concentrated in Kandahar (where they originate from) and ghazni. I'm not say they AREN'T any in Kabul but not as much as other pashtun tribes. Kabul is mostly dominated with Durranis. I'm not even going to bother arguing with you about your Turkish fetish.

read the link I posted; you don't know what you're talking about like AT ALL

This is the Tribal Map of Kandahar

http://www.nps.edu/programs/ccs/Docs/PDF%20Maps/KandaharTribalMap07.pdf

This is Ghazni

http://www.nps.edu/Programs/CCS/Docs/PDF%20Maps/GhazniTribalMap07.pdf

Really you really don'y know much about Pashtuns or Afghanistan; you just guess at stuff without fact checking.

[Kushan Prince]

read the link I posted; you don't know what you're talking about like AT ALL

This is the Tribal Map of Kandahar

http://www.nps.edu/programs/ccs/Docs/PDF%20Maps/KandaharTribalMap07.pdf

This is Ghazni

http://www.nps.edu/Programs/CCS/Docs/PDF%20Maps/GhazniTribalMap07.pdf

Really you really don'y know much about Pashtuns or Afghanistan; you just guess at stuff without fact checking.

Are you denying There aren't any ghilzai in Kandahar? Dude just stop. Your map is fricking false.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Are you denying There aren't any ghilzai in Kandahar? Dude just stop. Your map is fricking false.

That's not what you claimed though; you said that Ghilzai are primarily concentrated there. Unless you're a Ghilzai yourself stop acting like you're an expert on us.

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

Ghilzai's are mostly concentrated in Kandahar (where they originate from) and ghazni. I'm not say they AREN'T any in Kabul but not as much as other pashtun tribes. Kabul is mostly dominated with Durranis. I'm not even going to bother arguing with you about your Turkish fetish.

Please stop embarassing yourself.

[Kushan Prince]

That's not what you claimed though; you said that Ghilzai are primarily concentrated there. Unless you're a Ghilzai yourself stop acting like you're an expert on us.

Your not a pashtun but a Yemeni camel breeder. Therefore a Bedouin like you should not be so interested in the origins of Ghilzai's or any other pashtun qaums for that matter.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Your not a pashtun but a Yemeni camel breeder. Therefore a Bedouin like you should not be so interested in the origins of Ghilzai's or any other pashtun qaums for that matter.

Says the guy absolutely clueless about Pashtuns., Just like Shamlawar said; stop embarrassing yourself.

[HalloIsBack]

rtr has got a turkish fetish and i have a pashtun fetish

[HalloIsBack]

i have more clue about pashtuns in compare to kp although i'm not one

[Sanzerkhel]

Please stop the drama, I did not make the thread to know RTR has a turk fetish or some other guy wears blue t shirts on a daily basis. Get back on topic, please!

[Kushan Prince]

Says the guy absolutely clueless about Pashtuns., Just like Shamlawar said; stop embarrassing yourself.

I had respect for you as a user on here before but you can't seem to talk to anyone with respect. You try to shove your opinions down peoples throats as facts and get offended when people don't agree with you. Your'e random hissy fits really annoy me and your'e two stooges here (hallo and that tajik khursani guy) are ruining this forum with their trolling along with you as their ring leader. I highly doubt you can say half the crap on here in real life in someones face and have the guts to tell a pashtun that he is a backwards, uneducated and tribal because if you did, you would literally be beaten senseless. I've never met such a beghirat half breed pashtun in my life who hates his own people and blames them for the problems in his pathetic life. That Bedouin blood of yours must have canceled out the pride and courage that pashtuns usually carry.

In short, go F yourself.