why are afghan pashtuns now called kabuli?true pashtun are pakistan or afghan pashtun

[rednwhite99]

what abt turis ..

i m getting married to a kundi from dera ismail khan ..is it similar to marwat or different..what kind of tribe is that ..thanx

[khushal]

bro ..i tell u one thing u will find some pashtun in kpk who are nationalists but fata people over there are v patriotic ..this might be surprizing but i know that especially kurram agency
and they didnt submit actually amir of afghanistan sold them..submission was by the amir of afghanistan who submitted to the brits with an agreement

this is a red herring fallacy, your changing the topic. make another thread and I will answer you.

FYI, there are Turis in Afghanistan as well.

[torkham]

Momand, Safi, Zazai, wardak, khogyani, wazir and khosti are in Afghanistan. I never heard wardak, ludin, popal in Pakistan except transient. And yusufzai to lesser extent also in Afghanistan.
Other well known are kakkar, acahkzai, noori all over from Quetta to oruzgan.

And as mentioned above, anthem is in both pashto and farsi.
However I do wish pashto language dominates all spheres.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

I would suggest you to stop talking until you have educated yourself.

please educated me

my kabuli friend

[rednwhite99]

this is a red herring fallacy, your changing the topic. make another thread and I will answer you.

FYI, there are Turis in Afghanistan as well.

woow mashalah man thanx i didnt know that

[khushal]

i m getting married to a kundi from dera ismail khan ..is it similar to marwat or different..what kind of tribe is that ..thanx

I think they are related to Marwat, who are Lohani not Karlani.

but luffy should answer this question.

[Haris]

100% of karlani pashtuns are in pakistan(40% of pashtuns are karlani alone)

That has to rank up there as one of the stupidest claims I have ever seen on these forums (and I have seen many stupid claims).




In the Pashtun History section, you provide sources for your claims if you want to be taken seriously.

You are obviously not to be taken seriously.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Momand, Safi, Zazai, wardak, khogyani, wazir and khosti are in Afghanistan. I never heard wardak, ludin, popal in Pakistan except transient. And yusufzai to lesser extent also in Afghanistan.
Other well known are kakkar, acahkzai, noori all over from Quetta to oruzgan.

And as mentioned above, anthem is in both pashto and farsi.
However I do wish pashto language dominates all spheres.

afghanistan was suppose to be the nation of pashtuns only

i dont know why dirty people like tajiks are even allowed to stay in afghanistan when they can opt for tajikistan or uzbek for uzbekistan

why dont you guys kick them out.

as i said earlier wazir even being a sub tribe of karlani pashtun is a massive tribe.hence small number of wazir are present in afghanistan.but they are indigenous to Waziristan and now bannu as well.

because of the attitude of afghan pashtun.

tajiks already has dominated the afghanistan even though they are only 27% of the total population.70% of strategic post in ANA are held by tajiks as per reports


Wake up afghan pashtuns.tajiks are bigger enemies than even the taliban

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

instead of such one liner replies.

i would rather want to be proven wrong with solid authentic sourcesa

[Haris]

instead of such one liner replies.

i would rather want to be proven wrong with solid authentic sourcesa

lol!

The onus is on you to prove your claims first providing sources.
What are your "solid authentic sources"?...one Wikipedia page on Pashtun Tribes?

[rednwhite99]

I think they are related to Marwat, who are Lohani not Karlani.

but luffy should answer this question.

i know luffy but luffy belongs to a lot of tribes at the same time.. the way i caught him was because he was having the same username but different identities as per the tribe is concerned..marwat was one of them

[khushal]

afghanistan was suppose to be the nation of pashtuns only

i dont know why dirty people like tajiks are even allowed to stay in afghanistan when they can opt for tajikistan or uzbek for uzbekistan

why dont you guys kick them out.

as i said earlier wazir even being a sub tribe of karlani pashtun is a massive tribe.hence small number of wazir are present in afghanistan.but they are indigenous to Waziristan and now bannu as well.

because of the attitude of afghan pashtun.

tajiks already has dominated the afghanistan even though they are only 27% of the total population.70% of strategic post in ANA are held by tajiks as per reports


Wake up afghan pashtuns.tajiks are bigger enemies than even the taliban

The places where Tajiks reside in the north is Tajik land, you cant kick them out. Ahmed shah Abdali ruled them and annexed them to Afghanistan. Like I said go get an education.

Plus What is pashtunistan, forget this non sense. think big , don't think small. Think Hindustan, Pakistan, Afghanistan Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkemistan and all the other stans into one federal unit. That would be ideal. The Europeans are unifying and your thinking about dividing. You are truly mentally colonized.

[khushal]

i know luffy but luffy belongs to a lot of tribes at the same time.. the way i caught him was because he was having the same username but different identities as per the tribe is concerned..marwat was one of them

What do you mean. didn't he say he was a michen kheil which is a marwat. What else did he say he was. I have only read he is marwat.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

The places where Tajiks reside in the north is Tajik land, you cant kick them out. Ajhmed shah Abdali ruled them and annexed them to Afghanistan. Like I said go get an education.

Plus What is pashtunistan, forget this non sense. think big , don't think small. Think Hindustan, Pakistan, Afghanistan Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkemistan and all the other stans into one federal unit. That would be ideal. The Europeans are unifying and your thinking about dividing. You are truly mentally colonized.

how come they are considered the richest and most important ANA is made up of them.

when i asked a afghan in a yet another forum is to why tajik are in majority in ANA..he said because pashtuns might have soft heart for the fellow pashtun taliban

now tell me wtf is this?

if they are in north than get seperated from them.

i dont dream of impossibles

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

lol!

The onus is on you to prove your claims first providing sources.
What are your "solid authentic sources"?...one Wikipedia page on Pashtun Tribes?

indeed.

common sense aswell.karlani in majority are in pakistan.

of the total 10millions pashtuns living in afghanistan.2millions of them are registered as refugees in pakistan while 2-3millions are living illegal in kpk

making the total population of pashtuns living in afghan below 10millions
while as per latest studies there are 35millions pashtuns in pakistan alone

making all of the historic major tribes of pashtuns