What makes a Pashtun a Pashtun?

[tilla_jogian]

Guys I asked if these indic people I posted can pass as pakhtuns? :/

[Samandri]

I am just messing with [MENTION=18277]Afghanfootball[/MENTION]....i hope he doesnt commit suicide.

[Samandri]

can these indic people pass among pakhtuns?

The two Aryans, Football and princess are in better position to analyze these pictures. [MENTION=2329]Karachi[/MENTION] is crazy about this stuff, tagg him.

[Afghanfootball]

Holy shut this porki ****boy is still mentioning me in his posts XD. I have you on ignore have some self respect its getting sad af.

[Afghanfootball]

can these indic people pass among pakhtuns?

No to all of them except the 5th. Maybe he could pass but just maybe.

[Kushan Prince]

Sir Olaf has written a very interesting and well-researched book about Pashtuns..........what has it any thing to do with inferiority complex?. Our Khar Pashtuns are lazy about research and history, so credit must be given to those British who wrote some authentic stuff about us, or atleast wrote about us.

Ghilam Jama, All of the great British administrators considered it their duty to study and research on people under their governance, they were super-power for this reason.

Now most of our recorded info, even of 19th century Afghanistan comes from Western authors, and big chunk of it is biased particularly in the matters of military history. Your Persianized monarchs were also good for nothing. Even the history of ghilzais in 18th century comes from european author. And all of our medieval history comes from authors based in Hindostan.

Ghilam Jama, All of the great British administrators considered it their duty to study and research on people under their governance, t

LOL this proves his inferiority complex to the British, he thinks they were "authentic" and "unbiased" conerncing their opinions on Pashtun haha. Hey Farty, did you know some British writers thought that Pashtuns were actually a mixture of Greeks and Rajputs? You still think they are reliable when it comes to Pashtuns?

You're a dunce, you know nothing, even your whole "History of Pashtuns" blogspot is filled with unreliable english sources that speculate at best. I suggest you pick up some books on Afghan history by REAL authors like Abdul Khan Habibi, Mahmud Tarzi or Akram Aseem.

[Samandri]

LOL this proves his inferiority complex to the British, he thinks they were "authentic" and "unbiased" conerncing their opinions on Pashtun haha. Hey Farty, did you know some British writers thought that Pashtuns were actually a mixture of Greeks and Rajputs? You still think they are reliable when it comes to Pashtuns?

You're a dunce, you know nothing, even your whole "History of Pashtuns" blogspot is filled with unreliable english sources that speculate at best. I suggest you pick up some books on Afghan history by REAL authors like Abdul Khan Habibi, Mahmud Tarzi or Akram Aseem.

My interest in Pashtun history doesnt extend to Greek or Roman or Scythian era.

Interesting to see that that you browsed through my blog. About Abdul Hai Habibi, i have posted some of his articles on my blog. Mahmud Tarzai wrote about Pashtun history?

[Kushan Prince]

My interest in Pashtun history doesnt extend to Greek or Roman or Scythian era.

Interesting to see that that you browsed through my blog. About Abdul Hai Habibi, i have posted some of his articles on my blog. Mahmud Tarzai wrote about Pashtun history?

Yep, Mahmud was an intellect who wrote history along with literature. Since your too concerned about what the british wrote you don't have time to read the books of the many Afghan historians out there. Your blog is nothing interesting, just old memoirs of what the British stationed in your land thought of Pashtuns and the tribes they encountered.

My interest in Pashtun history doesnt extend to Greek or Roman or Scythian era.

Since the Scythians were from south Afg, it matters to Pashtuns since they have been paired with them by many historians. Even farsiwan historians know Pashtuns better than your former masters.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

inferiority complex of Pakistani pashtuns against afghantani?really?

Well i had noticed that with money come proud.

For example India or iran.Pakistan from 1947 till 2005-06 had a higher per capita than India but now with each topic about economy and standard of living,they call we Pakistanis as poor and of low standard because somehow the average indian earns more than us and live better than us.

People of iran consider us poor pakistanis because of this.

So even today,the difference between the pashtuns of Pakistanis and Afghanistan is not this wide but with the phenomenon growth,the per capita income is growing of Pakistan especially the pashtuns,let say 15 years from now when our per capita will be atleast 5 times of the average from Afghanistan.Than you will know the difference in the attitude of a Pakistani toward Afghanistan.

Anyway 6Million Afghanistan pashtuns(55% of total Afghanistan pashtun population) are living along with us Pakistani Pashtuns for better and more safe future.

[Samandri]

Yep, Mahmud was an intellect who wrote history along with literature. Since your too concerned about what the british wrote you don't have time to read the books of the many Afghan historians out there. Your blog is nothing interesting, just old memoirs of what the British stationed in your land thought of Pashtuns and the tribes they encountered.



Since the Scythians were from south Afg, it matters to Pashtuns since they have been paired with them by many historians. Even farsiwan historians know Pashtuns better than your former masters.

He was a Journalist, thats what i know. Tell me the names of his books, what is his work on Pashtun history?

[Kushan Prince]

He was a Journalist, thats what i know. Tell me the names of his books, what is his work on Pashtun history?

I don't have the time to search for his books right now, maybe when i am free but since you are free right now you can.

Good luck.

[Samandri]

I don't have the time to search for his books right now, maybe when i am free but since you are free right now you can.

Good luck.

Hahaha gotcha. I was surprised when you mentioned Tarzai in the list of historians. I immediately knew you wont be able to name a single book .

Rabbit got caught in the trap again. lol


@Brown Skinned Savage

[Kushan Prince]

Hahaha gotcha. I was surprised when you mentioned Tarzai in the list of historians. I immediately knew you wont be able to name a single book .

Rabbit got caught in the trap again. lol


@Brown Skinned Savage

Tarzi himself is believed to have coined the word "Graveyard of empires" to refer to Afghanistan you moron lol. And Ghulam jan Tarzi is writing a book on the history of Afghanistan. No point in tagging your boyfriend Brown savage since he has been banned.

Tell me Farty, can you name me at least one non-british historian that talks about Pashtuns?

[Afghanfootball]

Tarzi himself is believed to have coined the word "Graveyard of empires" to refer to Afghanistan you moron lol. And Ghulam jan Tarzi is writing a book on the history of Afghanistan. No point in tagging your boyfriend Brown savage since he has been banned.

Tell me Farty, can you name me at least one non-british historian that talks about Pashtuns?

Mahmud Tarzi

http://www.barnesandnoble.com/mobile/w/mahmood-tarzi-dr-m-halim-tanwir/1113807863?ean=9781469146690&st=PLA&sid=BNB_DRS_Core+Shopping+Books_00000000&2sid=Google_&sourceId=PLGoP439&k_clickid=3x439&kpid=9781469146690

[Kushan Prince]

Mahmud Tarzi
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/mobile...=9781469146690

Thanks man, i knew about this book but was waiting for Farty to find it lol.