So why do you Pashtuns/Afghans hate Punjabis?

[RevolutionThroughReason]

څوک دئ؟ Killzai

د پاکستان په ملي اردو (فوج) کشې ډېر قومونه شته دي

Punjabis: 53.19%
Pashtuns: 21%
Sindhis: 13.5%
Kashmiris: 9.11%
Balochis: 3.2% .

Ta killzai ye dase tsok dai lol

we don't say fauj for Army, we say Lashkar, I guess you're speaking Peshawaari.

tsa mana dai chi domra Pakhtaneh pa pakistaniano lashkaro ki dee? Haghase mana chi pakhtaneh da pakistan depara cannon fodder dee. Kom punjabiyan wajhali dee pa da talibano sara jang?

[DSM0305]

I agree with most of your Post.But those countries disputes are very limited.Such as Kashmir is a small part when considered with respect to Pakistan and even more smaller when considered with respect to India.But in Afghanistan case they were claiming everything west of indus river as disputed territory,Just recently one general in Afghanistan claimed it again.

May be your right but i had heard it differently that after the agreement of durrandline in british india era,the pashtun fought against the british forces but no help came from Afghanistan side and was the reason they could not successfully secceed back into Afghanistan

After the creation of Pakistan,within less than a year,Pashtuns captured 37% of kashmir which even today pakistan hold and has a extremely strategic value for pakistan.

Well i had come across many sources claiming that Bacha khan didnt wanted to be part of Pakistan rather to remain with india but i have never come across a single source which claimed that bacha khan during the partition wanted to become part of Afghanistan.

Though i am sure if Pashtun majority region would have remained out of Pakistan and rather with india,the merger with Afghanistan was inevitable later.

From your post it seems you have no idea about the world and dispute amongst the different countries. So I leave it at that.

How you interpreted history is none of my business. If you wanna ignore some facts so it can suit you better then be my guest. Those Pashtuns who lived at that time is most likely dead anyway and the youth don't know the other side of the story.

Regarding the war against British then every historian or Pashtun will know that Pashtuns have never been one unity. Every tribe fought on its own. That what made it difficult for British because they didn't know who to negotiate with and was one of the main reason Britain lost huge amount troops in Afghanistan and other Pashtun areas. Pashtun was refereed to as Noble savages. No Pashtun any given time expected help from other tribes. To simplified it for you it was Tribal war against the British.

Whether you believe it or not, I couldn't care less to be honest. People in pashtunkhwa will interpret history different way so it doesn't look like they are the fault in division of Pashtuns. So basically I am not exactly expect you or other Pashtuns in Pakistan to believe it. I just responded because you brought it up. So I will end the discussion here.

[DSM0305]

You didn't offend me, you make me pity you, how desperate you are, you can't even see reality for what it is you live in a fantasy world where Pashtuns are 6000 years old, defeated Alexander the Great and are independent warriors who were never conquered and all come from the same ethnic origin.

You have an inferiority complex, and people who usually pride themselves on things like nationality, ethnicity, race etc. only do so because they have nothing of their own merit to take pride in. You're basically a Redneck, just like redneck's in America pride themselves about their race when everyone laughs at them for their ignorance and backwards thinking, The rest of the world laughs at you because you haven't evolved.

Trust me, the only offense you could muster is that people like you hold humanity back from evolving. Now go back to molesting boys dancing in your hujra. We have grown up things to discuss here.

It kinda sad to see how it effect people when they have been traumatized as children. It is okey RTR, everything will be okey

[1.4.18. Black & Gold]

pakwatan doesn't speak pashto lol

دا پښتون فورمز دئ، زه به پښتو کښې خبرې کوم

[Bost Bastan News]

People don´t hate Panjabis but people hate the military government dominated by some cruel, satanic and criminal Panjabis.

[1.4.18. Black & Gold]

Ta killzai ye dase tsok dai lol

we don't say fauj for Army, we say Lashkar, I guess you're speaking Peshawaari.

tsa mana dai chi domra Pakhtaneh pa pakistaniano lashkaro ki dee? Haghase mana chi pakhtaneh da pakistan depara cannon fodder dee. Kom punjabiyan wajhali dee pa da talibano sara jang?

يم Black & Gold نه یم، زه Killzai زه

لښکر، اردو او فوج يو شی دئ

ټول مسلمانان وژلی دي په جنګ کښې

[RevolutionThroughReason]

دا پښتون فورمز دئ، زه به پښتو کښې خبرې کوم

well it's Pashtun forums, not PASHTO forums, you can speak Pashto but when you're speaking Pashto to a Punjabi, it makes it seem like you're trying way too hard.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

It kinda sad to see how it effect people when they have been traumatized as children. It is okey RTR, everything will be okey

That's just your inferiority complexes' coping mechanism. Whatever helps you sleep better at night, maybe you can keep make believing Pashtuns are 6000 years old because they kept their language secret this whole time because they didn't write it down until suddenly they started doing so a few hundred years ago. Amazing. lol

[1.4.18. Black & Gold]

well it's pashtun forums, not pashto forums, you can speak pashto but when you're speaking pashto to a punjabi, it makes it seem like you're trying way too hard.

پرېږده سړيه، تاسو ټول په انګرېزي کښې غږېږئ نو دا څه رنګه پښتون فورمز دئ؟

[RevolutionThroughReason]

پرېږده سړيه، تاسو ټول په انګرېزي کښې غږېږئ نو دا څه رنګه پښتون فورمز دئ؟

easy because there are Pashtuns here lol

[1.4.18. Black & Gold]

easy because there are pashtuns here lol

هاها

زه انګرېزي ترجمان غواړم

[DSM0305]

That's just your inferiority complexes' coping mechanism. Whatever helps you sleep better at night, maybe you can keep make believing Pashtuns are 6000 years old because they kept their language secret this whole time because they didn't write it down until suddenly they started doing so a few hundred years ago. Amazing. lol

You can say whatever you want RTR jan, as long it helps your traumatized past. I wish you well with your past and your family

[1.4.18. Black & Gold]

[MENTION=8995]DSM0305[/MENTION] [MENTION=4934]RevolutionThroughReason[/MENTION]

وروڼو، جګړې مه کوئ

جنګ او جګړه د جاهلانو کار دئ

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

From your post it seems you have no idea about the world and dispute amongst the different countries. So I leave it at that.

How you interpreted history is none of my business. If you wanna ignore some facts so it can suit you better then be my guest. Those Pashtuns who lived at that time is most likely dead anyway and the youth don't know the other side of the story.

Regarding the war against British then every historian or Pashtun will know that Pashtuns have never been one unity. Every tribe fought on its own. That what made it difficult for British because they didn't know who to negotiate with and was one of the main reason Britain lost huge amount troops in Afghanistan and other Pashtun areas. Pashtun was refereed to as Noble savages. No Pashtun any given time expected help from other tribes. To simplified it for you it was Tribal war against the British.

Whether you believe it or not, I couldn't care less to be honest. People in pashtunkhwa will interpret history different way so it doesn't look like they are the fault in division of Pashtuns. So basically I am not exactly expect you or other Pashtuns in Pakistan to believe it. I just responded because you brought it up. So I will end the discussion here.

I am not ignoring the fact but the thing i do know is that Bacha khan rather wanted to stay with India.Not with Pakistan or Afghanistan.

And Pashtun within less than an year were ready to capture 37% of land in Kashmir.

Yes after the durrandline agreement in 1897 Pashtun did wanted to join back Afghanistan and had fought with the british forces but Help from Afghanistan didnt came.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Ta killzai ye dase tsok dai lol

we don't say fauj for Army, we say Lashkar, I guess you're speaking Peshawaari.

tsa mana dai chi domra Pakhtaneh pa pakistaniano lashkaro ki dee? Haghase mana chi pakhtaneh da pakistan depara cannon fodder dee. Kom punjabiyan wajhali dee pa da talibano sara jang?

Wah,troray oola,paise na pa razi

A simple Question.

Why would Pakistani army need pashtun recruit as cannon fodder?Can't they just recruit 21% more punjabis instead of recruiting pashtuns?

Well you should know in Pakistan the competition to get into army is as much higher as much it is to get into a Medical or engineering college.so the addition of 21% more punjabis into the army won't be a big deal for them.