Shia Islam for Dummies: Ask Those who Know

[Dreamer]

You posted hadith from a book you do not consider as authentic. So help us out? we are confused what to believe and what not to believe. And the book you are refering to, you say it refers to other shi'ite books. Which books?

Please help us. We want to learn from you.

again learn how 2 debate...

[شمله ور خراساني]

read it and ull find out wont u!

well, give us a full discription of this wonderful book so we can find it. Who is the author, who is the publisher? And most importantly, which shi'ite books does it refer to?

[Abu Hurayrah]

Yes, I want to learn also about Shi'ism, in particular your modern way of shi'ism.

[Dreamer]

modern shiaism? Wht were hz Salman al farsi? what was Hz miqdad?
What was Hz Abu dar? they were supporters (shia of ali)

[Dreamer]

Yes, I want to learn also about Shi'ism, in particular your modern way of shi'ism.

answer plz what was abu dar annoyed about?

[شمله ور خراساني]

no because u lack capacity 2 understand how 2 debate or 2 take in anything (other than whats approved by abdul wahab of course!)

well, let us not look at what ibn abdul wahhab approves, what do you approve for us so we can study it? which books do you consider as authentic and reliable sources?

[Abu Hurayrah]

No u didnt! psoting links is not refuting... btw Hz Abu Dar was annoyed at what?

It was a link to another topic on this forum (where I wrote the answer).

About the divorce issue, I gave you a Fatwa which explained it in detail.
About the Pen and Paper issue, I wrote you a reply on the other topic.
etc.

During the era of Uthman (ra), the Khawari-j where growing, and doing takfir on everything that moved and was alive. They killed Uthman (ra),The same people initiated the battle of Jamal later on, and after that, they fought against Ali (ra) in the battle of Nahrawaan. Later, two of them succeeded in killing Ali (ra).

[Dreamer]

nope... he was annoyed at caliph 3 nepotisim.... correct me if Im wrong but why did the ppl rise up againts the caliph if not 4 amongst other things his nepotism?

[شمله ور خراساني]

dreamer! are you there? Answer me please.

Haidar Bangash 2.0? maybe you can help us?

[Dreamer]

It was a link to another topic on this forum (where I wrote the answer).

About the divorce issue, I gave you a Fatwa which explained it in detail.
About the Pen and Paper issue, I wrote you a reply on the other topic.
etc.

During the era of Uthman (ra), the Khawari-j where growing, and doing takfir on everything that moved and was alive. They killed Uthman (ra),The same people initiated the battle of Jamal later on, and after that, they fought against Ali (ra) in the battle of Nahrawaan. Later, two of them succeeded in killing Ali (ra).

who was this fatwa from?

[Dreamer]

dreamer! are you there? Answer me please.

Haidar Bangash 2.0? maybe you can help us?

again learnb 2 debate... then talk... its pointless talking to an amoeba as urself

[Dreamer]

sangar who considers other sunnis as non sunnis! the ultimate authority in decalring whose sunni and who isnt!

[شمله ور خراساني]

again learnb 2 debate... then talk... its pointless talking to an amoeba as urself

why don't you answer my question? Should I also be evasive in order to become good in debating like yourself?

[شمله ور خراساني]

sangar who considers other sunnis as non sunnis! the ultimate authority in decalring whose sunni and who isnt!

but we are not here to discuss sunnis. We are here to learn about shi'ism.

[Dreamer]

didnt the khawrij form in Hz Alis caliphate? after the battle of siffan where Hz Ali fought against muawiyya.... why did Muawiyya go 2 war against hz Ali?