Can you be Pashtun & be an Atheist?

[khushal]

Great Britains is composed of multiple nations.
The English nation conquered the other nations.
Each nation(English, Welsh, Scotts, Irish) occupy different Islands & Corners of Great Britain.
They speak different languages & they ethnically different

They no longer speak different languages but they did at one time and they all speak English today, they have anglofied much like parts of Africa and parts of India but they all have different accents.

Pashtuns are Isolationists. If they weren't, they wouldn't have devided themselves as tribes. AAAAAzai, BBBBBzai, CCCCCzai etc....
There is none of this other countries, where people regularly move around & communicate with the rest of the nation.

People dont divide themselves up into tribes. Society starts as tribes and evolves to feudal and then industrial. You are too young and too uneducated to understand these things.

Also, Geographically it does make sense. Afghanistan discourages travel.
But things have changed thanks to cars & 4x4.
Not to mention, People in the USA speak with different accents of English depending in what area they live.
And English was already a well established language.

What are you talking about. Afghanistan have millions of nomads. People in paktia have always moved down to the peshwar valley in the winter time and then move back up in the summer. You dont know what your talking about.

[Damir9000]

They no longer speak different languages but they did at one time and they all speak English today, they have anglofied much like parts of Africa and parts of India but they all have different accents.


People dont divide themselves up into tribes. Society starts as tribes and evolves to feudal and then industrial. You are too young and too uneducated to understand these things.



What are you talking about. Afghanistan have millions of nomads. People in paktia have always moved down to the peshwar valley in the winter time and then move back up in the summer. You dont know what your talking about.

The Scotts, Welsh & Irish are slowly loosing their language to English.
But they aren't the same people.


I guess you do know more about Afghanistan than I do. But all I have said has comes from documentaries by people who done researches about it.
I am not making up these idea up myself.

[khushal]

you dont even have the basic knowledge of languages. You must read more scholarly work that is evidence based and not some dude that has an opinion.

[Damir9000]

you dont even have the basic knowledge of languages. You must read more scholarly work that is evidence based and not some dude that has an opinion.

Hey you don't have to rub it in. I already said you knew more than me.

Like I said, I heard it from researchers.

[khushal]

What researchers?

[Damir9000]

What researchers?

William Dalrymple & Rory Stewart.

[khushal]

Your claiming Those researchers said that afghans discourage travel. Show me where they said that?

[Damir9000]

Your claiming Those researchers said that afghans discourage travel. Show me where they said that?

By "Afghanistan discourages travel"

What I mean't to say was that the harsh climate and very rugged terrain prevents people from being able to freely move around the country.
As a consequence, It was much harder for people to move around in Afghanistan than it is now.
As result, people tend to stay in their home area. This essentially creates bubbles. The tribal areas in Pakistan is a similar case.

Members from my family agree with this.

[Damir9000]

Anyway, I would like to go back to topic of this thread.
Pashtun & Atheism.

[randolph85]

If you can be this and Pashtun, then you can be anything. Keep reaching for the stars, bro.

[Afghanfootball]

Can you be Pashtun & be an Atheist?
&
I would also like to know Muslim-Pashtuns' opionion on Atheist-Pashtuns.

Pashtuns did exist before Islam.

Lol your a troll.

[Damir9000]

If you can be this and Pashtun, then you can be anything. Keep reaching for the stars, bro.

Keep reaching for the stars?

[Damir9000]

Lol your a troll.

How am I a troll?

[khushal]

By "Afghanistan discourages travel"

What I mean't to say was that the harsh climate and very rugged terrain prevents people from being able to freely move around the country.
As a consequence, It was much harder for people to move around in Afghanistan than it is now.
As result, people tend to stay in their home area. This essentially creates bubbles. The tribal areas in Pakistan is a similar case.

Members from my family agree with this.

Who cares what you think, dumbshyt. Show me where your researchers said it.

[Damir9000]

Who cares what you think, dumbshyt. Show me where your researchers said it.

Go read their books & watchs their documentaries yourself.
Or ask your own family if they are educated.
I am not here to help you write a book.

Let's go back to the main topic which is : Pashtun & Atheism