My questions to Jana,

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Currently we are having more suicide bombers coming from your country into Khyber Pukhtunkhwa and killing my people here.

Majority of those are situated within Pashtunkhwa. Even the Major Afghan taliban command centres are in Pashtunkhwa. Haqqani crew is happily tucked in NW. So I am sorry you must be confusing things. (as usual).

[Shayesta]

Its such an unfortunate phrase when you guys just see ISI and forget the role of US, your own people in this war and the earlier one too.

The difference here is that USA hasn't got millions of Pukhtoons like Pakistan does and nor is it a Islamic nation, so therefore unlike you they ain't deceiving their motherland. But all you hear from Pakistanis when Afghans argue with them is, 'yeah but we are Muslim brothers'. We, Afghans, were Muslims even before you took birth sixty years ago. What happened to your brotherhood back then?

ISI is not alone responsible for that. You, we and US we all had started it so better accept the reality.

We do accept this reality, and also the reality that your country by far is not done yet interfering with us and this is a reality you and your type of people need to accept as well.

If US is so bad then why Karzai and his CO mostly includes criminals have become puppy of US?

Because for majority of Afghans, USA is the better option out of Taliban versus USA as they won't deceive in name of Islam, may it be in name of anything else.

Shifting blame on ISI is the easiest thing. But in all this blame game you everytime forget that Rabbani, Rasool Syyaf, Ahmad Shah Masood, Hikmatyar and the famous six and their thousands of supporters and fighters were Afghans.

And pretty much most of them trained by Pakistan, and if you call them terrorists now then what made you send them to us in first place? I can understand a Punjabi doing this but why would you as a Pukhtana support this?

For the same reason for which you are so worried if we ally with Taliban

And at the same time you even fight against those very same Taliban for Amriki Dollars. At least we don't fight and love India at the same time.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Shayesta, We simply ally with Taliban because its good for Afghans. We support Pashtuns.

If its not for us, Iran will make you all speak Farsi. We support Pashto. Taliban brought Pashto and made the capital a Pashtun province -- Kandahar.

Loll ye I mean strategic depth had nothing to do with it. Obviously North Waziristan and Orakzai agency is blooming in a renaissance of Pashto. I heard even the 20+ media channels in those areas are all in pashto. lolll please stop.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

Shayesta, We simply ally with Taliban because its good for Afghans. We support Pashtuns.

If its not for us, Iran will make you all speak Farsi. We support Pashto. Taliban brought Pashto and made the capital a Pashtun province -- Kandahar.

Dear Pakistani, if you want to promote the Pushto language in Kandahar then why isnt pushto the official spoken and written language in Pakthunkha, why is replaced with Urdu?

[Shayesta]

Shayesta, We simply ally with Taliban because its good for Afghans. We support Pashtuns.

WE DON'T WANT YOUR BARBARIC CREATION DAMN IT! If Taliban so good then why don't you send them to your Punjabi masters who might feed you with more than just Dhal if it makes them happy? And if you know what's good for us then you yourself wouldn't have been in this sh*t today, go and clean your own mess first will ya?

If its not for us, Iran will make you all speak Farsi. We support Pashto. Taliban brought Pashto and made the capital a Pashtun province -- Kandahar.

What else besides Pukhto did you bring? Oppression of women? Oppression of minorities? Oppression of freedom? Etical hatred? To hell with your help and if you care for Pukhto oh so much then go and make those few crore Pathan bhaiyo aur behno of yours in Karachi speak Pukhto and go and make your Pekhawris count in Pukhto first!

[MazloomyarMaseed]

Taliban was created by you Kandaharis.

Mr Urdu Nation, who was the Darul Islami Haqqania? who was Maulana Sami ul Haq, was he a Kandahari, was hamid gul and col imam from Kandahar????

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Taliban was created by you Kandaharis.

Ahh you are now trapping yourself in your web of tales. Come on Pakistani give it up.

[Shayesta]

^ Mullah Omar wasn't the creator of Taliban you Einstein, he is a leader. Just like how the British created you but Jinnah led you.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

Was Mullah Omar a Pakistani? Or a Kandahari?

Was Jinnah a Muslim or an Ismaili?

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Was Mullah Omar a Pakistani? Or a Kandahari?

Before Mullah umar there was Mullah burjan. Mullah Burjan was killed "mysteriously" (many believe it was ISI) a few kilometers from Kabul.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Guys, Taliban was something Afghans supported and still support.

You jump from one premise to the other. Maybe it is true, maybe it is false. At the end of the day, your credibility is so shot it is hard for anyone of us to take what you propose seriously.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

BLS,
Answer me this. How come Afghans did not do anything against the Taliban when they ruled them for 5-6 years?

You must have slept those years, because Afghanistan went to a civil war, where many sides were pit against each other. In the end taliban got the upper hand for a variety of reasons. They did bring peace that is true. That is not the issue. The issue is that their peace came at a cost, or rather the civil war and the proxy war played in Afghanistan came at a cost to the country. It lost many key institutions. Here is where you all don't get it. You are romanticizing the role and making it seem to be something it is not. Many times you have been caught contradicting yourself. The peace taliban brought to afghanistan, can be brought to Pashtunkhwa as well. It can be brought to panjab and sindh, but that means no basant, no urdu dramas, no ddamchorii, no more lovey dovey desi entertainment, etc. Long story short, your culture will cease to exist. If you can't stomach it yourself, don't expect Pashtuns/Afghans to tag along then. This mentality reminds me of die hard leftists in the west, who praise many communists, but wouldn't spend a day in such communist countries.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Jaana,
The Taliban is bad for you and good for us since you developed it? Just because ISI serves for your own purposes its a good thing?

loll supporting kashmiris is ok and legitimate, but giving armed support to balochis is obviously not good. It is ok to arm chechens and afghans in the 80s, but a sin to do so to the baloch. That is a double standard. This of course politically is not a problem (as nations and states go after their interests, sadly some pashtuns are defending a policy that goes counter to their nation), but when people proclaim to be put on pedestals, then it is important to bring them a few notches down.

[akbarkhan]

Currently we are having more suicide bombers coming from your country into Khyber Pukhtunkhwa and killing my people here.

Define terrorism.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

Jana, I am from Pakistan but I hate being known as a Pakistani. We were Afghans for 5thousand years and now you want to come here and force us to become Pakistanis? A country dominated by Punjabis who want to see Lahore developed yet Pashtunkhwa a desert? No Jaana. You have a lot of answering to do.

Afridi Roara

Not just this, Punjab has refused to do operation against its militants. This is clearly double standards and Pakistan only wants to save its Punjab.

Kind Regards