Message Of Felicitation Of The Esteemed Amir-Ul-Momineen On The Occasion Of Eid-Ul-F

[ScimitarXEdge]

You don't even know the guy ......he actually LIVES there sir.

[khushal]

You don't even know the guy ......he actually LIVES there sir.

I dont know him personally, but I know exactly what he is saying. Listen to his words. He values the autonomy more than anything else just like all the other tribesmen. He has said most tribesmen support the taliban because the taliban have respect for this autonomy.
When the tribesmen talk about Islam, they are talking about their freedom. When NATO talks about freedom, they are talking about the rule of law and central authority which in the tribesmen way of life is a contradiction.

He has exposed what I have been saying this whole time.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Taliban apologists debunked by a local

Allah Akbar

[khushal]

Exactly Bermal, the haqqanis use tribal conflicts for their own advantage.

This article explains the strategic significance of the Pashtun tribes, and then examines how the Haqqanis has been able to increase its influence in this tribal belt.

Haqqani Network Influence in Kurram and its Implications for Afghanistan | Combating Terrorism Center at West Point

[ScimitarXEdge]

Khushal, your "tribesmen theory" is not completely false, as there is severe ethnic tension in Paktika, especially Bermal and other multi-ethnic districts

.




Hmmm what he's saying sounds vastly different from this ....I do recall FALSE is the opposite in meaning to TRUTH.

He has said most tribesmen support the taliban because the taliban have respect for this autonomy.

[khushal]

Taliban apologists debunked by a local

Allah Akbar

What are you talking about. I am not an Taliban apologist. I dont agree with them.
My theory of conflict in Afghanistan has more to do with the independent nature of the tribes which makes sense to this local.
Your theory is Paki enslavement which does not make sense to anyone.

[khushal]

He said people in his tribe support both, your picking and choosing scimitar

you fail again

[ScimitarXEdge]

He said people in his tribe support both, your picking and choosing scimitar

you fail again

But you said that the rural people support the Taliban this shows that entirely true; which makes you whole statement false.

[khushal]

But you said that the rural people support the Taliban this shows that entirely true; which makes you whole statement false.

Its fact, many rural pashtuns agree with the taliban.
Why are Customary Pashtun Laws and Ethics Causes for Concern? | Center for Strategic and International Studies

[ScimitarXEdge]

many is not ALL though, you were implying it is a rural movement; if it was then all tribes would support them.

bermal exposed your claim

[khushal]

many is not ALL though, you were implying it is a rural movement; if it was then all tribes would support them.

bermal exposed your claim

I never said all.

no all tribes would not support them. the tribes have conflict with each other, what the taliban does is come in and broker peace with conflicting tribes in exchange for sanctuary and support to attack NATO forces which the tribes have no conflict with because they also have conflict with NATO and the afghan government. there is a mutual interest.

do you get it yet.

[ScimitarXEdge]

so basically the Taliban don't even have rural support for the most part;

yeah I get it.

[unknownprince]

^you have lost. L-O-S-T spells LOST

stop putting words in peoples mouths. So Khushal said ALL RURAL people support the Taliban -> BUT he never said that.

Now, go and proceed to change the GOAL post yet again.

[ScimitarXEdge]

you're brainwashed and deluded by Pakistani ISI...and live in denial

[ScimitarXEdge]

^you have lost. L-O-S-T spells LOST

stop putting words in peoples mouths. So Khushal said ALL RURAL people support the Taliban -> BUT he never said that.

Now, go and proceed to change the GOAL post yet again.

so basically you're admitting that there are Pashtun tribes from rural areas that oppose the Taliban

good .....that discredits the Talibs.....finally you exposed yourself