Who is more dangerous for Pashtuns: Tajiks or Panjabis

[Gulbabo]

Just by reading "Afghans" responses the enemy is Tajiks. Look how insecure Afghan Pashtuns get when someone says something about Tajikistani's.

Also, "Afghan" channels are exclusively Dari/Tajiki. I feel like am watching Iranian TV not an "Afghan". This i not a Pashtun problem, Afghanistan was suppose to be a Pashto speaking countries so Tajiki's should be speaking Pashto.

LOL @ tajikistani. please read some about Afghanistan, it will only do you benefit so that you don't end up making a fool of yourself like this. Afghanistan has had Dari speaking inhabitants for as long as it has had Pashto speaking ones. They are the true inhabitants of the land just like pashtoons are. Afghanistan, whether it was Khusaran, Ariana, or part of the big Persian empire, there has been people in that region that we call Afghanistan now, that spoke Dari as their primary language. They are as much Afghan citizen as any other Afghan. They are not Tajikistani. Tajikistani are those who are from Tajikistan and some 100 years ago have migrated to Afghanistan. those people are at a small minority. The rest of the Dari speaking are as original to the land as Pashtoons are. get your facts straight!.

stupidity, lack of knowledge, and ignorance can get you in a lot of trouble. its not healthy.

[ScimitarXEdge]

I'll tell yo what's damaging?

Tajnabis and Punjiks!!!

:O

*plays music* ..DUN DUN DUN

[ghundal]

and who us going to speak for all those Tajik parents who were forced in to marrying their daughters to the so called talibs??
I don't really want to get into this but if you people intend on going on a raping spree that you pay for the consequences and not innocent women and children en up fighting your war because I am sure the Uzbeks didn't just wake up one morning and decide to rape Pashtun women. Something lead to that.

None of what is said has any basis, and is not true.

Even when Taliban went to Mazar, they never targeted women and children.

Till this day, the reason their reach has extended throughout Afghanistan is because they do not target innocent civilians unlike the foreign aggressors.

Remember, the Taliban arose out of the chaos of the 90s, and have again risen due to the same reasons.

They are the only group that is bringing security and order to Afghanistan, and the international community is coming to terms with this (Turkey, India, Russia have come on board).

This also explains why the majority of Afghanistan is supporting them.

This is all factual.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Well, like they say, if you cant stomach it, then dont moan over it.

I am sure your Moral-code would be best suited to people who are similar to you. Plus, as I said before, I do not see you leaving the UK over the Mass scale of Liberalism so why shouldnt other Pashtuns enjoy it too.

because it's degeneracy and would make everything our ancestors fought for null ans void.

[Manzareh]

LOL where ? give me the ayat from quran ?? and what u mean about liberal ??? cuz the liberal i know is somethin away from what islam teaching us !!

stop saying non sense !! if u dont have prob with liberal s then dont say islam teaching us liberal .

Learn english and study the word liberal before you conclude that someone is speaking nonsense..

lib·er·al

   /ˈlɪbərəl, ˈlɪbrəl/ Show Spelled[lib-er-uhl, lib-ruhl] Show IPA
–adjective 1. favorable to progress or reform, as in political or religious affairs.





This isnt wahhabi saudi arabia we believe in forms of Liberalism (even that word is from the Latin liberalis, "of freedom") is the belief in the importance of liberty and equal rights.

[KingKhan]

Listen sweetheart, we have been living with these people for decades like we would with our own people. We are not going to abandon everything and declare a war on them because they don't pronounce things they we want them to or don't play our favorite music on television. If you are so concerned then get off of your ass and go produce better shows for Pashto audiences.
You are one to speak of insecurities
If you spend all your life in the bathroom of a buding, the bathroomof the building would be all you would know and want to protect. We hav people blowing our schools. Does that say anything to you?? There are far better things you could be worrying about at this moment thanthe evilnes of Tajiks for not playing your songs..

Are you serious?

Your country has been silently coup de tat by Tajiks. If they think like you then no wonder Pashto will be completely unneeded in Afg. I don't know where you got music from, am talking about their 20 channels that was suppose to be Afghan. I don't listen to music, am talking about dramas which are exclusively in Dari. Tajiks will slowly take over the government, and Pashtun will just have to live in South Tajikistan, while you just hang back and not say nothing.

[KingKhan]

LOL @ tajikistani. please read some about Afghanistan, it will only do you benefit so that you don't end up making a fool of yourself like this. Afghanistan has had Dari speaking inhabitants for as long as it has had Pashto speaking ones. They are the true inhabitants of the land just like pashtoons are. Afghanistan, whether it was Khusaran, Ariana, or part of the big Persian empire, there has been people in that region that we call Afghanistan now, that spoke Dari as their primary language. They are as much Afghan citizen as any other Afghan. They are not Tajikistani. Tajikistani are those who are from Tajikistan and some 100 years ago have migrated to Afghanistan. those people are at a small minority. The rest of the Dari speaking are as original to the land as Pashtoons are. get your facts straight!.

stupidity, lack of knowledge, and ignorance can get you in a lot of trouble. its not healthy.

Then Afghanistan cannot say they are the land of the Pashtuns, since it really is Farsiistan. Afghan cannot equal Pashtuns as Afghan means The majority Farsi people.

People want Loy Afghanistan, And look at Baluch, and KP, why? They should just include East Iran, and central Asia.

Arrogance, will get you killed. I could say something smart too.

[ScimitarXEdge]

LOL @ tajikistani. please read some about Afghanistan, it will only do you benefit so that you don't end up making a fool of yourself like this. Afghanistan has had Dari speaking inhabitants for as long as it has had Pashto speaking ones. They are the true inhabitants of the land just like pashtoons are. Afghanistan, whether it was Khusaran, Ariana, or part of the big Persian empire, there has been people in that region that we call Afghanistan now, that spoke Dari as their primary language. They are as much Afghan citizen as any other Afghan. They are not Tajikistani. Tajikistani are those who are from Tajikistan and some 100 years ago have migrated to Afghanistan. those people are at a small minority. The rest of the Dari speaking are as original to the land as Pashtoons are. get your facts straight!.

stupidity, lack of knowledge, and ignorance can get you in a lot of trouble. its not healthy.

That's not entirely true; although I find this obsessive and self contradictory ethnocentrism to be loathesome to say the least (yeah Tajik and Punjabis are threats to our culture ....but lets let Americans mold their whorish society with Pashtuns ...???)


Dari was originally a court language and linga franca between neighboring groups in Post-Abbasid era, the people who currently speak Dari was descendants of people that spoke other Indo-Iranian languages such as Soghdian, Tocharian, Khwarzemian. They only eventually adopted Dari as their tongue when the Mongol hordes exterminated most of their ancestors and demolished vast libraries of their books.

[ScimitarXEdge]

after a second reading, DZJ's justification for Tajiks/Uzbeks raping Pashtun women is a despicable scapegoat

Both Uzbeks and Tajiks in Afghanistan have given their daughters in abundance to Pashtuns, to appease the wants of the Mohmadzai Kings and rulers. There was no hoo and cry then. To say that it was the Taliban's fault as the cause of Pashtun women being raped by such people is a pathetic excuse.

[ScimitarXEdge]

by the way, my last comment does not support Pashtun ethnocentrism in anyway, flamboyant/extravagant names like "Hyper Nationalist, Insecure Ethnocentrist", doesn't cover up for the fact that the same individuals are more than willing to welcome faranagiyan and will even justify the rapes done by Farangis. They only wish to kiss white european tail, not defend Pashtuns, dont be fooled by labels, look at the substance first.

[IamDZJ]

Are you serious?

Your country has been silently coup de tat by Tajiks. If they think like you then no wonder Pashto will be completely unneeded in Afg. I don't know where you got music from, am talking about their 20 channels that was suppose to be Afghan. I don't listen to music, am talking about dramas which are exclusively in Dari. Tajiks will slowly take over the government, and Pashtun will just have to live in South Tajikistan, while you just hang back and not say nothing.

what the hell is wrong with you people? If a Pashtun took interest in putting his money down to provide his people with Pashto dramas, there would be plenty of those. Since no one gives a damn, there is none of that. They don't have Pashto dramas because acting is an abomination and the television set the devil according to Pashtuns. You don't ant your sister working in television why should a Tajik or Uzbek allow his sister to entertain you in Pashto?????
At this rate you are more likely to choke yourself and die in fear than Tajiks taking over Afghanistan.

[KingKhan]

what the hell is wrong with you people? If a Pashtun took interest in putting his money down to provide his people with Pashto dramas, there would be plenty of those. Since no one gives a damn, there is none of that. They don't have Pashto dramas because acting is an abomination and the television set the devil according to Pashtuns. You don't ant your sister working in television why should a Tajik or Uzbek allow his sister to entertain you in Pashto?????
At this rate you are more likely to choke yourself and die in fear than Tajiks taking over Afghanistan.

Am already dead, and Tajiks already took over Afghanistan. They also do have Pashto dramas filmed in Peshawer.

Forget the drama part, that's done. In the university the majority language being spoken and lectured is Dari, even in University of Jalalabad. You don't need to know Pashto to survive anywhere in Afghanistan, since they all understand Dari. This is how you slowly lose a country, and a language.

[ScimitarXEdge]

what the hell is wrong with you people? If a Pashtun took interest in putting his money down to provide his people with Pashto dramas, there would be plenty of those. Since no one gives a damn, there is none of that. They don't have Pashto dramas because acting is an abomination and the television set the devil according to Pashtuns. You don't ant your sister working in television why should a Tajik or Uzbek allow his sister to entertain you in Pashto?????
At this rate you are more likely to choke yourself and die in fear than Tajiks taking over Afghanistan.

your argument makes no sense; if a Pashtun doesnt want his women folk trotting around on TV like a courtesan in the Mughal court, why would people who do allow that suddenly make a gripe about whether their women are doing so in Pashto or not.;.

[Nokia_Apridy]

Haga MUNAFQANU Pata da TOPIC kha safa khakarey......

[KingKhan]

your argument makes no sense; if a Pashtun doesnt want his women folk trotting around on TV like a courtesan in the Mughal court, why would people who do allow that suddenly make a gripe about whether their women are doing so in Pashto or not.;.

That is what am saying in the sense of media. I find it funny how they are alot of Pashtuns on their TV who speak Dari, when it's suppose to be a Pashto majority nation. Should not a Dari speaker talk in Pashto? Or at least give it a try. Sometimes theirs a segment where everyone their are Pashtun but they all afe speaking Dari.