Who is more dangerous for Pashtuns: Tajiks or Panjabis

[Zemaryalai]

I want to take a survey on this topic.


Who is more dangerous for Pashtuns: Tajiks or Panjabis

[randolph85]

tajiks are weak and have not had historical animosity towards pashtuns. punjabis have been trying to derail peace among pashtuns since the creation of pakistan.

[emkhan]

In Afghanistan Tajik and in Pakistan Punjabis....

[IamDZJ]

how about everyone speaking for themselves?? i am not nor have i ever felt threatened by tajiks or punjabies.
some people have not only been scared to death by punjabies all their lives they also assume every other pashtun lives the same life of a dog as they do. may be if you didn't assume that you too would be treated like a human being.

[BarakzaiAbdali]

Neither as a whole in regard to the people themselves. Everyone is poor as crap just trying to survive. The Panjab and Tajik leadership though, in the forms of Mr. Spanta and Mr. Altaaf Hossein are equally dangerous. The conflicts between the people themselves are based on natural distrust that exists between different ethnic groups squeezed together into relatively close confines. What usually creates trouble is that the leadership will execute some sort of attack that will result in mass casulties on the other side (e.g. the initial assault on the Taliban at Mazar) and in response, the offended will execute brutal unwarranted retribution (when Taliban took Mazar).

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Neither. The issue isn`t the selective people, rather a state (Pakistan) on one hand and in the case of the northerners Northern Alliance. Other than that there shouldn`t be animosity towards others. As long as Pashtuns/Afghans can garner their peace and stability, we should opt for peace amongst all.

[emkhan]

yes we also have enemies among us.

[randolph85]

i must also say that afghans are their own worst enemy.

[khushal]

i must also say that afghans are their own worst enemy.

I thought that goes for everyone. Everyones worst enemy is him/herself.

The afghans enemy is foreign intervention. Take away foreign intervention and let the afghans fight it out so they can learn that fighting among each other solves nothing.

[randolph85]

its the foreigners who take advantage of afghans fighting each other. if we didn't have such differences, then no one could take advantage.

[Zemaryalai]

Since I have lived in Afghanistan for 6 years in the past decade, I view Tajiks a bigger threat to us. Anyone who has been there and has lived there for a bit knows what i'm talking (short vacations do not count). We might think Tajiks are weak because of their divisions on the surface but they are the most cohesive and united group in Afghanistan at this moment. Panjabis lack any cultural power over us and they are losing their panjabi identity too; Urdo is not a panjabi language but a language created for all muslims in the sub-continent. Tajiks thou have a much greater weapon which is their culture and they have even invaded the homes of our most ultra-nationalist Pashtuns (Ahady being one of them that speaks dari most of the time). They are in control of the media, the government and the opposition. Faim's power exceeds Karzai's power and anyone who has recently been to Kabul can clearly see Faim's power on Shahid Nader Khan's hill (Maranjaan). On top of the hill where Nader Khan's tomb is located there use to be a billboard with his picture but now Nader's picture has been replaced with Masood's on the hill which once was a symbol of Pashtun Nationalism. Certain users on this forum is misleading most of you by viewing these khourasanis or tajikists as a small group that operates in the west. Any Tajik who has influence or power today is surrounded by these people or have been converted to tajikism and they are the tajiks who control the media. Mandagar, Arman, Kabul weekly are all controlled by these tajiks and the same material that gets published in jawidan, khawaran and tajikam gets published in these papers. same can be said regarding the 20 dari-tajik TV stations and radios that has worse material on pashtuns than youtube and facebook combined.


to be contin.

[ghundal]

This is a battle between the weak corrupt foreign backed sold outs and the true, just, noble warrior of Afghanistan- a group that the international community has grudgingly respected, and realized these are the only people they will be talking to.

All these other clowns were part of the side show for the last decade.

[randolph85]

zem, so why not just blame pashtuns for not doing what tajiks in kabul have done? this is not a tajik threat, but a sign of pashtun weakness.

[ghundal]

Since I have lived in Afghanistan for 6 years in the past decade, I view Tajiks a bigger threat to us. Anyone who has been there and has lived there for a bit knows what i'm talking (short vacations do not count). We might think Tajiks are weak because of their divisions on the surface but they are the most cohesive and united group in Afghanistan at this moment. Panjabis lack any cultural power over us and they are losing their panjabi identity too; Urdo is not a panjabi language but a language created for all muslims in the sub-continent. Tajiks thou have a much greater weapon which is their culture and they have even invaded the homes of our most ultra-nationalist Pashtuns (Ahady being one of them that speaks dari most of the time). They are in control of the media, the government and the opposition. Faim's power exceeds Karzai's power and anyone who has recently been to Kabul can clearly see Faim's power on Shahid Nader Khan's hill (Maranjaan). On top of the hill where Nader Khan's tomb is located there use to be a billboard with his picture but now Nader's picture has been replaced with Masood's on the hill which once was a symbol of Pashtun Nationalism. Certain users on this forum is misleading most of you by viewing these khourasanis or tajikists as a small group that operates in the west. Any Tajik who has influence or power today is surrounded by these people or have been converted to tajikism and they are the tajiks who control the media. Mandagar, Arman, Kabul weekly are all controlled by these tajiks and the same material that gets published in jawidan, khawaran and tajikam gets published in these papers. same can be said regarding the 20 dari-tajik TV stations and radios that has worse material on pashtuns than youtube and facebook combined.


to be contin.

Since you have lived there, you must know the situation more, and your words have more credibility. The current government is obviously very anti-Muslim/ anti-Afghan/ and anti-Pashtun. This is this group of ex-pats, and those few treacherous souls they have got on board. the whole government is the enemy of the Afghan people, so regardless of who it is, they are traitors, and guilty of treason and sedition to the Afghan state for their anti-Muslim and anti-Afghan attitudes.

It is an illegitimate government. Any government supported by foreign aggressors are enemies of the Afghan nation.

[graveyardofempires]

this zamaryalai is full of BS ,pass on kiddo.
morons such as you are dangerous to our name and people.