Requesting member Catya Sher

[Roshina]

Aw c'mon, Barakzai! Catya and Baygham are incomparable. No, not in intellect-- I in fact think both are quite lacking in intellect--but in terms of the ambiguity we speak of. At least we know for a fact what Baygham's faith and race are. All we know of Catya is that 1) She's an American/western journalist whose poor soul is drowning in self-hatred, hating America and Americans like she's got nothing better to do in her life (but, yes, yes, I admit this is not professional of me to mention. Oh well), 2) She's herself a non-Muslim who ridicules and bashes non-orthodox Muslims (that is, anyone other than Sangar, UnknownPrince, and every once in a while GraveyardOfEmpires). Why point 2?

Rest, I think Wrayun has made it quite obvious what the purpose of his query is as well as the difference between Catya and the atheist "gang" of PF.

[Wrayun]

Wrayun, you're a very unbiased and rational guy. Thank you for being you. I forgive you for your anti-secularism thoughts, but I commend you for your honesty and fairness, for not taking sides at least in this matter. I mean, had you wished, you coulda just let the matter go, right? It's not like you're a secularist or another of those people Catya Jaan is always mocking and harassing and demanding they be banned. May you live forever in peace and safety. Sara zamung. Aameen.

I forgive you for your pro-secularism thoughts. Thanks for the kind words, they'll be used the next time against me to declare me a closet infidel. Oh my.......interestingly, it might come from a non-Pukhtoon, non-Muslim, Western journalist...hahahahahahahahahahahahaha

[Wrayun]

Really? Where? With me in all our exchanges, he has stated his adherence to a brand of Islam but refuses to delineate it. The same goes for Toramana.

I actually like Toramana wrorre and enjoy our little back and forths.. so I am not suggesting an online trial.

I am just pointing out I have not been able to find a single statement, except from Lawanaay Zalmaay that he is athiest.

No hard feelings... Im out because I got early rounds tomorrow. I hope the issue gets resolved, but I would say that if you are concerned about Catya's influence, I would need some evidence that she actually is capable of influencing anybody. No offense to her, but I generally gloss over her posts as they are ideological or opinionated.

Oh well, to each their own. Salamoona and good night.

Beradaar, if baygham is a Muslim, then I'm superman. lolll

[Fahd]

Beradaar, if baygham is a Muslim, then I'm superman. lolll

u sure ?
u called yday millions of muslims monfaiq !! calling muslims monfaiq's returne at u brainwashed mullah

[Wrayun]

u sure ?
u called yday millions of muslims monfaiq !! calling muslims monfaiq's returne at u brainwashed mullah

Football haram akhiiii!!! Watching men in shorts haram akhiii....kafffir sports taking you away from ibada haram akhhiii.....But you are Salafiya? So munafiqyaaa ;- )

hallelujah!!!!

[JAMALUDEEN]

Drama queens.

[faye]

that's the perfect response from a kool koala.

[JAMALUDEEN]

and still napping.. num num..

[Michin Khel]

Catya is our senior and respectable member of PF, i dont care if she doesnt reveal her full background.
Wrayun aka mokadar is on rampage

[Fahd]

Football haram akhiiii!!! Watching men in shorts haram akhiii....kafffir sports taking you away from ibada haram akhhiii.....But you are Salafiya? So munafiqyaaa ;- )

hallelujah!!!!

LOL give me one proof that football is haram ? watching men in shorts haram when u r a dirty mind :p
who said its taken me away from ibada !!

u wasting ur time on NET and share bad views about islam . and teach us islam LOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLL
why u dont tell us about ur self , how old r u , and where r u from ,and r u muslim or Secular ?sunni or shia or sufi or monfaiq :D
i dont know any thing about u else u r brainwashed mulla .


oh where did u study islam ? LOL

[salahuddin]

She is obviously admired by the Talib Supporters on Pashtunforums who sit in the West and spread their confusing tell tales.

Graveyardofempires could be her colleague, I have never met a Single Pashtun who says Taliban are fighting for Pashtun rights and are fighting for a Loy afghanistan, I think its a FBI cell, trying to lure us into this Islamic Fanaticism and then trap us.

I think she is yvvone ridley.

[graveyardofempires]

well well well
what do we have here,another jirga.

i rather respect a non pukhtun non muslim who doesnt disrespect our religion and our prophet than a Baygham type high on racial pride and anti religious crack.

catya has never been disrespectful even though we once had disagreement about the isi agent getting wacked.
as for Faye ,i must say faye is a million times better than "Pukhtuns" such as baygham.

one must understand we Pukhtane as muslims love our religion and love our prophet more than ourselves so putting pukhtun first to cover for someone like baygham is worthless effort.

Any way its better to have these jirga's

[graveyardofempires]

She is obviously admired by the Talib Supporters on Pashtunforums who sit in the West and spread their confusing tell tales.

Graveyardofempires could be her colleague, I have never met a Single Pashtun who says Taliban are fighting for Pashtun rights and are fighting for a Loy afghanistan, I think its a FBI cell, trying to lure us into this Islamic Fanaticism and then trap us.

I think she is yvvone ridley.

oh crap i forgot to mention you
but you came along and showd us your filthy anti intellect mind.

i dont think you have ever met a single Pukhtun in your whole life thats why you are always wrong.
in this case about me.

[salahuddin]

Seculars are a minority Roshina.

What you were trying to say is actually the other way around

Well, what the hell are you doing in a Secular Country where Majority of Muslims in the world prefer to live.

If Secularists are a Minority in the Muslim world, then why are your Talib brothers resort to suicide bombings and murder just to stop secularism?

UnknownPrince, you got some soul searching to do, your living a life of a hypocrite, and Allah does not love Hypocrites.

[salahuddin]

Football haram akhiiii!!! Watching men in shorts haram akhiii....kafffir sports taking you away from ibada haram akhhiii.....But you are Salafiya? So munafiqyaaa ;- )

hallelujah!!!!

did you know Fahds hero in Football is Ronaldo, Ronaldo drinks, goes to parties, dates girls, has lots of sex out of marriage, that is very harram. Plus he posed naked for Armani, and does modelling, which is haraam.

Wrayun, why do these guys live like hypocrites?