What constitutes a Muslim?

[Dust]

My friend, everyone would give you the above answer, for example, Mujib. Why is it that you are right and he is wrong? Why can't you just live and let live?

[khushal]

Your response is irrelevant to my question.

I am agreeing with you (for argument's sake) that it is man who has corrupted religion. Hence, this means that Hinduism or Buddhism are also correct, right?

I beleive Islam is right, and if I beleive islam is right, then I have to beleive that Hinduism and buhddaism is wrong. I dont beleive worshipping idols is rational. To me worshipping objects that man has made into some artistic form is ludicrous.

[شمله ور خراساني]

My friend, everyone would give you the above answer, for example, Mujib. Why is it that you are right and he is wrong? Why can't you just live and let live?

Mujib is wrong on some points. And he cannot produce any quranic verses to support his dogma neither does he have any ahadeeth to support them.

For example, Mujib and like would claim that we should not mention allah's attributes. Eventhough they are mentioned in quran. If you ask him why, he will tell you that because he is from afghanistan and people in afghanistan lean towards ash'ari creed, he is having this belief.

Likewise if you ask him how he prays, he will probably say that you should hold your hands on the lower part of your belly during the prayer. And if you ask him if he has any hadeeth about the prophet muhammad preforming the prayer as such, he will say that hadeeth is not necessary because in afghanistan people are hanafi. and hanafis pray like this, therefore it us not useful to rely on hadeeth because they are redundant in matters of jurisprudence.


Obviously I would disagree because I believe that if we aught to practice the religion, whe should solely rely on quran and authentic hadeeth. And not follow our respective community blindly. Because that is against the essence of Islam.

[Dust]

the overwhelming majority of people around the world are not muslims. Does that mean anything?

Do you know how silly you wahabis sound calling the rest of the Ummah who is more than 1,2 billion people for "non muslims".

My point exactly.

Pakhtun_Policy, what constitutes a Muslim?