If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
^everyone has thier own beliefs that doesnt mean thier not muslim
Hehehehehe..... ridiculous
Christians have their own beliefs so it DOES mean they are not Muslim. Hindus have their own bleiefs so it DOES mean they are not Muslims. Jews have their own beliefs so it Does mean they are not Muslim and in the same way Ahmadi or Qadiani have their own beliefs so it DOES they are not Muslims.
^lol but arent they muslims? all my ahmadiya freinds are, they pray and believe in one god the only difference is that they belive the last prophet was someone else
^as i said before everyone has thier own beliefs, people should just let them be!
lol @ the "he gave birth to himself part" haha
you are right everyone should have their own belief and they should also be pinpointed if they calim to be muslims while their actions and beliefs go against it.
shisha that difference is the problem
we muslims believe that Muhammad(pbuh)was the final prophet and massenger.
i wouldnt say your friends are bad people.
^i get what your saying and im not trying to take thier side or anything, im just saying that thier are so many different muslims in this world and many of them have different ways of intreperting islam.
i make no sense LOL
^lol but arent they muslims? all my ahmadiya freinds are, they pray and believe in one god the only difference is that they belive the last prophet was someone else
only believing in one god is not enough... believing in the last prophet and considering him as the last and final messenger is mandatory.
Hindus, christians, jews almost all believe in one god but believing in the last and final messenger makes the difference...
ok ok i get it but that doesnt mean they should be killed
They should not be killed in england or in america but in an islamic country their destiney is death because they are traitors... and if you bother and go and search any country's laws... so there you will find clearly that the punishment for a traitor is death only but islam is so flexible that it still gives an option of getting them exiled.
lol sis i understand the hadith : p
and i didnt say i know who are going to heaven or hell
i agree about some are sunnai by names or any thin lik that !!
lol @ closer !! its about follow he's sunna not be close to him by hurting ur self because what happend to ali !! and not be close by crying at propht Grave and pray to his Grave !!
and like u said qadyani is out of islam and thats clear !!
about motazila the Scholars are Divided some say they are kafir and some say no they are not or , who said they are kafir because of the wrong things they Extract by wrong understand !! by saying quran is Creature and dont belive of some of allah Attributes . also about other things . and who said no they they said because of the hadith i did said about 73sects and they are not in kafir because propht said they are my My community and thats why they said they are not kafir they are just (i dont know what the hell is the word in english :@ ) lol
but i will go with the first one becaus if they dont belive of some Attributes then they dont belive of thise Provisions of the attributes and thats kufr !!
lol u said somethin wrong about : ''I wouldn't be so sure of myself if I were you'' why ?
Did you know that hadith to which you are referring to, the last sermon given by the Holy prophet (pbuh) at Arafat, in its original format mentions two things that he is leaving behind 1) Quran 2) Itrati. It was later during the Abbasid's time that the hadith was changed to say Quran and "sunnah"...the word sunnah was not used until 200 years after the holy Prophet (peace be upon him) passed away.
3trati, the word meant by it was family, his linage...the children of the Holy Prophet peace be upon, whom the shia hold dearly to. I bet you don't even know what happened to the family of the prophet ...and how they were massacred by mawiyah and those who had sworn vengence against the Prophet's family.
If you actually go into the details and study the history...you won't be so sure of your self Fahd. Bottom line being...that what you call "sunnah" is not a concept posed by the prophet (pbuh) but later on.
Even the debate about the creation of the Quran is a lot more complex than you think.
Just think for a second...if no muslim were alive to recite the Quran, would the quran exist?
They should not be killed in england or in america but in an islamic country their destiney is death because they are traitors... and if you bother and go and search any country's laws... so there you will find clearly that the punishment for a traitor is death only but islam is so flexible that it still gives an option of getting them exiled.
i know that but by killing them in mosques or while thier at prayer is wrong the same thing goes for shias, their have been numerouse times where they have been killed and attacked while in congretion(prayer rite?)
i know that but by killing them in mosques or while thier at prayer is wrong the same thing goes for shias, their have been numerouse times where they have been killed and attacked while in congretion(prayer rite?)
dont call their worship places as mosques... yes they should not be killed in their worship places but they should also follow the laws of the country.
if they are not allowed to preach and practice their religion then they should not do that otherwise others can also break the law.
i have not said that... i say one should follow the laws of the country otherwise anybody can take the law in his hands...
every action has got a reaction... so simple law of univers
Comment