Identity Politics in Afghanistan: Nation-State or State-Nation?

[Firdousi]

Is that how you talk to your dad?
You are just a khar asani donkey.
Your iranic fascism crap doesn't mean anything to me.
Why do you want Pashtuns to be iranic people anyway? Does that give you satisfaction ,does it feed your inferiority complex.

kharasani.. wow, thats a original one. Never heard it before lol


You monkey, I DO NOT WANT PASHTUNS TO BE IRANIC. PASHTUNS ARE AN IRANIC ETHNIC GROUP. STOP MIXING OPINIONS WITH FACTS YOU LOW IQ DONKEY LOL

[Akbar]

kharasani.. wow, thats a original one. Never heard it before lol


You monkey, I DO NOT WANT PASHTUNS TO BE IRANIC. PASHTUNS ARE AN IRANIC ETHNIC GROUP. STOP MIXING OPINIONS WITH FACTS YOU LOW IQ DONKEY LOL

Your wish of Pashtuns being subgroup of your Persia is just a wish. We aren't or interested in your Iranian people theory.

All caps
I must have struck a nerve , you seem angry Mr donkistani
Khar asani.😄

[Firdousi]

Your wish of Pashtuns being subgroup of your Persia is just a wish. We aren't or interested in your Iranian people theory.

All caps
I must have struck a nerve , you seem angry Mr donkistani
Khar asani.😄

Dude, you are really very stupid. I dont mean to bring you down. But you are indeed embarrassing yourself. Repent yourself and try to educate yourself a bit. I can not understand how a person can be this ignorant and low IQ. Wow.

[Akbar]

Dude, you are really very stupid. I dont mean to bring you down. But you are indeed embarrassing yourself. Repent yourself and try to educate yourself a bit. I can not understand how a person can be this ignorant and low IQ. Wow.

You seem to be very angry now.
Calm down , not all of us are wanna be Iranian.
Gee this khar asani guy finds me ignorant because I don't support his anti Afghan agenda.

Why do you mention IQ so much? What is your IQ level?

[Akbar]

<<<<watch out we have an angry khar asani on our hands.

[jama0112]

As much as i don't like Firdousi and Ibliz, he's right about us being iranic. It's accepted, not only by persianate-cultured people(they're even trying to un-iranicfy us sometimes. Well, i care just as much about iranicness as you do though, so it doesn't really matter) but everyone else, everyone who don't have any kind of agenda towards us. But we're just classified as iranic by language, and ancestry(shared ancestry with tajiks, balochs, kurds etc). Nothing more, nothing less. It doesn't mean we're being persified by accepting being iranic. Hell, ossetians are iranic as well, but only by language. But they aren't considered iranian/persian at all.

You have to understand, no matter how much ******* these guys are, they aren't trying to insult you this time. But it doesn't make you more similiar to iranians, only a little. You're still pahstun and afghan. Hell, you don't even have to worry about it, because we never talk about iranicness at all in real life. Nobody cares.

[UnknownUser]

What if Afghanistan Was dissolved, at lease into a northern and Southern Half?

[UnknownUser]

While we are at IT Is like Pakistan to reunite with India. Pakistan should have never even existed if not for British Raj

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

kharasani.. wow, thats a original one. Never heard it before lol


You monkey, I DO NOT WANT PASHTUNS TO BE IRANIC. PASHTUNS ARE AN IRANIC ETHNIC GROUP. STOP MIXING OPINIONS WITH FACTS YOU LOW IQ DONKEY LOL

You nailed it on calling the Dunning-Krueger Effect.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

I'm not going to discuss this any further as I know what shirk is and what it is not and no where I used the word kafir.

You said he isn't a Muslim, when he's a Muslim, that's takfir. You don't need to use the word kaffir when what you're claiming he is carries the same meaning.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

Kalakani support was because the king was seen as someone who was behaving un Islamic. Nothing to do with ghilzai or durrani.

If that was the case, they would also have stayed and supported Nadir Shah, his successor, it was only the Mangals who joined Nadir Shah and turned against Kalakani. You need to read history and stop making up your own narrative.