Hazarewal Province

[RightWingPakhtun]

It's very simple, just merge Hazarawal province with Punjab.

It's a nice place, with greenery and good climate and peaceful. Abbotabad is the ****

[Elite Pakhtun]

It's very simple, just merge Hazarawal province with Punjab.

It's a nice place, with greenery and good climate and peaceful. Abbotabad is the ****

so why would you give that to Punjab, you obvious afghan.

[RightWingPakhtun]

so why would you give that to Punjab, you obvious afghan.

because the majority of those people are hindko-speaking.

sure, 20-30% of them might be Pashtuns in the tribal sense yet hindko-speaking (Swatis, Dilazaks), but i assure, the rest of the hindkowans are not pashtun even in the tribal sense. They are awans, gujjars, mughals, jats or rajput, therefore they can't be tribally pashtun also. Why have abbotabad be part of KPK if they are not Pashtuns?

i only have interests for a pure-Pashtun state, therefore i also insist for the cession of non-Pashtun lands of Afghanistan and rejoin with others like Hazarajat, Uzbekistan, Tajikstan and Iran, while at the same time, have Pashtun dominant areas of Pakistan to join Afghanistan. Sure, it may be land-locked but we can negotiate a bi-national state with Balochistan... If not that, then rename Afghanistan to The Islamic Republic of Khorasan , because Afghan only means Pashtun and it is misleading when non-Pashtun afghans pass themselves as being named Afghan. We all know how the word Afghan has lost it's meaning, and the dire-consequences a it shows for the identity of Pashtuns (like Pakistani Pashtuns being deprived of that name and going off as Pathan insead) . I'm here for ethnic integrity...

[RightWingPakhtun]

so why would you give that to Punjab, you obvious afghan.

or what else? Pashtunize all the non-Pashtun lands in AFghanistan and parts of Pakistan? By instilling a mass migration of Pashtuns and making everyone speak Pashto as their first language? I don't support this as the other ethnic groups are entitled to stay in their lands, though some people want it.

Well, this has already happened to an extent. Remember, Peshawar used to be a hindko-speaking majority city as late as the 1980's. Pashtuns had been present but had remained in the rural areas. Due to urbanization, i can say many cities of former NWFP(now KPK) have been Pashtunized due to Urban sprawl, with a steep decline of Hindko speakers, the hindu ones fled to india after the partition, and the rest probably moved to else-where in Pakistan.

and the Pakistani Media rarely talks about this, but they probably don't care

[a.s.takhar]

It's very simple, just merge Hazarawal province with Punjab.

It's a nice place, with greenery and good climate and peaceful. Abbotabad is the ****

Hazara area was never a Pashtun area. British added it to NWFP, they wanted a summer town with good weather which was Abbottabad. It is better to be merged with Punjab.

[RightWingPakhtun]

Hazara area was never a Pashtun area. British added it to NWFP, they wanted a summer town with good weather which was Abbottabad. It is better to be merged with Punjab.

it is sort of a complicated matter.

Think about KPK. North from the hindkowan/hazarawal area you have Kohistan, there be the dardic speaking kohistanis, whom also aren't pashto speakers, maybe some are tribally pashtun but they're dardic, so would you include them with KPK or Punjab?


plus, the term hazarawal makes no sense. Where does it come from? Do they not realize just by the name, they will get mistakaned for hazarajat hazaras?

[maneatinglizard]

so why would you give that to Punjab, you obvious afghan.

Obvious Afghan? lol it's Kanishka, the Indic who pretends to be a nationalist Pashtun.

What about him suggests he's an Afghan?

[RightWingPakhtun]

Obvious Afghan? lol it's Kanishka, the Indic who pretends to be a nationalist Pashtun.

What about him suggests he's an Afghan?

Was the other guy insisting that Loy AFghanistan secrelty plot to annex hazarawal region into Pashtunistan? Like come on, their plots to dismantle pakistan go's extreme, just to reduce it to a really narrow plot of land. I assure you that isn't the case. Bangladesh is just as big , if not half the side and it's doing just fine. Then they rumor that attock was supposed to be part KPK and not Punjab.

it's quite funny.... I've even seen Loy Afghanistan maps where they include northern areas and possibly azad kashmir. It's like a fest.


About me being Kanishka or a desi man wannabe Pashtun? No, i'm just a hardcore Pashtun nationalist, clearly from the Afghan Mellat... whoever that Kanishka guy is... and who are you ? Are you Pro-Pakistani Pashtun or an Anti-Pashtani Pashtun nationalist ? Moreover, some of you guys think i am killzai.....

[RightWingPakhtun]

Obvious Afghan? lol it's Kanishka, the Indic who pretends to be a nationalist Pashtun.

What about him suggests he's an Afghan?

I support the AFghan Mellat, look at my profile and my name. "RightWingPakhtun", we were a right wing party.

what is wrong with a non-Pashtun Indian dude pretending to be a Pashtun nationalist? He was supporting the opinions of the majority of the people on this forum ( Such as removing the durand line and Afghan Pashtuns annexing Pashtun parts of Pakistan into their lands). I mean really, is this Kanishka dude supporting something that go's against HIS ethnicity? The majority of Punjabi Pakistanis are AGAINST KPK and Balochistan seperating from Pakistan?

[RightWingPakhtun]

Obvious Afghan? lol it's Kanishka, the Indic who pretends to be a nationalist Pashtun.

What about him suggests he's an Afghan?

let me guess. That dude was bashing or thrashing or attacking Gul Khans on this forum?

then he keeps going to the point of cursing islam ?

well, i know you all dislike or hate them with a burning passion....

plus, i know alot of you pashtun nationalists disagree with islam also and blame it for radicalization of Pashtun youth, suicide bombings, and the destruction of Pashtun society, if the Artificial Durand line , erasure of Pashtun history wasn't enough....

[Elias]

let me guess. That dude was bashing or thrashing or attacking Gul Khans on this forum?

then he keeps going to the point of cursing islam ?

well, i know you all dislike or hate them with a burning passion....

plus, i know alot of you pashtun nationalists disagree with islam also and blame it for radicalization of Pashtun youth, suicide bombings, and the destruction of Pashtun society, if the Artificial Durand line , erasure of Pashtun history wasn't enough....

You aren’t Afghan but an Indian troll. Remember when I said Shah gul sounds better? Well that was a trap cause if you were Afghan you would have known that Shah gul is a females name but you assumed it was a males name and started using it.

Dave Chappelle - GOTCHA BITCH! - YouTube

[RightWingPakhtun]

You aren’t Afghan but an Indian troll. Remember when I said Shah gul sounds better? Well that was a trap cause if you were Afghan you would have known that Shah gul is a females name but you assumed it was a males name and started using it.

Dave Chappelle - GOTCHA BITCH! - YouTube

Exactly ! I am not Afghan ( i am afghan by ethnicity in the perspective of Pashtun nationalists but not by citizenship in the modern sense , because i am a Pashtun from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, well, my half of family has moved to islamabad and karachi more specifically .

Shah Gul is problably a persianized named which is why i wouldn't know since i never been there . And Bro, stop being sexist.....

Though i am not Afghani ( well i consider myself Afghani in the sence Afghan and Pashtun are one but not in the citizenship sense), ii support the Afghan Mellat because i like their philosophy compared with the sitting ducks Awami National Party. Mahmood Achakzai is cool too but i am supsicious of him, afghan mellat reflects my views hands down.

[RightWingPakhtun]

You aren’t Afghan but an Indian troll. Remember when I said Shah gul sounds better? Well that was a trap cause if you were Afghan you would have known that Shah gul is a females name but you assumed it was a males name and started using it.

Dave Chappelle - GOTCHA BITCH! - YouTube

you want to keep the terms masculine? Let's stick with Gul Shah

as with Gul Khan, we have Gul Shah....


man, stop ganging up on me guys. You know what, i'll just shut up for a while... like seriously, why you all angry at me ? You want Gul Khans from Defence.pk to infest this website and rename to "PathanForums" ?

[Elias]

Exactly ! I am not Afghan ( i am afghan by ethnicity in the perspective of Pashtun nationalists but not by citizenship in the modern sense , because i am a Pashtun from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, well, my half of family has moved to islamabad and karachi more specifically .

Shah Gul is problably a persianized named which is why i wouldn't know since i never been there . And Bro, stop being sexist.....

Though i am not Afghani ( well i consider myself Afghani in the sence Afghan and Pashtun are one but not in the citizenship sense), ii support the Afghan Mellat because i like their philosophy compared with the sitting ducks Awami National Party. Mahmood Achakzai is cool too but i am supsicious of him, afghan mellat reflects my views hands down.

Haha you know what? Shah gul is also a popular females name amongst Pashtuns, yes even amongst Pashtuns in Pakistan. Proves you aren’t neither Pashtun from KPK.

[RightWingPakhtun]

Haha you know what? Shah gul is also a popular females name amongst Pashtuns, yes even amongst Pashtuns in Pakistan. Proves you aren’t neither Pashtun from KPK.

well i dont know you.

it seems all have you guys had grown up.....

well, i have to call it quits and probably join some ex-muslim forum

Hardliner out