Destroy the myth

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

??

"Former US military commander Gen (R) David Petraeus has said that during his long association with his Pakistani counterparts and interaction with ISI as head of CIA, he could never find a convincing piece of evidence which supported the alleged double game by ISI or its explicit support to elements associated with terrorism."

Totally different time period, he wasn't an intelligence source during the period we speak of as far as you reference is concerned.

Pashto music is from India considering most of classical pashto singers are of mirasi caste.

1.) Irrelevant
2.) Pashtuns don't have a caste system

[Khostai]

This myth was destroyed a long time ago in Afghanistan. But its Pakis that still belive in this.

[asif86]

Most of Pakistanis mistake NA and Jamiat Islami.

Most pakistanis dont know anything about afghan demoghraphics.To them afghanistan is all about pashtuns and its leader according to pakistani pathans must also be pashtun.

[dawn]

Totally different time period, he wasn't an intelligence source during the period we speak of as far as you reference is concerned.



1.) Irrelevant
2.) Pashtuns don't have a caste system

Then why pashto singers are mirasis if there is no caste system?

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

Then why pashto singers are mirasis if there is no caste system?

You say this as if it's a universal fact; which it's not. If you mean the royal Kharabat in Kabul, they were classical musicians, who were trained in India, but not a "caste"

Either way irrelevant to anything we discussed here.

[dawn]

You say this as if it's a universal fact; which it's not. If you mean the royal Kharabat in Kabul, they were classical musicians, who were trained in India, but not a "caste"

Either way irrelevant to anything we discussed here.

I don't know who are kharabuts but classical pashto singers are all from mirasi caste. Singing and dancing is looked down upon in caste system.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

I don't know who are kharabuts but classical pashto singers are all from mirasi caste. Singing and dancing is looked down upon in caste system.

No such thing as Pashtun caste system.

[dawn]

No such thing as Pashtun caste system.

I don't know about afghanis but in Pakistan there is caste system, pathan being one such caste. And pashto singers are from mirashi caste.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

I don't know about afghanis but in Pakistan there is caste system, pathan being one such caste. And pashto singers are from mirashi caste.

Pathan are NOT a caste, they;'re an ethnic group. Pathan is what muck mouth Indics call Pashtuns.

[dawn]

Pathan are NOT a caste, they;'re an ethnic group. Pathan is what muck mouth Indics call Pashtuns.

Not really, pashto singers are mirasis but not of ethnic pathan caste. You being afghani don't know much about Pakistan.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

Not really, pashto singers are mirasis but not of ethnic pathan caste. You being afghani don't know much about Pakistan.

No such thing as caste among Pashtuns Tilla Jogian I've never even heard of mirasis, so hence it's not a Pashtun thing.

[dawn]

No such thing as caste among Pashtuns Tilla Jogian I've never even heard of mirasis, so hence it's not a Pashtun thing.

And? just because you never heard of one doesn't mean much. I don't expect you being from USA to know all about habshis and afghanis let alone Pakistan.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

And? just because you never heard of one doesn't mean much. I don't expect you being from USA to know all about habshis and afghanis let alone Pakistan.

This is from a self hating Indic that calls "Pathan" a caste and

[Elite Pakhtun]

I don't know about afghanis but in Pakistan there is caste system, pathan being one such caste. And pashto singers are from mirashi caste.

What stupidness. Pathan is a caste and pashto singers are another caste? A caste within a caste? "Pathan" is not a caste, you idiot.

[Porus]

Not really, pashto singers are mirasis but not of ethnic pathan caste. You being afghani don't know much about Pakistan.

My brain hurts.