Man-Made Laws vs. Shari'ah

[afghan]

Their personal opinion is not part of shariah. They did not make any mistakes in conveying the message and therefore they did not err in shariah.

Learn the distinction.

Speech and action of prophet Muhammad sal allahu alayhi wasalam are divided into different categories. You have know those before making such statements.

so then tell me which sharia has to be followed? saudis or the taliban's? sharia law has to be man made to be implemented.

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

so then tell me which sharia has to be followed? saudis or the taliban's? sharia law has to be man made to be implemented.

Usually, when ignorant people fail to produce a sensible come back, they resort to childish and immature comments like these ^.

[vinyard80]

Only humans can implement such punishments, no other species implements such things.

so the word "inhuman" is a misnomer.

Come on dude, please, you are a smart guy. Stop embarrassing yourself.

You know very well how barbaric those punishments are.

[vinyard80]

You are so funny guy. Many of your ancestors got raped by, Hellenic people and later by Arabs and moved here to Pashtun soil, don't act like you have done something great, because you have not. Be happy my ancestors let you live in peace and respected your language/culture without forcing anything in your mouth. This is what I hate with ungrateful sub humans. Like many minorities, they talk to much. Pashtuns are majority we let you live in peace, we don't want anything from you, just show respect to society, and your thanks is talking **** against us? If you are so happy with you persians iran, move to Iran. You think you have conquered Pashtunistan?

Arabs took whole Iraq. 90% are arabs and 70 % of Iranian looks like arabs. "persian" core army has always being build up by Pashtun warriors. When we got tired of you and didn't fought by your side, you got raped hard 2 times. Even many great mind came from Pashtun soil in your "history". I have nothing against our Iranian cousins, if they don't act, like they are those royalist like Koroush-e-Bozorg or Dariush-e-Bozorg. Because those families lines, moved away from Iran and settled in Pashtunistan from Arabs. Many has married to Pashtuns.

Bla, bla, bla, pure nationalist BS. Please provide sources. Historical sources. Patta Khazzana does not count, LOL

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Come on dude, please, you are a smart guy. Stop embarrassing yourself.

You know very well how barbaric those punishments are.

Thank you for acknowledging my intellect...and because of my intellect I know words like "inhuman" are emotional reactions. and have nothing to with intelligence.

You're just soft hearted, that's not very smart in nature, the feeble tend to get extinct.

[vinyard80]

Thank you for acknowledging my intellect...and because of my intellect I know words like "inhuman" are emotional reactions. and have nothing to with intelligence.

You're just soft hearted, that's not very smart in nature, the feeble tend to get extinct.

Great. Thank you for your kind words. I love you too xD

[Loy Afghanistan]

Bla, bla, bla, pure nationalist BS. Please provide sources. Historical sources. Patta Khazzana does not count, LOL

AHAHAHAH I AM favour of the whole Iranian race. Meaning I don't discriminate our Iranian brothers/sisters, neither Baloch, not even the poor Kurdish etc and I choice then over arabs, panj baboons, Mongolians and rest of the world. Please go ask any professor you want. Ask them, what happend to the most influenced rich "Persians" when Arabs invaded, he will tell you they moved and settled in today's AFGHANISTAN/PASHTUNISTAN. Allah is my witness, I don't lie. I asked a Iranian Ph.D.

I won't e-email a professor and waste my and his time again. But I give you a chance to proof me wrong. Do it and stop with blah blah blah. You coward.

[vinyard80]

AHAHAHAH I AM favour of the whole Iranian race. Meaning I don't discriminate our Iranian brothers/sisters, neither Baloch, not even the poor Kurdish etc and I choice then over arabs, panj baboons, Mongolians and rest of the world. Please go ask any professor you want. Ask them, what happend to the most influenced rich "Persians" when Arabs invaded, he will tell you they moved and settled in today's AFGHANISTAN/PASHTUNISTAN. Allah is my witness, I don't lie. I asked a Iranian Ph.D.

I won't e-email a professor and waste my and his time again. But I give you a chance to proof me wrong. Do it and stop with blah blah blah. You coward.

"Here, in this region (Khorasan), the language is Persian, and the kings of this realm are Persian kings."

Samanid edict. The History of Iran By Elton L. Daniel, pg. 74


Since afghanistan was created by brits in 1893 by durrand (actually even the name of khorasan was changed into afghanistan by elphistone. ahmad shah durrani never called to his empire "afghanistan") and there is no historical evidence about any pashtun presence in what used to be called sakastan-khorasan one thousand ago (actually according tarikh al hind by al biruni he calls to pashtun an indian tribe from solemain mountains lol) your statement is pure nationalist garbage.

Please prove wrong. You won't because you can't. You will just call me tajik b*stard just because I point out facts LOL

[Loy Afghanistan]

"Here, in this region (Khorasan), the language is Persian, and the kings of this realm are Persian kings."

Samanid edict. The History of Iran By Elton L. Daniel, pg. 74


Since afghanistan was created by brits in 1893 by durrand (actually even the name of khorasan was changed into afghanistan by elphistone. ahmad shah durrani never called to his empire "afghanistan") and there is no historical evidence about any pashtun presence in what used to be called sakastan-khorasan one thousand ago (actually according tarikh al hind by al biruni he calls to pashtun an indian tribe from solemain mountains lol) your statement is pure nationalist garbage.


Please prove wrong. You won't because you can't. You will just call me tajik b*stard just because I point out facts LOL

BAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA!! INDIAN. You are one funny guy!! Majority of you look like arabs. Pashtuns doesn't look like Arabs nor Indians. Anyway. It is pointless to argue now. In the future the our people tajiks, pashtuns, "persians" etc DNA tests will show the genes codes, compare to our ancestors grave 2000-3000 years old ones. I am very positive that you will eat your own words. If not, I will end my own family line. So, lets take it easy with history and origin for now. When there is DNA proof, there is no need for history books written by men with agenda.

[afghan]

Usually, when ignorant people fail to produce a sensible come back, they resort to childish and immature comments like these ^.

i know you are good in twisting hadis and interpretation of the quran. what difference would it make if i prove you wrong. i know what i am talking about. don't believe everything people write go back to the true primary source and spread what is right.

[vinyard80]

BAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA!! INDIAN. You are one funny guy!! Majority of you look like arabs. Pashtuns doesn't look like Arabs nor Indians. Anyway. It is pointless to argue now. In the future the our people tajiks, pashtuns, "persians" etc DNA tests will show the genes codes, compare to our ancestors grave 2000-3000 years old ones. I am very positive that you will eat your own words. If not, I will end my own family line. So, lets take it easy with history and origin for now. When there is DNA proof, there is no need for history books written by men with agenda.

So according to you al biruni had a secret agenda against pashtuns? man you are unique lmao xD


Al Beruni mentions the Afghans once (ed Sachau, I 208) saying that in the western mountains of India live various tribes of Afghans who extend to the neighbourhood of the Sindh (ie Indus) valley. Thus in the eleventh century when the Afghans are first mentioned, they are found occupying the Sulaiman Mountains now occupied by their descendents, the very tribes which the advocates of the exclusive claims of the Durannis will not admit to be true Afghans. Al Beruni no doubt also alludes to them in the passage (loc. Cit .p 199) where he says that rebellious savage races, tribes of Hindus, or akin to them inhabit the mountains which form the frontier of India towards the west


A Glossary Of The Tribes And Castes Of The Punjab And North-West Frontier Province Vol. 3 By H.A. Rose, Denzil Ibbetson Sir Published by Atlantic Publishers & Distributors, 1997 Page 211



So I look like an arab? How do you know that? You don't even know me. I met some tajiks with mongol features just like met many pashtuns with dravidian features but never met any tajik or pashtun with arab features.

Please do us that favor. End your family line. LOL

[Loy Afghanistan]

So according to you al biruni had a secret agenda against pashtuns? man you are unique lmao xD


Al Beruni mentions the Afghans once (ed Sachau, I 208) saying that in the western mountains of India live various tribes of Afghans who extend to the neighbourhood of the Sindh (ie Indus) valley. Thus in the eleventh century when the Afghans are first mentioned, they are found occupying the Sulaiman Mountains now occupied by their descendents, the very tribes which the advocates of the exclusive claims of the Durannis will not admit to be true Afghans. Al Beruni no doubt also alludes to them in the passage (loc. Cit .p 199) where he says that rebellious savage races, tribes of Hindus, or akin to them inhabit the mountains which form the frontier of India towards the west


A Glossary Of The Tribes And Castes Of The Punjab And North-West Frontier Province Vol. 3 By H.A. Rose, Denzil Ibbetson Sir Published by Atlantic Publishers & Distributors, 1997 Page 211



So I look like an arab? How do you know that? You don't even know me. I met some tajiks with mongol features just like met many pashtuns with dravidian features but never met any tajik or pashtun with arab features.

Please do us that favor. End your family line. LOL

you are afraid, that's why you bullschit so much. Like I said, shut up for now about this. We will see in the near future.

[vinyard80]

you are afraid, that's why you bullschit so much. Like I said, shut up for now about this. We will see in the near future.

So you can't provide any source nor prove me wrong. You just run away.

Your parents must be very proud of you.

[Loy Afghanistan]

So you can't provide any source nor prove me wrong. You just run away.

Your parents must be very proud of you.

I can proof to you, go to the genetics lab, take DNA test, compare to arabs, Iranian, Indians, and Pashtuns. see who you are most close to or if you are mix raced.

[vinyard80]

I can proof to you, go to the genetics lab, take DNA test, compare to arabs, Iranian, Indians, and Pashtuns. see who you are most close to or if you are mix raced.

Please prove us that you are not a half breed.