Dividing Afghanistan

[gadoonwal]

plus do not fall for information that is available on wikipedia.. Wikipedia is completly under control of farsiban.. tehy even claim that tajiks are majority in farah and badgahis?? see in badghais, the four fertile district with highest popultaion density are pashtuns.. how can anyone else be majority there??

i never follow the iranian wiki.
The iranian nationalists are day and night claiming on pashtun areas.
THat is fact pashtu was never the dominant language in badghez.
Pashtun migrated there.
Farah is majority pashtuns with 80% but there is strong farsi influence there.Pashtuns are also migrated there within the last few centuries.
The yazdi tajiks are the 2nd largest group in farah.
The main tribe in farah are norzai and alakozais.

[Tiger Khan]

i never follow the iranian wiki.
The iranian nationalists are day and night claiming on pashtun areas.
THat is fact pashtu was never the dominant language in badghez.
Pashtun migrated there.
Farah is majority pashtuns with 80% but there is strong farsi influence there.Pashtuns are also migrated there within the last few centuries.
The yazdi tajiks are the 2nd largest group in farah.
The main tribe in farah are norzai and alakozais.

ok.. so how did tajiks end up in Badghais? even wikipedia agrees that pashtuns are dominant in Murghab, Ghormach, Muqur and Jawand Districts. so that is four out of seven districts.. now some might say that these districts are not very heavily populated. .. Below is the agriculture map of the district and and you see that pashtun lives on the Murghab river.. (thanks to ex rulers of afghnaitsan), so then how are Tajiks majority,, ....
http://www.aims.org.af/services/sect...er/Badghis.pdf

Also Ab Kamri has a total population of 36,000.. so Qali Naw is very multi ethnic and has large AImak representation.. same goes for Qadis... but even if we count these districts as Purely Tajiks.. pashtuns still make a majority..

Finally, even western ethnic maps show the above mentioned districts as pashtun. do yuor research.. Western afghanistan is basically pashtun.. yet in the past may be it wasn't.. but now it is... in paksitan.. traditionaly, Battagram, Toorghar, Kohat, Lakki Marwat, Swat, Shangla, Swat, Malakand, Tank, Kulachi Tehsil, Ghazi Tehsile, Ogai Tehsil, etc ect were not pashtun but now they are as pashtun as any other pashtun areas..

[Kushan Prince]

ok.. so how did tajiks end up in Badghais? even wikipedia agrees that pashtuns are dominant in Murghab, Ghormach, Muqur and Jawand Districts. so that is four out of seven districts.. now some might say that these districts are not very heavily populated. .. Below is the agriculture map of the district and and you see that pashtun lives on the Murghab river.. (thanks to ex rulers of afghnaitsan), so then how are Tajiks majority,, ....
http://www.aims.org.af/services/sect...er/Badghis.pdf

Also Ab Kamri has a total population of 36,000.. so Qali Naw is very multi ethnic and has large AImak representation.. same goes for Qadis... but even if we count these districts as Purely Tajiks.. pashtuns still make a majority..

Finally, even western ethnic maps show the above mentioned districts as pashtun. do yuor research.. Western afghanistan is basically pashtun.. yet in the past may be it wasn't.. but now it is... in paksitan.. traditionaly, Battagram, Toorghar, Kohat, Lakki Marwat, Swat, Shangla, Swat, Malakand, Tank, Kulachi Tehsil, Ghazi Tehsile, Ogai Tehsil, etc ect were not pashtun but now they are as pashtun as any other pashtun areas..

Actually you got it the other way around. Western and northern Afghanistan today are not pashtun but they were in the past. The Pashto language itself has origins from Bactria (balkh)

[Tiger Khan]

Actually you got it the other way around. Western and northern Afghanistan today are not pashtun but they were in the past. The Pashto language itself has origins from Bactria (balkh)

well it depends on how far back in history you want to go.. but how things stand today.. western afghanistan is majority ethnic pashtun.. do the simple maths. farah and badghais is pashtun.. alot of pashtuns in herat as well.. how can western afghanistan be non- pashtun?,,

[randolph85]

hmm. i agree with you.. to a certain extent.. however, whats shocking is how closed afghanistani pashtuns are to other peoples comments..

its shocking to you that afghans are against a pakistani talking about the disintegration of their nation?

[Tiger Khan]

its shocking to you that afghans are against a pakistani talking about the disintegration of their nation?

well.. yes.. you might not agree with me (which is fine).. but that doesnot mean you get all pissed off,.. you should have the courage to listen and try understanding other peoples point of view..