What to do with pseudo-Pashtuns?

[Son of Mountains]

Have you ever checked a world map? Pakistan does exist. Its not artificial.

How is Pakistan substituting our identiy? Go to Pekhawar we even have universities that teach Pashto? Look wrora. this is not Pakistani forums or Hindu forums. This is Pashtun Forums and I am just as Pashtun as you are. What you mean what are you going to do with us?

Anyone who is against my motherland Pakistan is my enemy.

well said wrora
thanks

[Levanaye Zalmaye]

Have you ever checked a world map? Pakistan does exist. Its not artificial.

How is Pakistan substituting our identiy? Go to Pekhawar we even have universities that teach Pashto? Look wrora. this is not Pakistani forums or Hindu forums. This is Pashtun Forums and I am just as Pashtun as you are. What you mean what are you going to do with us?

Anyone who is against my motherland Pakistan is my enemy.

Khushal Khan Khattak would've had your head for this....

[Michin Khel]

There are some people here who down-play the importance of Pashtun identity and try to replace it with P*** identity? We all know Pakistan is an artificial entity and couldn't be a substitute for the 2000+ years of Pashtun identity.

What should this forum do with such people? Should these people be considered enemies? Are these people curable?

I request admin and moderators to lock this use-less thread.

This forum is for all pashtuns from all backgrounds of all ideologies but this person is trying to create an image of PF as it is only for his school of thought.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Sher Khan I already told you about the referendum, stop beating a dead horse. The referendum was fraudulent and boycotted. And to Pakistani, well there is nothing much to say about a confused person like him/her...they change their political stand like the seasons.

[Mayana]

I say we do this with them:

[Toramana]

i thought you were all "brothers" and every one was welcome.

Yes, but the brotherhood here is a Pashtun fraternity (Pashtun brotherhood). Moreover, we are brothers in humanity but have different interests and national aspirations. Those who are working against Pashtun interests are to be considered enemies as long as they don't give up their animosity towards Pashtuns.

[Son of Mountains]

Yes, but the brotherhood here is a Pashtun fraternity (Pashtun brotherhood). Moreover, we are brothers in humanity but have different interests and national aspirations. Those who are working against Pashtun interests are to be considered enemies as long as they don't give up their animosity towards Pashtuns.

Pashtuns living in different areas have different interests. I suspect you meant the interests of Nationalists of some kinds.
So u have no right to generalize it with all pashtuns.
Millions of pashtuns have some different interests that are living in Pakistan. Keep in Mind

[Son of Mountains]

I request admin and moderators to lock this use-less thread.

This forum is for all pashtuns from all backgrounds of all ideologies but this person is trying to create an image of PF as it is only for his school of thought.

well said
Its PashtunForum....For Pashtuns either live in Afghankhwa or Pashtunkhwa.....either they support pakistan or not.
But people try to make it Afghanistani forum
Admin should take notice for this thread plz

[r3alist]

its what can happen when you try and create such a purist ideology when that homogeneity does not exist, people within the wider group end up arguing with one another saying "no, i am the real pashtun and you are an imposter"

[Son of Mountains]

why are people crying to lock this topic?

this is a good thread to expose how weak your love is for a state. Toramana raised a good point if you think about it, Pashtuns of Pakistan are mainly working for our division. (govt officials)

who here thinks ISI wants to see Pashtuns unified?

ISI itself contains maximum number of Pashtuns.....congratulations to all so called Nationalist afgans!!!

[BLS_1919v2.0]

I would love if someone can give me proof of these numbers of Pashtuns in ISI. I hope it is not the statistic like the one where people say "Balochis all love Pakistan" or "Pashtuns make 40 % of the army..".

[Michin Khel]

why are people crying to lock this topic?

this is a good thread to expose how weak your love is for a state. Toramana raised a good point if you think about it, Pashtuns of Pakistan are mainly working for our division. (govt officials)

who here thinks ISI wants to see Pashtuns unified?

What the hell is pseudo-pashtun and how he has become an authority to determine who is real Pashtun?

If your thinking about Pakistani Pashtuns is that they are working for division of Pashtuns....................then you are wrong. They are not working or bothered about division or unity of pashtuns.....their point of focus is Roti, Kaprra aur Makaan.

My father is a school teacher in governament school, a servant of pakistani governament. Now wonder if he is a traitor and pseudo-pashtun in your eyes?

[Michin Khel]

Luffy, What they are talking about is ISI Pashtuns in Pakistan. Those who serve for the ISI are traitors, do you agree?

Does ISI work for Pashtun unity luffy?

ISI is small institute and i highly doubt that there will be so many pashtuns in it. Our brother "handsomePashtun" is labelling all Pashtuns governament servants as traitors and he thinks that they are specifically working for division of Pashtuns......

I dont know much about ISI and its functions. I also dont know how many Pashtuns are in it and what kind of work they do so dont expect from me to issue ISI this and ISI that statements.

[Michin Khel]

[

ISI is not a small institute, Its a powerful Spy agency that wants to see our land destabilized.

From your opinion, Do you think ISI cares about Pashtuns? you live in Pakistan right?

Dear jasmine i have already shared my views about ISI with you.

.

I dont know much about ISI and its functions. I also dont know how many Pashtuns are in it and what kind of work they do so dont expect from me to issue ISI this and ISI that statements.

That is i lack sufficient knowledge about ISI so i cant assume things about it.

[Toramana]

Point being?

اصل پښتون څوک به وي؟
کم پښتون چی یوازې په پښتونستان کښی ژوند لري؟

Who decides who is pseudo and who is real?

The ctiteria for being a Pashtun is very clear that must be obvious to every genuine Pashtun. Only those are to be considered Pashtuns who are born of Pashto-speaking parents, are native speakers of Pashto, consider Pashto to be the first, foremost, and primary identity of Pashtuns, have unwavering belief in the right of self-determination to Pashtuns and show/do practical support/activism for it, and above all, in no way do things that are against the political unity of Pashtuns or perpetuate political division of Pashtuns and/or Pashtun land.

The rest all, including those who are not even Pashto speakers, is just junk worth throwing in garbage-bin.