Why can't our countries be like this ????

[Khostai]

As long as fanatics (Ikhwanis/Wahabis/Salafis) are there this dream would not come true---The first thing is, how to put this jinni in the bottle-

Hmm, you are right, thats the dificult part, maybe by catching all the leaders of those biatches would help.....

[Afghanistan2010]

It just suits your highness,mr munapiq.

[ډګروال]

oh now playing faisha game ? not saying what you mean , and not meaning what you say ????

you fell very smart ?

doesnt matter if you continue to behave like a faisha i will just treat you just like one ...

munapiq jana
you may adress people at home like that but this isnt your home.
behave yourself.

[SiiNii]

Men will always create war. Just look at our world leaders. Most are men and they left this world in a bloody mess.

The map Musa has posted is nothing but a fantasy. which country would willingly give away*an area close to the harbour or filled with natural resources?

Men will always fight just as women will always bear children, that is the way of our species.

[Tjanaparh]

Pamirians and Karakalpaks have been forgotten by Your map, same to Tajiks from Samarkand and Bukhara.

to me, I realize the importance of union among nations divedid by borders. But I would rather support Khushals idea, union can be done by unification instead od division, by respect to eachother and more economical and governmental union but more cultural freedom. Why actually not?

[Afghanistan2010]

sorry son my father taught me to say what i mean and to mean what i say , i am not a shia mutah taqqia one like you .besides i come from a respectable and known family , i dont know out of which chauk you come

who play irony and sarkasm or plays with words which he dont mean like this.... only very sust faisha like you and you bacha boyfriend do so ...

calling others munafiq but playing irony and sarkasm , not knowing a real muslim is not suppossed to do such things ...

but as i said selfproclaimed salafis are not muslims , they are KAFIRS

What family is this,you don't know your tribe......you don't know pashtun traditions.

[abassinafghan]

how predictable

typical munapiq
the way you talk here looks like you come from a faisha family thats why this word is stuck on your tongue,maybe because this is how you adress your family members.
i dont need to adress you seriously ,my one word does the job.
btw your father should have taught you how to not be a munapiq.

If you live in europe i am more than willing to give you a and you arab salafi brothers you certainly share the same mother , a lesson which will let you mom moura. .

I know you are a broke loser tell me a place and a time i will be more than happy to bring you to a u.k based paki adira .

[ډګروال]

If you live in europe i am more than willing to give you a and you arab salafi brothers you certainly share the same mother , a lesson which will let you mom moura. .

I know you are a broke loser tell me a place and a time i will be more than happy to bring you to a u.k based paki adira .

we have already been through this and you coward out like the coward you are.
da spey zwaya mor pesey khaberey me kawa,da mordagaw nasla.
ta dey sirf ekhpel asley noem wewaya da mordagaw zoya.

[pashtanajan]

they all hate Pashtuns and see themself as supirior to us they even call us dravidians -_- and themself arian.

I've never come across an Iranian whose called me a Dravidian, mainly because most aren't aware of the word. The only Persians I've come across who hate Pashtuns are wannabe KKK teenagers on the internet, who have nothing better to do with their lives. I have many great Iranian friends, and we share many cultural similarities. However, combining all of those countries would be a stupid. We all may share genetic similarities, but we've branched out into our own little groups by now – we can't have another 'Persian Empire' so to say. It failed eventually and it'll fail again. There'll just be far too many different ethnicities living under one roof = more drama.

[Khostai]

I've never come across an Iranian whose called me a Dravidian, mainly because most aren't aware of the word. The only Persians I've come across who hate Pashtuns are wannabe KKK teenagers on the internet, who have nothing better to do with their lives. I have many great Iranian friends, and we share many cultural similarities. However, combining all of those countries would be a stupid. We all may share genetic similarities, but we've branched out into our own little groups by now – we can't have another 'Persian Empire' so to say. It failed eventually and it'll fail again. There'll just be far too many different ethnicities living under one roof = more drama.

I guess you met only girls, most of the time its the men/boys who talk about arianism and race and that sort of noncense.
But you are right they are not all like that, but there is a significant portion of the population who feels superior and who will force Farsi and "persian culture" on others if we would have lived in one country.
There is no singnal country were all the peopel think a like, but you must look at the part of the population who has influence and power and how they think, and looking at Iran and its ruling elite, than you can be assured that those once are not that friendly towards others.....

[Al-Hindustani]

It's pretty obvious, just make countries based off of this map, its so easy ! We should for once make nation states -_-, and i'll post this on Afghan and Pakistani forums.

In regards to "Punjabistan", I really can't see such an entity ever existing. Creating countries based on ethnicity might work in the case of Pashtunistan and Balochistan because both groups of people follow the same religion and traditions.

That's not the case for Punjab. There are Hindu Punjabis, Sikh Punjabis, and Muslim Punjabis. Case in point: after the partition of 1947 the Indian part of Punjab was divided into the states of Himachal, Punjab, and Haryana because the Sikhs desired a state in which they were the majority.

Just my 2 cents.

[Afghanimusici]

It's pretty obvious, just make countries based off of this map, its so easy ! We should for once make nation states -_-, and i'll post this on Afghan and Pakistani forums.

Musa khan have you made the map by yourself?
if you did change the name of pathanistan in afghanistan
Afghan=Pashtun Pashtun= Afghan Afghan is a very old name for pashtuns because we are descendant of Afghana grandson of King Saul.
Only pashtuns were and are reffered as afghan
for example when you say to a westerner: Can you describe a Afghan they will say they have beards and has a weird woolen hat ( pakol) and some of them have weird turbans with a 'tail' on it (Lungee)