The case for Pakhtunkhwa

[Master Khan]

Bas kai please, its not nice celebrating innocents peoples death no matter if they are Punjabies, Pashtuns etc.
people die in the attack are someones mother, father, sister etc and we shouldn't be happy it about because at the end of the day innocent muslim people die.

[Talal]

Really? I am a member on largest Afghan Forum on internet and I can't remember Pukhtoons of Afghanistan showed hatred towards of Pakistan? Some people try to fuel things up but majority of Pukhtoons have ALWAYS defended Pakistani Pukhtoons, and some even defend Pakistan. Stop lying to yourself.


And you think no Pakistani will ever say this on their Forums? I remember I went through this Pakistani Forum which was for Pakistani's in Holland and two Pukhtoons were arguing where especially one Punjabi kept insulting Afghans and Pukhtoons. I even saw some Pakistani's write whenever a bomb-blast was there in Afghanistan; 'Oh, only ten people died?' There we go, sort these people out first. And in Afghanistan way less languages is being spoken compared to Pakistan so if language was the case then Pakistani Army wouldn't have been tagged as strong.

No we dont even when our country is being bombed by TTP that are fully supported by elements within Afghanistan we still dont hold any grudge against Afghans, if it wasnt for this forum id never have known any good people from across the border. The example i quoted wasnt of one guy the entire forum was like that, not one person there had the decency to say "rest in peace" instead they all looked like eid had come early this year for them. You are no better, absolutely no substance you make up stuff that defies both logic and reality

[pir_Rokhan]

TTP is the brainchild of ISI which after being double crossed by Musharraf in 2001 has fired back.When Pakistani military and agencies were killing the innocent afghans and pashtuns at their hands they were good and now when they have attacked Lahore then shahbaz sharif had to ask beg them to spare Punjab.What a muslim brotherhood? You dig the wells for others and when you fall in it then you lament.So do good to have good.

[Niazi]

I think this renaming crap went tits up ,there are few Panjabes live in some part of NWFP are up in arm to keep the old name ,I mean fair play to those gutsy Panjabes in Hazara at least they got the ball to show ball less Pakhtons thier middle finger .oops so much for parting and celebreting,after 65 years of begging of Panjabes for name change ,when they got half decent name now they have to lose a chunk of thier province .

[Son of Mountains]

^ i believe, there r working some negative forces in Hazara. PML-N is also involved in this rubbish. Otherwise, Hindkowans are not bad people, but now are being played in others' hands.

[Dinosaur Khan]

Yes PML-N has played game with ANP who betrayed us by bowing to their demands. PML-N on purpose did'not give name of hazara with pakhtunkhwa so that hazara would rise against ANP. while PML-Q is practically raising violence in hazara.

We Pashtuns should take care of our minorities & listen to their demands, believe me hazarywals are not bad people.

[Dinosaur Khan]

^I mean they should have their own province.

[Watanpal]

ارواښاد ډاکټر نجيب الله به وييل چې پنجابۍ دير مکار دی او مونږه له يې زمونږه خپل لاس په خله رامنډلی دی نه يې چيچلی شو او نه يې ايستلی شو. چوهدريانو نوی لوبه شروع کړه او زمونږه خپل لاس يې يو وار بيا زمونږه په خله راومنډلو. اوس بايد پښتانه خپله غوښتنه د پاکستان د چوکا ټ نه بهر اوباسي او د ازاد پښتونستان غوښتنه وکړي

[BLS_1919v2.0]

ارواښاد ډاکټر نجيب الله به وييل چې پنجابۍ دير مکار دی او مونږه له يې زمونږه خپل لاس په خله رامنډلی دی نه يې چيچلی شو او نه يې ايستلی شو. چوهدريانو نوی لوبه شروع کړه او زمونږه خپل لاس يې يو وار بيا زمونږه په خله راومنډلو. اوس بايد پښتانه خپله غوښتنه د پاکستان د چوکا ټ نه بهر اوباسي او د ازاد پښتونستان غوښتنه وکړي

Saiba dagha tolanae kae ao daasae ddero tolanae kae daasae pakhtaana dder dee che da pakistna/panjab khabrae raa makhae tha kaee...ao da Pakhtano bae ittepaqee bandae khushaala dee.

[Talal]

Yes PML-N has played game with ANP who betrayed us by bowing to their demands. PML-N on purpose did'not give name of hazara with pakhtunkhwa so that hazara would rise against ANP. while PML-Q is practically raising violence in hazara.

We Pashtuns should take care of our minorities & listen to their demands, believe me hazarywals are not bad people.

This is what one of my friends told me about people from hazaara and how off all the ethnicities in Pakistan they are the most patriotic ones.

This was in england

"Several years ago Afghan Hazara had settled in the city and started renting a hall along with sporting facilities for their own community. They invited the Hazara from the Pakistani community to join them yet surprising they rejected their calls and stayed with our mosque based on nationality."

[khyaal]

This is what one of my friends told me about people from hazaara and how off all the ethnicities in Pakistan they are the most patriotic ones.

This was in england

"Several years ago Afghan Hazara had settled in the city and started renting a hall along with sporting facilities for their own community. They invited the Hazara from the Pakistani community to join them yet surprising they rejected their calls and stayed with our mosque based on nationality."

So democracy is just an ambiguous term? It can be twisted either way?

[Talal]

So democracy is just an ambiguous term? It can be twisted either way?

In a democracy 51% of the population controls 49% of the population. Thats what democracy is, Pashtuns have a right to Pakhtunkwha but if the haazara/hunza people feel like its injustice to them, they have a right to voice they're opinions and it is GoP's duty that it caters to their needs

[khyaal]

In a democracy 51% of the population controls 49% of the population. Thats what democracy is, Pashtuns have a right to Pakhtunkwha but if the haazara/hunza people feel like its injustice to them, they have a right to voice they're opinions and it is GoP's duty that it caters to their needs

But then why don't they listen to Baloch?

[Talal]

But then why don't they listen to Baloch?

They do i have thread here somewhere on how much money they're putting into the development projects in that province. And that is the demand of the baloch majority there. Unfortunately due to the centre policies and the wadera culture, Balochistan has suffered a lot. But they are turning the tide now, Balochistan will see a brighter tommorrow inshallah

[khyaal]

They do i have thread here somewhere on how much money they're putting into the development projects in that province. And that is the demand of the baloch majority there. Unfortunately due to the centre policies and the wadera culture, Balochistan has suffered a lot. But they are turning the tide now, Balochistan will see a brighter tommorrow inshallah

But it is a fact that most of the waderas are with the establishment. Only khair Bux Marri, Ata ullah Mengal and one or two othersa are fighting for the rights of Baloch people.