Amirul Mumineen Mullah Omar Mujahid (hafidhahullah) tells his lifestory in his own vo

[Amir al Ghaznavi]

the islamic emirate of afghanistan had an opportunity, the opportunity of a life a time, to start over fresh, to build a new nation, and instead they delivered the pashtuns to the greatest calamity it has ever witnessed

[JAMALUDEEN]

To be honest, I have no respect for this man.....

[Al Hanif]

To be honest, I have no respect for this man.....

Salam. Can you explain why ? I want to hear all opinions but I want arguments.

What did he do ? And what do you think he should have done instead ?

[Afghanistan2010]

^You have some points, Afghanistan was in ruins, in his rule Afghanistan still was in ruins, you didn't even had any telephones, for one call peopel where going to Pakistan, can you belive that, in one whole country you could not even call someone :S
And why would you blow up a statue? Why did he do such barbaric act? It was our heritage, Do you see Indonesian muslims blowing up there old tempels? NO, do you se Egyptians blowing up the sfinx? NO do you see Pakis blowing up there old budhas statue? NO But he did, and that to me is a proof that he is a brainles monkey of Pakis and arabs whabist, he is a coward and ruined our country.
Oke so lets forget the statue, what about his stupid laws of baning music, television and girls education. And to say that it was for there safty is bulschit, if you can't protect your women than your have failed as a leader. He had no economic plans or any other to rebuild the country.
Mullah Omar= Epic fail
He failed as a muslim
He Failed as a pashtun
He failed as a human being

Provide sources if he ever gave a fatawaa or interduced a law regarding ban for girls to educate themselves.

speak about islam,when you have some islam in yourself.

[Afghanistan2010]

What is the proof the speaking man is himself? Everyone could claim beeing Mullah Omar. Every Pakistani Mullah can speak Arabic. Noone of us has ever seen that blind mullah nor heard his voice.

@Khushal
Taliban are the main drug producer today

yeh pakistanyo ko kis ne ejazet di hai ke yahan baqwas bolleni,in ko to ek ek kar ke golli mar dena si tab sara teek ho jai ga.

da pakistanyanom khabare shuro krae pe afghanistan bande,partaguna yeh pe mityase kakar di dumra dumra khabare alta kawi,dal mom wakhruai...

[Afghanistan2010]

we know a tree by its fruit

Do you know the gratitude of lion or its accomplishment by its fecal....

[khushal]

youre not saying anything i dont already know, But heres what else I know. I know that this khar destroyed the greatest historical monument we had. I know this khar implemented some of the most savage rules ever known to man in the modern era. I know this khar discriminated against the shamal.

what youre trying to do is justify how the khar came into being. i know that. what im saying is the man was a khar, and this eye brow plucker wouldve been ten times the ruler he was. so essentially youre agreeing with me but with one long foot note to add to your agreement

1)The destruction of the budha statues was a cry for help more than anything else.

2)What discrimination against the shamal are you talking about. It was the shamal who put Taliban prisoners in containers and left them to die of dehydration. It was the shamal who killed 3000 Taliban in an ambush in Mazar. Do you think there is going to be no reaction to it.

3)Those savage laws you talk about, Afghanistan was going through one of the most savage time of its history. There was rampant raping of women in major cities, kidnapping of children, murders happening left and right everywhere, looting of everything people with guns can get their hands on and selling them on the black market in other countries, etc. What do you expect from people that had no knowledge of administration. These are madrasa students.

I dont agree with any of their policies that they implemented but I understand that policies come about because of the political and economical environment at hand. The harsher the environment, the harsher the policies.

If the US with all its resources and intellectual capacity cant bring some kind of a functioning administration to the country, why would you expect anything better from him who had no resources nor any intellectual talents at his disposal. But for the record, he did a better job than the US.

[khushal]

To be honest, I have no respect for this man.....

You have no respect for this man because he is a product of destroyed society, why would you have any respect for a society that destroyed itself.

[khushal]

the islamic emirate of afghanistan had an opportunity, the opportunity of a life a time, to start over fresh, to build a new nation, and instead they delivered the pashtuns to the greatest calamity it has ever witnessed

What opportunity of a lifetime. Do you think a bunch a illiterate madrasa students can build a superpower from scratch in a couple of years. The society would have eventually adapted and evolved, but it would have taken generations. The calamity was delivered by the soviet invasion, thats what destroyed the country, once that happened, there was no turning back.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Do you know the gratitude of lion or its accomplishment by its fecal....

The Tree analogy is better because we dont try to benefit from a Lion; we strive to get benefits by a tree.

Mullah Umar showed poor fruits.

[ScimitarXEdge]

What opportunity of a lifetime. Do you think a bunch a illiterate madrasa students can build a superpower from scratch in a couple of years. The society would have eventually adapted and evolved, but it would have taken generations. The calamity was delivered by the soviet invasion, thats what destroyed the country, once that happened, there was no turning back.

False Dichotomy; he didn't say they needed to build a super power; but RESTORE some resemblance of a functioning and viable society. They weren't starting from scratch, this is a truism passed around to apologize for their antics. All they had to do was "clean up" the place and they did that, but then they started oppressing the people they were cleaning up. Many International agencies were trying to help, but were constantly harassed and threatened by the Taliban. The Few that stayed did so because they were willing to bear it. The Taliban lost so much assistance just for the fact they felt women shouldn't go to school. Even s not even ALL Girls schools, which were predominant in Afghanistan, this of course was at the mercy of the whatever minister or governor ran the area.

The Russian Calamity ws real, but Afghanistan still had its own airlines; so it couldn't have been that run down, There was electricity in Qandahar even during the Taliban era, until the Taliban tried severing Afghanistan from the rest of the world, everything indicates their agenda was to cripple Afghanistan even further and not relieve them.

[NokiaWnW]

The blind Mullah´s child is talking about suicide bombing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBWCD4mbtj4



See the hypocricy of Taliban who can not speak when it comes to the truth!!!!!

[NokiaWnW]

what will the Taliban of that forum say about this video?

[Afghanistan2010]

The Tree analogy is better because we dont try to benefit from a Lion; we strive to get benefits by a tree.

Mullah Umar showed poor fruits.

How can you taste the fruits when the tree never grew up and was ready to bear fruits.

[NokiaWnW]

yeh pakistanyo ko kis ne ejazet di hai ke yahan baqwas bolleni,in ko to ek ek kar ke golli mar dena si tab sara teek ho jai ga.

da pakistanyanom khabare shuro krae pe afghanistan bande,partaguna yeh pe mityase kakar di dumra dumra khabare alta kawi,dal mom wakhruai...

http://www.iwar.org.uk/news-archive/crs/6210.pdf

http://www.usip.org/files/resources/taliban_opium_1.pdf

http://www.jamestown.org/programs/gta/single/?tx_ttnews[tt_news]=4145&tx_ttnews[backPid]=182&no_cache=1