'Secret Pakistan' Exposed in BBC Documentary

[abassinafghan]

toba kabuli boy , did you live to long under american bush rule ?

just because i am against you mullah nezwar akhund , i am directly pro kharzai or pro usa ?

and who says that "the " taliban represents anyone ...

how old are you actually? , because i have the feeling to talk with an small boy who indoctrinated himself by internet .

[graveyardofempires]

i was born in kabul but originally from kunar.
im not from america,i think you are too slow to understand.

i am not from america.
for knowing the truth age doesnt matter,how old are you?
you are right taliban doesnt represen tme or you but they do represent the Afghan nation,otherwise Afghans would have already anihilated them.

[abassinafghan]

as i thought you are just a small boy , who just want to see his heros in an simple world , grow up

[graveyardofempires]

as i thought you are just a small boy , who just want to see his heros in an simple world , grow up

here is some education for you my mr wishful thinker.

http://www.pashtunforums.com/political-talk-11/critical-thinking-21250/

and also try to learn what pashtunwali is and the history of Afghanistan.

[tor_khan]

For those outside the UK and unable to access BBC iPlayer, I've uploaded the documentary here: MEGAUPLOAD - The leading online storage and file delivery service

[Afghanistan2010]

then why mullah omar akhund didnt intruct people to make jahad against napakistan ? and napak state , in opposite he distanced himself from groups which openly fight against the pakis .

so we see , your beloved talibans are also just politicians ...

and as soon they are able to do a deal by their own , they are hand over or killed by isi/ napaks .

If it was so he would have kicked out Fazlullah ,Faqir Muhammad and his men who are supporting the islamic emirate in nuristan and kunar out.

[Afghanistan2010]

how dare you compare mullah akhund with great leaders , and dont affiliate the people who fight, with the taliban arround mullah akhund .

strange its the same thing what nato does , they also claim if they kill civilians that it were taliban .



i ask you what did he accomplished under his rule ? in a political point of view , i ask you if you have lived under the taliban rule ?

but of course a 17 years old cyber ghazi knows everything keep on living in the internet

dont talkn about afghan or pashtun people , your not even born in afghanistan. i am sure you have an american birth certificate

which great leaders are you talking of ? those from ANP or Najib ?
Mullah Umar is comparable to people like Mirwais Khan , Wazir Akbar Khan and the similar.

[ScimitarXEdge]

which great leaders are you talking of ? those from ANP or Najib ?
Mullah Umar is comparable to people like Mirwais Khan , Wazir Akbar Khan and the similar.

Mir Wais Khan, and Wazir Akbar Khan weren't Pakistani stooges

[Alchemist]

Mir Wais Khan, and Wazir Akbar Khan weren't Pakistani stooges

Duh....Pakistan didn't exist back then genius.


Srsly dude... THINK!

[graveyardofempires]

he doesnt think
he has other thinking for him and creating his opinions.

[Talal]

oki so half the people here hate pakistan because it supports taliban and they hate taliban, therefore they hate pakistan for supporting it...lets call them population A

the other half hates Pakistan because it well its Pakistan but THEY like taliban..lets call them population B

So now it is impossible for both A and B to be right at the same time no ?

I mean you cant hate Pakistan if group B is right i.e Pakistan doesn't support Taliban & and neither can you hate Pakistan if Group A is right in that case Group B should like Pakistan for supporting taliban

It would have been very interesting if the documentary had discussed this

[graveyardofempires]

Take a hike Talal

pakistan is a hateful country created out of hatred yet you dare to call us haters?

[ScimitarXEdge]

Duh....Pakistan didn't exist back then genius.


Srsly dude... THINK!

first get the ability to think , then advise others on thinking, because it's like a Mentally challenged person trying to advise Philosophers on how to learn Truth.


Mir Wais and Wazir Akbar Khan were nothing like Pakistani Stooges like Mullah Omar

[ScimitarXEdge]

he doesnt think
he has other thinking for him and creating his opinions.

this is someone brainwashed from Pakistan and betrays every Muslim in the world by doing so.

[tor_khan]

oki so half the people here hate pakistan because it supports taliban and they hate taliban, therefore they hate pakistan for supporting it...lets call them population A

the other half hates Pakistan because it well its Pakistan but THEY like taliban..lets call them population B

So now it is impossible for both A and B to be right at the same time no ?

I mean you cant hate Pakistan if group B is right i.e Pakistan doesn't support Taliban & and neither can you hate Pakistan if Group A is right in that case Group B should like Pakistan for supporting taliban

It would have been very interesting if the documentary had discussed this

Interesting possibility, though in truth, I had to read paragraph 4 a few times to figure out exactly who was supposed to hate whom, blah, blah.

What about if we extend this logic.

Group C are Pakistanis who support the Taliban and want full Talibanization of Pakistan, because after all Pakistan is a Muslim country to be distinguished from India.

Group D are Pakistani liberals for whom religion doesn't matter and they see themselves as no different to India.

Group E are Pakistanis who support the Taliban but don't want Talibanization in Pakistan. It is only good for Pashtoons or Afghanistan.

Who is right?