Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army; Dawn news

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army; Dawn news

    MUSA QALA:

    This culinary sideline, which supplements the US forces’ spartan rations, helps the Afghans save enough cash to bribe their commander to give them time off to see their families, the men say. Some never return.

    Speaking in secret afterwards, the Afghan troops told AFP that because they are ethnic minorities in the country’s Pashtun-heavy army, bribery is the only way they can make sure their Pashtun commander gives them a break.


    “The commander tells us, ‘search your pockets’. If somebody gives him money, he can take vacation. I don’t have any money so I can’t go,” said one soldier, a 20-year-old ethnic Hazara man.

    “As a non-Pashtun, I’m cheap. I’m not as valuable to them (the army) as a Pashtun soldier,” added a Tajik, who like others requested anonymity for fear of retribution.


    The situation is sapping morale among young recruits at a small base in the Musa Qala district of volatile Helmand province, a highly dangerous area and one of Afghanistan’s main Taliban flashpoints.

    This is just one of the issues dogging Afghanistan’s 150,000-member national army, whose strength is key to the plan for international troops gradually to withdraw and hand responsibility for security to Afghan forces by 2014.

    A report from respected NGO International Crisis Group in May said today’s Afghan army was “incapable of fighting the insurgency on its own”, highlighting ethnic factionalism, illiteracy, drug addiction and desertion.

    Its research found that Pashtuns and Tajiks – thought to make up 42 and 27 percent of all Afghans respectively – dominate the officer ranks, while Hazaras, Uzbeks and other groups remain under-represented at that level..........


    http://www.dawn.com/2011/01/03/ethni...diers-say.html

    The above news article is from the most influential Paki english newspaper.
    Last edited by khyaal; 01-03-2011, 02:41 PM.

  • #2
    There might be truth in it. Afghanistan is notorious for ethnic-strife.

    Comment


    • #3
      i thought there wer more tajiks uzbeks hazara in the army then pashtuns or is that the police force?
      when i was in kandahar and passing thru each checkpoint on a normal day the police/army people all spoke dari cudnt understand a word.
      Ka Makh De Rana Hear Sho No Jehan Ba Rana Hear She
      Ka Nom De Rana Hear Sho No Khpal Zan Ba Rana Her She[

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Luffy View Post
        There might be truth in it. Afghanistan is notorious for ethnic-strife.
        LOL. But your masters have switched their tone now. They are proving now that minorities are being oppressed by Pashutns. LOL. What a shame!

        You people should at least consult each other while fabricating fictions and lies.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by sahil112 View Post
          i thought there wer more tajiks uzbeks hazara in the army then pashtuns or is that the police force?
          when i was in kandahar and passing thru each checkpoint on a normal day the police/army people all spoke dari cudnt understand a word.
          BTW, what were you doing in kandahar?

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by khyaal View Post
            BTW, what were you doing in kandahar?
            going back home for 2-3 weeks, i am from kandahar
            Ka Makh De Rana Hear Sho No Jehan Ba Rana Hear She
            Ka Nom De Rana Hear Sho No Khpal Zan Ba Rana Her She[

            Comment


            • #7
              Dawn news? nuff said

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by sahil112 View Post
                i thought there wer more tajiks uzbeks hazara in the army then pashtuns or is that the police force?
                when i was in kandahar and passing thru each checkpoint on a normal day the police/army people all spoke dari cudnt understand a word.
                Being from Kandahar you should have known that people from Loy Kandahar had been exempted from serving in the army. That is why people from Kandahar, helmand, oruzgan etc. still have the same attitude towards recruitment in Afghan army and that is why they are in minority in Afghan army.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by khyaal View Post
                  Being from Kandahar you should have known that people from Loy Kandahar had been exempted from serving in the army. That is why people from Kandahar, helmand, oruzgan etc. still have the same attitude towards recruitment in Afghan army and that is why they are in minority in Afghan army.
                  i did not no they wer freed from joining the army but i no many of them dont join becouse they dont want to fight their own brothers.
                  Ka Makh De Rana Hear Sho No Jehan Ba Rana Hear She
                  Ka Nom De Rana Hear Sho No Khpal Zan Ba Rana Her She[

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by khyaal View Post
                    LOL. But your masters have switched their tone now. They are proving now that minorities are being oppressed by Pashutns. LOL. What a shame!

                    You people should at least consult each other while fabricating fictions and lies.
                    What can i say, i am not owner of dawn news.
                    Frankely speaking i am surprised at the article.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by sahil112 View Post
                      i did not no they wer freed from joining the army but i no many of them dont join becouse they dont want to fight their own brothers.
                      You mean people from Punjab's ISI who are destroying afghanistan and Pakhtunkhwa are their brothers?

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by khyaal View Post
                        You mean people from Punjab's ISI who are destroying afghanistan and Pakhtunkhwa are their brothers?
                        i think those people know better about the situation than you.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by khyaal View Post
                          You mean people from Punjab's ISI who are destroying afghanistan and Pakhtunkhwa are their brothers?
                          there are other groups who are also waging jihad its not just this norm of this isi punjabi etc and pakhtunkhwa hmm to be honest i dont care much for it becouse the pashtuns that live there consider themselves pakiz so why should i care about pakiz?
                          Ka Makh De Rana Hear Sho No Jehan Ba Rana Hear She
                          Ka Nom De Rana Hear Sho No Khpal Zan Ba Rana Her She[

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by graveyardofempires View Post
                            i think those people know better about the situation than you.
                            LOL. If they could, they would never be in such worst conditions.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by khyaal View Post
                              LOL. If they could, they would never be in such worst conditions.
                              you think you are smart with your dawn news propaganda LOL
                              im sure those people know better than you and me.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X