why kabuli people are hated by other afghans?

[$hiva]

I have never lived in Kabul (or any other place in Afghanistan for that matter), but I do know that Kabulis are usually stereotyped as being arrogant and condescending towards people from the rural areas (and thus are no different than the inhabitants of any other capital in the world). So maybe this is the reason?

when the people from the rural area rocket, bomb, destroy, destroy the culture, destroy the history, force people to leave, confiscate property, kidnap, bring arabs married to their women and settle them in the city, bring their pakistani masters

after that there is no longer a question of arrogance, its war

[Zarim]

when the people from the rural area rocket, bomb, destroy, destroy the culture, destroy the history, force people to leave, confiscate property, kidnap, bring arabs married to their women and settle them in the city, bring their pakistani masters

after that there is no longer a question of arrogance, its war

I'm not sure I understand what you're saying. Surely you don't believe that ordinary Afghans who flock to cities like Kabul in search of a better life are out to 'destroy, confiscate, kidnap, etc'? I think you are confusing the warlords with ordinary people.

[Kushan Prince]

your evading the question.

Khushal,

He's just another beghirat tajik on here who is finally coming out of the closet to give us his opinion on us since something bad happened to him involving pashtuns in the past. Let him get his anger out on us so called "talibs" it will ease is his hissy fit.

I have a feeling this thread will close in the time being.

[$hiva]

Khushal,

He's just another beghirat tajik on here who is finally coming out of the closet to give us his opinion on us since something bad happened to him involving pashtuns in the past. Let him get his anger out on us so called "talibs" it will ease is his hissy fit.

I have a feeling this thread will close in the time being.

i might be the worst human being out there, but i have you as my bitc.h, so don't forget that - bitc.h

[khushal]

Khushal,

He's just another beghirat tajik on here who is finally coming out of the closet to give us his opinion on us since something bad happened to him involving pashtuns in the past. Let him get his anger out on us so called "talibs" it will ease is his hissy fit.

I have a feeling this thread will close in the time being.

The guy is mentally ill.

[Khostai]

Actualy Kabulis were the outcast in Afghanistan, they were like tourist in there own country especialy the rich ones, having western clothes practising no Islam and acting like they were Europeans made them in the eyes of every one who was not born in Kabul pretty weird and culturless.

I know many Tajiks like to claim that the culture in Kabul was the farsiban culture, but in fact it was not, becuase people in Herat and Mazar also saw the people of Kabul as weird culturless people, who acted and dressed like foreigners. Other cities also began to look more like Kabul, becuase you can find pictures of Kandahar, Jalalabad teachers and goverment people also wearing clothes like that in Europe, but it was not that fully westernised like the elite of Kabul.

Kabul people immitaed western countries, and there culture was that of western Europe who spoke Dari. All the rich people were Pashtuns, Tajiks Hazara were servants and had most of the time some lower jobs, The goverment the money and almost everything was in the hand of Pashtuns, the same with military and police, I heard that during Zairsha, other minorities were not even allowed to join police forces and the army....

[$hiva]

bubble head

[KGODB]

when is the first time that the so called pashtun people is mentioned in history?

kabul has been a city for the last 3500, so kabul was a civilized city when pashtuns were small nomads moving around places

Herodotus mentioned us in the first milenium BC

Kabul was a city that was ran by Hindus for centuries, so its "civilization" is not very relevant to us today

Kabulis are disliked because na plar lari na mor lari, they lived in a bubble, infatuated with western supremacy, until the bubble got popped

ignore the countryside at your peril

[Badlun]

We should differentiate Dari speaking Pashtuns and Pashto speaking Pashtuns. Zahir Shah used to hire services of Pashto-Dari translators when Pashtuns used to come from the East or south and did not know Dari to talk to their PASHTUN king.

No doubt Persian as a language has always remained superior to Pashto. Persian was the official language of all Pashtun kings of all dynasties. This is for the first time that we see some surge in official use of Pashto language in Afghanistan.