Why do Pashtuns give their daughters to non-pashtuns?

[Khyber Pass]

it is incorrect to assume that every single thing in India and Indian culture is from aryans. Indian civilization is older then aryans. The influence of dravdian is integral to all of south asia

According to you then Pashtuns would be Indic-ized (?) in a way as well?

[Karachi]

^ like I said before pashtuns seem to be a bridging people between iranids, central asians and indics. Though I am not aware of pashtun history, perhaps in ancient times they were more indic? it is possible, but again there is no conclusive evidence of anything. I am going by what they are today, today they are not classified as indics because their language, culture, traditions are different from Indians

[Kushan Prince]

The Tajiks I've met as a whole are much lighter than Pashtuns.

I doubt you have met any tajiks by the way you are talking. And no Tajiks are no lighter then pashtuns, should i show you examples?

[Khyber Pass]

False. Panjabis speak the language "Panjabi". Any panjabi or sindhi living in Balochistan wouldn't speak "Balochi" because he/she isn't a baloch. Balochistan means the land of Baloch. Historically speaking the sistan-va-balochistan and todays balochistan was one big land. Baloch lived in these lands untill occupation from Pakistan. All panjabis are Indians or Indics. So you're living in Panjab right? after a decade would it be okay for me to call you a panjabi? since its just a term for a person living there? Absolutely not. You will stay pashtun you will not become panjabi because panjabi is a race not a term to be given to those who reside Panjab.

Panjabis are Indians. There are indian panjabis and then there are paki panjabis. Both are indians.

I know the story of the Baloch people and what the Pakistani's did to you, is both sad and pathetic, but that is history, that is how countries are made, learn to live on forward, and make towards a better country rather than hogging on and on about the past. Your language does not shape your identity, I know many Pashtuns who are born and raised in America, they do not know a word of Pashto, what does that make them? Many ethnicities of the Punjab have just settled there let that be from Ancient Persia, Europe, or heck even India itself

[Kushan Prince]

you still think false. think logically.

the population is changing and moving.

you can not say the current homeland of pashtun was also the homeland of pashtuns 500 years ago.

Ofcourse i can. I am Pashtun. But what the hell makes you think you can? who do you think you are to say Afghanistan wasn't the homeland of pashtuns 5000 years ago?

[Khyber Pass]

I doubt you have met any tajiks by the way you are talking. And no Tajiks are no lighter then pashtuns, should i show you examples?

The ones I met are from Panjshir.
Panjshir Tajiks
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...-6365W-379.jpg

Pashtuns
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...r_Province.jpg

All though the ANA soliders could be of different backgrounds, the old man resembles the typical Pashtun from Kunar.

[Khyber Pass]

Ofcourse i can. I am Pashtun. But what the hell makes you think you can? who do you think you are to say Afghanistan wasn't the homeland of pashtuns 5000 years ago?

Because Afghanistan did not exist 5000 years ago.

[Kushan Prince]

You can't say that about every single Punjabi that lives in Punjab, if you are going to generalize like that I can also say the same about Pashtuns can I not? You are making assumptions but are not using proper historical credible facts to back up your claims. The Indians in general are primarily Aryans, even India as a whole was founded by the Aryans when they came into India and settled in present day Sindh. The Aryans were classified as a bloodthirsty race, coming into the Indus in 1500 BC and basically creating a full blood bath one of these people was Bharata who created a very large Indian empire "According to ancient Indian epic legend of the Mahabharata as well as the numerous puranas and diverse Indian history, Bharat Empire included the whole territory of the Indian subcontinent, including parts of present day Pakistan, Afghanistan, China, Iran, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia,[3] Turkmenistan, North-west Tibet, Nepal and Bangladesh." As a whole we have no direct proof of mixing, we don't even have proof of Pashtuns mixing, so why bring up that topic?

You still think pashtuns are related to indians?











If these people look like us, then i am a god damm goblin.

[M17ArnoBaloch]

I know the story of the Baloch people and what the Pakistani's did to you, is both sad and pathetic, but that is history, that is how countries are made, learn to live on forward, and make towards a better country rather than hogging on and on about the past. Your language does not shape your identity, I know many Pashtuns who are born and raised in America, they do not know a word of Pashto, what does that make them? Many ethnicities of the Punjab have just settled there let that be from Ancient Persia, Europe, or heck even India itself

So you think Palestinians should just surrender their land to isreal? if they should too learn to forget and move forward?

i can show you numerous examples like that.

All i was saying is that can i call you panjabi because you live in panjab? no panjabi is not a term its a race. you can't be panjabi if your a pashtun.

[Kushan Prince]

The ones I met are from Panjshir.
Panjshir Tajiks
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...-6365W-379.jpg

Pashtuns
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...r_Province.jpg

All though the ANA soliders could be of different backgrounds, the old man resembles the typical Pashtun from Kunar.

That old man could be a pashtun from kunar.

Anyways Real tajiks look like this.











There you go, majority of them look like indians now stop this.

[Kushan Prince]

Because Afghanistan did not exist 5000 years ago.

And india did? LOL dumb logic.

[M17ArnoBaloch]

Tajiks dont look like indians.

uzbek + pashtun = tajik

some uzbeki features with some pashtun admixture.

[Khyber Pass]

You still think pashtuns are related to indians?











If these people look like us, then i am a god damm goblin.

But these people are South Indian and are the Native Indians as I and Karachi discussed earlier. But these Indians share similar roots to the Pashtuns and also share many things in common, look at their facial structures not their skin color.
http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f1...31212ab3my.jpg

http://img217.imageshack.us/img217/2693/140wo.jpg

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/i...x4Y5AHNZ1b7ukX

What is the difference between these men and Pashtun men? The looks are quite similar the structure as a whole.

[Khyber Pass]

That old man could be a pashtun from kunar.

Anyways Real tajiks look like this.











There you go, majority of them look like indians now stop this.

All of the Tajiks that you posted look very similar to the average Pashtun except the last one.

[Khyber Pass]

And india did? LOL dumb logic.

Infact there is no proof of it existing in 5000 BC but it did in 1500 BC.