Brainwashed Afghans?

[Gulbabo]

^yane delta mods aw admin khpal da khawre khayanan dei?

[Nokia_Apridy]

tata na.................

[Gulbabo]

taa ta dei?

[Nokia_Apridy]

za da zat da para da QOOM khair na ghwaram...da rogh QOOM khair ghwram

[Gulbabo]

^ma ta na bala pukhtana wakkra ta bal jawab rakawe... pakhto de sama na da.

[Shehbaz Khan]

GOE Hows you

Nokia Jana pa ma grana sanga e?

BLS where are you these days mate :p

[Nokia_Apridy]

na ma da te shuda(milk) ruwal prekhey di......

[Nokia_Apridy]

Shabiziya kham ror........sa hal da wya kna sanga Ghorma shta awo kna ?

[khashayar]

-----Thread closed------

Note:Admins can you close this thread pls. thanks.

[Gulalai]

The afghan side thinks that KP are brainwashed and the KP side thinks Afghans are brainwashed. I guess the British plan is working thanks to all of us.

true but not okay....

[khushal]

^ i agree with some of what youv written however i think your slightly biased towords yourself and i dont agree with certain things youve said, you say pashtuns in KP rather serve than rule..and pashtuns in afghanistan dont? tell me if pashtuns in afghanistan would rather rule then why are there so many non pashtuns in your parliment, why is the ruling and most respected language dari and not pashto.

Pashtuns in KP say afghans are brainwashed because afghanistanis think pashto dominance is widespread in the whole of afghansitan because you have a national song in pashto. pashtuns dont rule afghansitan because 50% of the country dont agree, i mean if i was a tajik,uzbek,hazara why would i yeild to pashtuns or submit to them??

KP pashtuns say afghan pashtuns are brainwashed because they dont know whether they are pashtun or afghan, afghan is uniting and sharing your race with persians, pashtun however isnt.

"Pashtun reunification as part of the natural order of things and as proud Afghans, they will never accept the Durrand Line."

- reunification? do you actually believe that, if thats the case then why do afghans go on like they are superior, come to KP you wont find them saying a khattack is better than a yousufzai weras afghans like to think there better than each other because there from kandahar or barakzai or whatever. if you believe in reunification then why are you more closer to dari peoples, you love their culture, there language there styles everything how is that reunification when the only thing your unified with is persians which ofcourse is the definition of "proud afghans" what is an afghan? is an afghan solely a pashtun? your brainwashed if you think so.

Manzareh,
Lewanaye Zalmaye is a Pashtun from KP so when he says that he is not being biased, he has witnessed the things he has said. You would think what he said could only be said by someone from Afghanistan but thats not the case here.
You have to realize that in Afghanistan, Tajiks, Hazaras, and Uzbeks were originally not Persian speaking. They became Persianized over time and have lost their identity. The Pashtun/Afghans are the only ones that have not lost our identity nor our language. Having Pashto as a national language is very significant, having a national anthem in Pashto is very significant, having Pashto as a mandatory requirement in School is very significant.
Afghanistan is currently in a civil war and once peace returns than you can complain about how the country is run until then you have to be a little more sensible.
I do agree with you that the "Afghan" label should not be lent to other ethnicities directly because this has disenfranchised the KP pashtuns while I do think they should be regarded as Afghan nationals but not "Afghan." just like a Turk can be a German National but not "German."

[Master Khan]

no one is brainwashed, they just need to learn about their History and culture, not many pashtuns in Pakhtunkhwa know about their history or culture, for them their history is Jinnah, alam Iqbal, Pakistan india and all that Bull****.

[graveyardofempires]

^
in pekhwaer they teach you hindu and budhist history and every thing from 1947.
for example about pakistan and india war which was about water.

they dont want to teach Pashtun history cuz they know the word Afghan might pop up which will not make the establishment happy.

i dont know why Pashtuns need to learn about hindu/sikh and budhist history while they have their own history which is more glorious.

you are right we need education and understanding.

[Master Khan]

yeah some one of my cousin did pashto history and he knows everything about pashtuns, over there its a choice to learn pashto but not many take it sadly.
they do Pakistan history instend, I ask them why, they said "Pashto history is hard"..I know its sad.

[Manzareh]

You have to realize that in Afghanistan, Tajiks, Hazaras, and Uzbeks were originally not Persian speaking. They became Persianized over time and have lost their identity. The Pashtun/Afghans are the only ones that have not lost our identity nor our language.

not lost our language yet..if after a certain time the tajiks and co lost thier language, identity and eventually embraced persian, then what makes you think the pashtuns wont eventually?