Who were Indus valley people?

[Karachi]

Who were Indus valley civilization people? did pashtuns have any relation to them?

[Toramana]

Karachi, no one knows for sure because their language has not been deciphered yet. However, some scholars say they were Dravidians.

Pashtuns are later comers to the Subcontinental scene late comers even than Tajaks. They mostly crossed Hinduskush in 1st Century BC some via Pamirs from the present Xingiang (called Indo-Sakas) some via a much we-sternly route via Ghor and Herat.

[Sarbani]

Karachi, no one knows for sure because their language has not been deciphered yet. However, some scholars say they were Dravidians.

Pashtuns are later comers to the Subcontinental scene late comers even than Tajaks. They mostly crossed Hinduskush in 1st Century BC some via Pamirs from the present Xingiang (called Indo-Sakas) some via a much we-sternly route via Ghor and Herat.

The ancient Indus Valley people may have had genetic similarities to a lot of modern day Dravidians, especially the low class ones, but they were not ethnolinguistically Dravidians. The ancient Dravidians look very different to modern day Dravidians and were originally from around Elam, Iran before they came over to colonize large swathes of India many centuries ago. The IVC people were most likely their own separate distinct group (or groups), there isn't evidence to confirm 100%, but that's the most widely accepted theory.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Not the modern india but Pakistan in true sense is the successor state of ancient India

[khushal]

Not the modern india but Pakistan in true sense is the successor state of ancient India

Pakistan has turned the indus valley into a toilet.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Pakistan has turned the indus valley into a toilet.

overpopulation to be precise,but this is the case with the rest of the south asia aswell,over population and poverty

[khushal]

overpopulation to be precise,but this is the case with the rest of the south asia aswell,over population and poverty

Thats an excuse. Europe is more densely populated than you.

you try to claim the Indus valley civilization but the fact is that you have turned it into a toilet and everyone hates you in the region.

[tripledouble]

Pakistan has turned the indus valley into a toilet.

Haha and Afghans have turned Ariana into a massive toilet, u guys are so funny, call Pakistan a ****hole yet live in an even bigger $hithole, you ppl shouldn't even talk,the irony is hilarious

Most of you proud afghans don't even live in Afghanistan, u have lived so long outside your hellhole that you have forgotten what it actually looks likes, here's a reminder of what 99% of what Afghanistan looks like

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Thats an excuse. Europe is more densely populated than you.

you try to claim the Indus valley civilization but the fact is that you have turned it into a toilet and everyone hates you in the region.

But europe per capita income on average is 50 times higher than Pakistan.

Whether pakistanis turned it into a toilet or whatever,no one can refute the claim that indeed Pakistanis are the indigenous people of IVC and the true successor state of ancient India.

And those region of India falling under the ancient IVC map belong to Pakistan including the people(sikh,gujrati,kashmiri,rajistani etc)

[Khostai]

Haha and Afghans have turned Ariana into a massive toilet, u guys are so funny, call Pakistan a ****hole yet live in an even bigger $hithole, you ppl shouldn't even talk,the irony is hilarious

Most of you proud afghans don't even live in Afghanistan, u have lived so long outside your hellhole that you have forgotten what it actually looks likes, here's a reminder of what 99% of what Afghanistan looks like

Thats is sadly true if you have 40 years of war, but whats pakistan excuse?
Just admit it you are like Indians you love **** and the smell of sewage it reminds you of your past.

[tripledouble]

Thats is sadly true if you have 40 years of war, but whats pakistan excuse?
Just admit it you are like Indians you love **** and the smell of sewage it reminds you of your past.

haha don't blame 40 years of war, afghanistan was always dirty barren wasteland that's why your great grandpapas invaded indus valley so many times and now immigrated -even Afghan ghettoes in pakistan are dirtier than average

and lol it isn't just "indic thing", according World Health Organization

http://tribune.com.pk/story/684071/quetta-peshawar-lahore-among-the-most-polluted-cities-of-the-world-who/

Quetta is 4th most polluted city in world, a pashtun city close to afghan border with half a million afghan immigrants

Peshawar is 6th most polluted city in world on list

Most polluted city is Ahwaz, Iran then 3rd polluted is also in Iran in Sanandaj

5th polluted is a Kurdish city of Kermanshah in Iran and 8th is also in Iran(Yasuj)

Lahore is 10th in list, and made it in top 10 first time last year, otherwise top most polluted cities are mostly in Iran, so yeah Iranics take the cake in this regard loool

[tilla_jogian]

Thats is sadly true if you have 40 years of war, but whats pakistan excuse?
Just admit it you are like Indians you love **** and the smell of sewage it reminds you of your past.

afghani muhajirs are dietiest people in Pakistan, they are especially know for being dirty. Its not just war excuse anymore.

[tilla_jogian]

Well IVC people were obviously Pakistanis, what kind of retarded question is that? For more exact origins we will have to wait for genetic tests. But nothing will change the fact that they were Pakistanis.

[tilla_jogian]

Tooth Enamel Shows Young People Moved to Harappa

Tooth Enamel Shows Young People Moved to Harappa - Archaeology Magazine

So rural people used to migrate to ancient Pakistani cities even back then!

[Karachi]

Not the modern india but Pakistan in true sense is the successor state of ancient India

Not really, since modern day pakistanis and north indians are genetically the same, it is stupid to think that Indians have nothing to do with it