Pashtun Macedonian link

[roadrunner]

OMG what is wrong whith you peopel.
Pashtuns majority have black hair and brown eyes and most of Pastuns cosider themself actually black or what we would say ghunumrang..
This Greek MAcedonian and now suddenly Bosnian linking is not correct,
if you gona link this peopel to us why not the whole world...
pfff I am so tired of foreigners who almost don't know any Pashtun in real life are telling us how we look and whith whom we are conected, its rediculous.
Please travel to Afghanistan and open your eyes, this Arian invasion have never been proven.

Pashtuns don't consider themselves black. You might be, and some Pashtuns might be (depending on what you think one is).

The Aryan migration has been very much proven. You might not know it has of course.

[roadrunner]

That is what I say since the beggining of this thread, my pashtun brother

Pashtuns have a very wonderful skin colour ( lal rang )

And infact, This " apollyon " guy know nothing about pashtuns
As you said, there are no links with bosnian or croatian
There may be a few greek links because of the invasions of Alexander the great

You are right, and you know your pashtun origins, more than apollyon

I don't see why you're criticizing Apollyon.

He showed his links. He wrote them down for you.

He didn't show the best pictures (at one extreme) but the links he made were solid.

[JattApache]

How much do you know about Pashtuns by the way? And why do some South Asians get agitated when any reference to probable Pashtun origin out of South Asia is made? True, Pashtuns are not "White" in strict sense but they are not South Asians appearance-wise either generally speaking.

The best statement one can make is they are like other Iranian and Dardic people people e.g. Baluchis, Kurds, Iranians, Tajaks, Pashais, etc in their neighbourhood. On the whole they are more West Asians than South Asians and can be easily distinguished from people east of Indus.

I feel there are some people wanting to pull us into South Asia and some wanting to prove us Arabs probably out of this Islamist Ummah politics and some wanting to prove us something else. Why pla
y politics with science like ethnogenisis of Pashtuns?

Read my posts bro
That's exactly what I said
Pashtuns are an iranic people just like persians, tajiks, balochs and kurds
They are not indics
Punjabis are indics, just like gujaratis or biharis of course
Jatts are not scythian, their ancestry is from sindh
Jatts are just like rajputs or any other casts

Pashtuns may have some greek links because of the invasions of alexander the great
They were mixed, I suppose
Same for some punjabis, they are indics with some foreign dna , due to their geographical localisation



I love pashtun people, I consider all the pashtuns like my brothers
I know that because of the punjabis on the pakistani side, some pashtuns don't like the punjabis

I hope the situation will be more good
Long live the friendship between punjabis ( any casts ) & pashtuns

[Khostai]

Pashtuns don't consider themselves black. You might be, and some Pashtuns might be (depending on what you think one is).

The Aryan migration has been very much proven. You might not know it has of course.

In Khost everyone who had black hair and brown eyes was considered toor or terra, only peopel whith colored eyes light skin and brown red and blondish hair were considered white, even the ones who were really pale but had black hair they considered black/toor.
And Aryan mean black head in old persian or something, I read that in wiki
so europeans can never be Aryan....

[roadrunner]

Read my posts bro
That's exactly what I said
Pashtuns are an iranic people just like persians, tajiks, balochs and kurds

Being Iranic doesnt mean anything.

[roadrunner]

In Khost everyone who had black hair and brown eyes was considered toor or terra, only peopel whith colored eyes light skin and brown red and blondish hair were considered white, even the ones who were really pale but had black hair they considered black/toor.
And Aryan mean black head in old persian or something, I read that in wiki
so europeans can never be Aryan....

Many Europeans have dark hair and eyes. Old Persian has nothing to do with Aryan.

[JattApache]

Being Iranic doesnt mean anything.

^ I wanted to say " indo-iranian "
To differenciate with indics ( east pakistanis and indians )

[roadrunner]

same. indo iranian means nothing

[roadrunner]

the african makrani are indo iranian

[JattApache]

the african makrani are indo iranian

I want to mean that pashtuns share the same ancestry with baloch , persians, kurds and tajiks

That's why they are different to punjabis and sindhis.

^

[roadrunner]

the pashtuns do not share ancestry with all those groups you mention. it has been proven

[JattApache]

^ pashtun people are related to them
You can ask all the pashtuns in this forum

[JattApache]

the pashtuns do not share ancestry with all those groups you mention. it has been proven

"with which groups is it then proven the Pashtuns do share ancestory with if not with Baloch Persians Kurds and Tajiks. " ?

[Wahe Guru]

wahe. please calm yourself down.

i won't speak to you anymore until you've been sedated. you sound like you're going mad.

I am always calm, but if others start calling me a fool or troll etc then I tend to reply back in the same way. So dont do that to me and I wont do it to you or anyone else.

As regards Apollyn, I did not like him printing photos of what I call idiotic fringe people in India. And those photos are also faked to make them look worse. I also did not like him referring to Indians as mutants etc. I have seen his writeups before on a website.

I am not mad yet.

[roadrunner]

A lot of what you posted was garbage, wahe. If you post garbage you'll get called a fool.

A lot of Apollyon's pictures were extreme but he was trying to show the correlation with his writing. You might have misunderstood him. After a bit he started trolling you as you were trolling him.