Is Pakistan disintegrating?

[drona]

That is backstabbing behaviour madam. I once argued with my teacher who declared during lecture that afghans have backstabbing nature, i think may be he was right.

Unfortunately, most young Pakistanis are fed the same canard about Indians too, most lovingly summarized by "Bagal mein churi, muh mein raam raam".
No wonder the current generation is so prone to paranoid schizophrenia, and falls for ludicrous conspiracy theories ..

~Drona

[Shehbaz Khan]

My country existed Right!!

You are now going into an imaginary situation the idealistic one !! Same I can say that If Russia and US didn't exist everything would have been fine? O_o!!

Who would have helped you If Pakistan would have said we are not welcoming you here? This was the question and you went to an ideal situation?

[khyaal]

That is backstabbing behaviour madam. I once argued with my teacher who declared during lecture that afghans have backstabbing nature, i think may be he was right.

What else can one expect from a Punjo teacher and his Punjo student.

Any one should have told your teacher why the erstwhile Indians, now Pakis, always looked towards afghans to help them protect from Sikhs and Marhatas.

[Michin Khel]

What else can one expect from a Punjo teacher and his Punjo student.

Any one should have told your teacher why the erstwhile Indians, now Pakis, always looked towards afghans to help them protect from Sikhs and Marhatas.

I agree he was brainwashed soul but said such words on topic of tehreek e hijrat in 1919 in which afghanistan refused to allow muslims from british india for refuge. Even pashtuns from pakhtunkhwa were denied entrance.

[khyaal]

Who would have helped you If Pakistan would have said we are not welcoming you here? This was the question and you went to an ideal situation?

Read this:

Reply to luffy:

[QUOTE=khyaal;204344]Do you understand the meaning of Pakistan? Pakistan is just the name of an arrangement of nations which live on their own historical lands.

Pashtun(afghan) have had their historical lands of Northern and Southern Pakhtnukhwa before their was any such thing as Pakistan.

Pakistan doesn't have an inch of its own land. The displaced afghans settled in Northern and Southern Pakhtunkwha and not in your Punjab or Sindh. Now got it?[/QUOTE]

[Shehbaz Khan]

Hehe Pakistan doesn't have an inch of it's own land .. Hehe LOL LOL !!

[Master Khan]

Afghans just settled in Pakhtunkhwa during the War..is their land anyway lol.
We pashtuns welcome them...not your Punjab and sindh.

[Master Khan]

Hehe Pakistan doesn't have an inch of it's own land .. Hehe LOL LOL !!

right now USA owns it and your goverment takes all the money for themselfs

[khyaal]

Pakistan is a federation just like Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia once were. Now today both are defunct. You see, Serbs, Bosnian, Croatian, Slovenian Macedonian, Czech, Slovak nation states. It is always the nation which remains and not the state. People of one nation have tied destinies.

[khyaal]

Hehe Pakistan doesn't have an inch of it's own land .. Hehe LOL LOL !!

OK. Convince me how Pakistan has its own historical land which doesn't belong to either of the nations in the federating units. First you must understand the meaning of a federation.

[Michin Khel]

Pakistan is a federation just like Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia once were. Now today both are defunct. You see, Serbs, Bosnian, Croatian, Slovenian Macedonian, Czech, Slovak nation states. It is always the nation which remains and not the state. People of one nation have tied destinies.

A sensible post from you after long time

[khyaal]

Thanks a lot.

[Shayesta]

My country existed Right!!

And you as a Pukhtoon were forced into this nation, remember?

Same I can say that If Russia and US didn't exist everything would have been fine?

You could be very correct about USA; No USA, no Dollars, no Pakistan. Aye?

Who would have helped you If Pakistan would have said we are not welcoming you here?

How would Pakistan have received billions of Dollars if we had decided not to go to Pakhtunkhwa? Oh yeah!

This was the question and you went to an ideal situation?

This question has been already answer a million times on different threads, though creatures like yourself will close their eyes to this reply as it doesn't meet their standard (if any left) and needs (whatever may be).

A sensible post from you after long time

I still need to see one from you.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Forced to join it? What are you saying? There was a referendum do you remember? The people of KPK voted to join Pakistan


Hehe, my dear each and every of your problem is not created by Pakistan!!


Again dollars? Why didn't Iran want that dollars?


Hehe again!!

____________________



The dollars that Pakistan received than and even today are nothing in comparison with the worst situation that Pakistan has suffered/is suffering.

[Levanaye Zalmaye]

Shehbaaz, the partition of Punjab and Bengal and their accession to Pakistan were done through a vote in parliament. It was the same case with Sindh. However, when it was clear that the NWFP assembly would not vote in favor of Pakistan, a psuedoislamic conglomerate of colonial slaves, the Muslim League devised a strategy to circumnavigate this little issue. It became clear to Bachaa Khan that Pakistan wanted this province of Afghanistan that was captured in the late 19th century to become a part of its new state. The very fact that the Muslim League establishment didn't go for a vote in the provincial assembly was indicative of that fact that they would do whatever it takes to take the province. Therefore, it was a foregone conclusion that any referendum would be rigged to provide the result that the establishment wanted. The referendum itself, incidentally, didn't include huge chunks of Pashtun populations and is considered, to this day, as highly suspicious and unreliable.

Shehbaaz Khan, just after one generation of Soviet occupation, Turks from Central Asia were patriotically dying on the front lines of Europe for the sake of their Russian masters. Similarly, Pakistan Studies and PTV have worked their magic on you and you have forgotten 6,000 years of history for the sake of 60 years.