Persian Nationalist Forgery

[BarakzaiAbdali]

And what about Arab forgery, Mr. Barakzai Al-Arabi?

Are you implying that the Prophet Muhammad forged something or that a certain paracha forged a Pashtun identity?

[Toramana]

Are you implying that the Prophet Muhammad forged something or that a certain paracha forged a Pashtun identity?

Al-Arab, you will never grow beyond the limits of a typical Maulavi even if you are educated in Harvard. Like typical Mullahs you use intimidating tactics.

[BarakzaiAbdali]

Al-Arab, you will never grow beyond the limits of a typical Maulavi even if you are educated in Harvard. Like typical Mullahs you use intimidating tactics.

Intimidating? By what, asking you a question? The topic was with respect to a Persian Nationalist forging a document and attributing it to the British museum, which subsequently wrote to disprove the forgery. You went on to talk about Arab forgery... your alliance is more often with avowed atheists and some guy named Paracha who you said you are related to that also is supposed to be anti Islam....

So lets repeat the question... are you alleging the Prophet Muhammad forged something?

[Manzareh]

How an Islamic scholar or Mullah can be expert at the same time on every thing from politics, culture, education, science, technology, philosophy to economics. He is not a PhD in any of these subjects then how can one generalist decide the fate of so many specialized areas? And where on the surface of the earth took place in this manner or taking place now? Any model?

Which scholar of ANYTHING is an expert in all the fields you mentioned at the same time? A mullah is a human being not a superhuman to be an expert at politics culture education blah blah all at once .. There is a group of different individuals that have different roles based on their expertise and research just like western politicians, by your logic in order to be a politician you have to be an expert at a range of completely different fields.

What's your definition of a mullah anyway? If it's a scholar then there's plenty of Muslim scholars that are experts in the subjects your speaking about..doctors, teachers, scientists at same time being Islamic scholars.

There's also different types of Islamic scholars specialising in different areas Muftis for example have done further research into legal matters and are more qualified to give certain rulings.

I think your definition of a mullah is some guy that is not allowed to have an education or some other extreme view point lol. Open your mind beyond the realms of self denial

[RevolutionThroughReason]

And what about Arab forgery, Mr. Barakzai Al-Arabi?

like how you forged being Pashtun when you were really a Paracha

[Herat]

x

Dr BarakzaiAbdali, I think I understand and I appreciate your helpful insight and wisdom here. Would you perhaps have any recommendation on literature I can read?