Anybody come up with answer to these questions?

[zamurd]

Can you try to give a satisfactory answer to these questions?
its not arguments battle field but we need to know what could be the explanation as these question weaken us from inside.
i hope for a productive discussion not cross fires sir/ madam who ever reading! thank you

,


source:http://www.alsharia.org/mujalla/2006...t-asif-mahmood

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

write it in Pashto or English so that we can read them and answer them.

[zamurd]

Ok, here, i dare you

Questions of Tahir Cahudhry:

1. I have married a woman from 'people of the book', i have a son who has not reached adulthood yet. His name is Ali. Suppose his name is not 'Ali' but else and he is from 'people of the book', now should i disown him from inheritance?
if marriage is allowed with 'people of the book' then why not inheritance for son who is 'people of the book'?!

2. why a muslim woman has 'half inheritance', i am usually answered as economic responsibilities are on shoulders of Man thats why. if this answer is correct then the culture i live in here women work equal to men, so in our situation won't women will earn equal inheritance as a men? !

3. i am told that 'blood money' for woman is half, because her witness is half, her inheritance is half, thats why her 'blood money' is half. now i have few questions here; is a woman not intelligent enough in reality?so her witness considered half? 2nd if we agree on half witness and half inheritance rule and apply on half 'blood money' then why not this half rule applies on other things e.g.
woman will do half fasts, half Prayers; and half punishment on crime because she considered not as intelligent as a man, why she gets full punishment as a man does?!

4. For marriage permission/agreement of a woman is necessary, but when i visit pakistan i see many ' mismatched' marriages. And our culture treats women as animals who are not allowed/cant express their feelings. women are forced here for marriages. Now tell me will you call such marriages as 'Rape' ?!

5. In islam Marriage is called "contract", now only those person can do 'contract' who is adult, and in Islam there is concept of marriage for a girl who had not reached adulthood. Is it right? Sometime i think why a child girl should be married?why not wait till she reaches adulthood? May be she starts liking someone else when she reaches adulthood and she already married in childhood to someone else..
Is not against Human Rights? what islam says about it?

6. If Marriage with 'people of book is allowed then why not friendship? !

7. why a person leaving islam is ordered to be murdered? why you want to keep a person forcefully in islam, why abandon him off from islam community?

8. What is concept of 'Slave Girl' in islam? can one keep Slave-girl in today's era? in America i am asked this question and i have no answer..
Slave-girls is live human being, someone become her owner and force sexual relations with her or sell her, my heart doesn't agree thats islam allows it. Sometime i think, i live on a mountain community, there lives my fiancee and one day Islamic Army comes for war, we loose war, they take my fiancee and Leader of army hands over my fiancee to a soldier like a packet of peanuts, what ever soldier wants to do with her; i dont think Islam the religion of kind prophet Muhammad has any space for this thing.
Tell me what is real concept of Islam on this? i am at loss to this question in America.



i will translate remaining questions later, for now try answering these anyone!!

[Mujib]

These are questions for scholars, bro. Non-scholars are not fit to answer them.

There are reliable Question and Answer services at SunniPath.com and at SeekersGuidance.org. Perhaps you can ask these questions to the scholars there. You can also search in the Q&A page for the answers to some of these questions.

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

Sunnipath propagates shirk:

http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=7&ID=3752&CATE=24

[Badlun]

Questions of Tahir Cahudhry:

1. I have married a woman from 'people of the book', i have a son who has not reached adulthood yet. His name is Ali. Suppose his name is not 'Ali' but else and he is from 'people of the book', now should i disown him from inheritance?
if marriage is allowed with 'people of the book' then why not inheritance for son who is 'people of the book'?!

2. why a muslim woman has 'half inheritance', i am usually answered as economic responsibilities are on shoulders of Man thats why. if this answer is correct then the culture i live in here women work equal to men, so in our situation won't women will earn equal inheritance as a men? !

3. i am told that 'blood money' for woman is half, because her witness is half, her inheritance is half, thats why her 'blood money' is half. now i have few questions here; is a woman not intelligent enough in reality?so her witness considered half? 2nd if we agree on half witness and half inheritance rule and apply on half 'blood money' then why not this half rule applies on other things e.g.
woman will do half fasts, half Prayers; and half punishment on crime because she considered not as intelligent as a man, why she gets full punishment as a man does?!

4. For marriage permission/agreement of a woman is necessary, but when i visit pakistan i see many ' mismatched' marriages. And our culture treats women as animals who are not allowed/cant express their feelings. women are forced here for marriages. Now tell me will you call such marriages as 'Rape' ?!

5. In islam Marriage is called "contract", now only those person can do 'contract' who is adult, and in Islam there is concept of marriage for a girl who had not reached adulthood. Is it right? Sometime i think why a child girl should be married?why not wait till she reaches adulthood? May be she starts liking someone else when she reaches adulthood and she already married in childhood to someone else..
Is not against Human Rights? what islam says about it?

6. If Marriage with 'people of book is allowed then why not friendship? !

7. why a person leaving islam is ordered to be murdered? why you want to keep a person forcefully in islam, why abandon him off from islam community?

8. What is concept of 'Slave Girl' in islam? can one keep Slave-girl in today's era? in America i am asked this question and i have no answer..
Slave-girls is live human being, someone become her owner and force sexual relations with her or sell her, my heart doesn't agree thats islam allows it. Sometime i think, i live on a mountain community, there lives my fiancee and one day Islamic Army comes for war, we loose war, they take my fiancee and Leader of army hands over my fiancee to a soldier like a packet of peanuts, what ever soldier wants to do with her; i dont think Islam the religion of kind prophet Muhammad has any space for this thing.
Tell me what is real concept of Islam on this? i am at loss to this question in America.

Great and valid questions and we must give our feed back on all these questions as all of us are Muslims so we must have some response on these matters and may not wait for only scholars to deal with such questions.

My response is as follows

1. For the questions on inheritance, evidence, polygamy, slave girls, blood money etc we need reinterpretation of Qur'an. The simple solution is shane nazool, context and milieu of Arabia 1400 years back. Now these injunctions are not valid. These were for that time and now in this modern era where human rights prevail and there is no difference in man and woman in their intelligence and personalities(except biological differences), these injunctions need reinterpretation otherwise young generation will start abhorring Islam which does not go in favor of Islam.

2. The polygamy of the Prophet Muhammad, his marriage with minor etc may be considered his personal acts not his acts as a prophet of a religion. He him self says in the famous hadith of date palm trees pollination that his words on religious matters may be taken only AND NOT on mundane matters. If we consider his each and every act as Sunna then it will be very difficult for Muslims to marry 12 or 11 wives, having slave girls and marrying a girl of 9 years. Prophet was great in his religious capacity but his personal life has a lot of issues which cannot be adjusted with this mdern era.

3. Forced marriages and early marriages are also connected to our society and the only solution is modern and professional education. An engineer, a doctor, a professor, a scientist woman will never never be forced in to a marriage, an uneducated yes.

4, On questions like music, dance, dress, fine arts etc , the solution is separation religion from culture, art and science. Religion is only for your faith, worship and ethics not for determining your tastes for fine arts, utilitarian arts, dress needs, hair style, fashion etc.

Spiritual part of religion is more important. That is why in the 5 pillars of Islam we only have religious and spiritual fundamentals not things related to politics, economics, culture, society science and education. One can be a perfect Muslim if he/she believes in oneness of God, considering Muhammad as the last prophet, offers prayers, keep fast, pay zakat and goes for pilgrimage and observes the basic moral and spiritual injunctions of Islam .

That is the religion of Islam while political Islam or Islamism is based on Wahhabism, Salafism and other extremist ideologies which has nothing to do with the religion of Islam.

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

^ the grand mufti of Pashtunforums has spoken haha

[zamurd]

hmmm

i found a weblink while searching, i have sent a question to Dr. Zakir Naik here, lets see how he responds, then we will have scholar's opinion.

link is below;


http://www.irf.net/index.php?option=...acts&Itemid=28

[Mujib]

i found a weblink while searching, i have sent a question to Dr. Zakir Naik here, lets see how he responds, then we will have scholar's opinion.

Zakir Naik is not a scholar of Islam.

Again, you can find answers to many of these questions at the Q&A page at SunniPath.com and SeekersGuidance.org.

[Friend]

RTR should answer now rather than than rebuking everyone on here and refuting every scholar.

[zamurd]

Is Sex allowed with Slave Women in Islam Dr Zakir Naik

Is Sex allowed with Slave Women in Islam Dr Zakir Naik

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=dYr8l1hkp0U

[ډګروال]

Zakir Naik is not a scholar of Islam.

Again, you can find answers to many of these questions at the Q&A page at SunniPath.com and SeekersGuidance.org.

Zakir Naik is one of the greatest Islamic preacher and probably has more knowledge than most of your so called scholars.
why do you always refer people to this sufi website?
what do you want to proof?

and why are you sufis against a great man like Dr Zakir Naik who has done more for Islam than all fo your scholars combined.

[Mujib]

Zakir Naik is one of the greatest Islamic preacher and probably has more knowledge than most of your so called scholars.

Wrora, in Islam a scholar is someone who has studied the Islamic sciences under qualified scholars and who has been authorized by those scholars to teach. A scholar is someone who has a sanad (chain of transmission) through teachers back to the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace).

At which Islamic institute has Zakir Naik studied? With which scholars?

No one denies that Zakir Naik is well-versed in the Bible and in comparative religion. He first became popular giving talks about the Bible and Christianity. But now he has begun playing the role of a mufti, answering questions related to fiqh and `aqida.

[Mujib]

why do you always refer people to this sufi website?

Tasawwuf (Sufism) is not a sect; it is a science (`ilm) in Islam. Tasawwuf is about ridding oneself of spiritual diseases, acquiring praiseworthy traits, and dedicating one's life to Allah.

See The Place of Tasawwuf in Traditional Islam

[Badlun]

Zakir Naik is a a Salafi, Wahabi, extremist, promoter of terrorism, extremism and hatred against other religions and undermining them which create disharmony.

In secular India he is creating problems for the minority Muslims.

He is against pluralism and who calls Osama bin Laden a soldier of Islam.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakir_Naik