Hanafi Prayer

[Dreamer]

yes yes Imam hanifa this and imam hanifa that.... who cares!

[abubaker]

Fiqh al-Sunna is not a Hanafi text. It contains strange fiqhi positions, and the English translation is further misleading. It should not be relied upon for fiqh rulings.

strange in what since? as in they are not Islamic. or they don't conform to the hanaif fiqh?

don't take this as an attack iam merely a student, and so would like to know your views

[Dreamer]

because according to hanafies only imam hanifa is the sole authority in islam so anything that doesnt have a label of hanafi isnt islam.... sad really but thats this cult 4 u

[abubaker]

if I am not mistaken you say the same about wahabis.

lets not ruin his third shall we

[شمله ور خراساني]

There certainly is evidence. The evidences of the Hanafi madhhab fill volumes. You as a non-scholar don't know of these works, but that shouldn't be a reason for you to claim "there is no evidence." It is better for us to acknowledge that we don't know and not to make claims about what we don't know.

why the secrecy? If there is evidence, just post it. Let us see it. Why should "scholars" have the monopoly over knowledge of Islam? And why should common people follow "scholars" blindly?

Bring the evidence forward.

Which sahih hadith supports your claim?

[شمله ور خراساني]

This is a thread for questions and answers related to prayer, for the benefit of forum members. The vast majority of Pashtuns and Afghans are Hanafi. Of course everyone can benefit from the thread, but please keep arguments out.

again the majority argument.

If you want people to benefit, then show people ayat of quran and sahih ahadith in support of your madhabi stance. If not, why do you presist on people following others blindly?

[Feroza_Banu]

youve done a head count? stop bigging up your cult of hanifisim

this topic is not for you... since u are not following hanafi fiq... what r u trying to prove with your childish comment if u don't even belong here... mujib is posting these material for those who like to benefit from it... if u don't find the material beneficial just stay out of it then...

[Dreamer]

we are asking him wy hanafisim is so important 2 him...

[Iqra]

^That's the madhab he follows...

forgive me for answering ...

but there's no reason to attack him here when he is not badmouthing you or anyone else...

[Dreamer]

Im not attacking him we are asking why is it so important 2 blind follow as he does?

[Iqra]

^ I must've misread the discussion

[Dreamer]

no worries... Im mearly enquiring why madhabies think as they do

[شمله ور خراساني]

LOL, this thread is now sticky. I wonder why...oh let me guess..Its the "majority" thingy again.

[Mujib]

strange in what since? as in they are not Islamic. or they don't conform to the hanaif fiqh?

Strange as in they contravene the rulings of all four madhhabs. Like the incorrect opinion in Fiqh al-Sunna that one can touch the Qur'an without being in a state of wudu. Or like the incorrect opinion in the English translation that wiping in wudu can be done over regular socks when the correct ruling is that it can only be done over a particular kind of socks/boots.

[abubaker]

Strange as in they contravene the rulings of all four madhhabs. Like the incorrect opinion in Fiqh al-Sunna that one can touch the Qur'an without being in a state of wudu. Or like the incorrect opinion in the English translation that wiping in wudu can be done over regular socks when the correct ruling is that it can only be done over a particular kind of socks/boots.

so what's the difference socks are socks aren't they

and what is the argument for not touching the quran without wudu