Two type of Islam

[شمله ور خراساني]

From where, then, do we learn prayer (namaz)?

This a common dialogue that will end up like this: Well if something is not in Qur'an then we don't have to do it. Hence, it is for these people not necessary to even pray. All is left is philosophy.

On one occasion, one such "intellectual" concluded that we should stop praying and only be good in our hearts and everything will be fine.

[Ghurzang]

This a common dialogue that will end up like this: Well if something is not in Qur'an then we don't have to do it. Hence, it is for these people not necessary to even pray. All is left is philosophy.

On one occasion, one such "intellectual" concluded that we should stop praying and only be good in our hearts and everything will be fine.

My dear brother...you are justifying mulla made ahadiths only for NIMAZ...Can you tell me Islam is only the name of NIMAZ???No not at all,one is MUAMILAAT one is IBADAAT,and the over all impression of Quran and Prophet is focused on MUAMILAAT.But for Nimaz i have reason without ahadiths,and that is as under..

For Nimaz,i have three answers.First:If we pray according to ahadiths then every mosque and Firqa will have his own praying style.
Second: Lacs of muslims obsereved Prophet while Praying,then the same muslims were observed by Crors of poepl and so on and at the end this pray connection reached to us...Whether the observation/witness(shahadat) of crors,billions of muslims is not sufficient to teach Pray???????
Can a illeterate villager learn pray from Bukhari ???????.The way our forefathers used to pray,the same we continued and now new generation of us imitating(NAQAL) the same pray....Here whats the need of Bukhari sharif???? A muslim living in far flung valley of Kashmir called ''Samdi'' has no access to Bukhari shareef or ahadiths but still he pray correctly....

There are many many affairs which not covering either Quran or Ahadiths then what to do with that????no doubt using comtemporary knowledge and mature common sense we can adopt good option in that affairs.

Pray is not the special feauture of Islam.All religions have their own pray with their own style....

I dont wana continue this matter for longer as i smelled many things from my bretherns so will stop here by Qrratugi quote ,where she says,

''In religious discussions with people who don't know what they're saying, the one who stops is the smart one; the one who continues on is.....

(Woh andhe he,behre he,gongey hay,aur Allah ne on ke dilon per muhar laga dia hay,,,...............HAQ KO SONNA GAWARA NAHE KRTE...QURAN)

Take ur good care and SALAM