Hanafi or Salafi???

[ScimitarXEdge]

My Theology is Mu'tazilah

but my MadHab of Fiqh is Unified between Hanafi an Shafi'i from the Syrian, Iraqi and Yemeni Mushrab.; but most importantly, logical and rational understanding based on evidence we can determine from science, mainly anthropology, biology and sociology

[ScimitarXEdge]

I am deobandi Hanafi.

tragic; those guys are ignorant as they come and went into creating the Taliban.

[Afghanistan2010]

People learning from the Darul Uloom Deoband are following the right path of Sunnah, it is just wrong to call oneself deobandi...

the proof

Sheikh Sudais visits Darul Uloom Deoband 2011 - YouTube

[Michin Khel]

tragic; those guys are ignorant as they come and went into creating the Taliban.

Yes talibans were students of deobandi madrassas. By the way Pashtuns of KP are mostly deobandi...Muslims of Punjabi and India are mainly barelvis.

[Michin Khel]

By the way Pashtuns of Afghanistan follow which school of thought?

[Afghanistan2010]

By the way Pashtuns of Afghanistan follow which school of thought?

Brother we in Afghanistan don't want such names like brevlis or deobandi or any other names that makes division among the ahlus sunnah,we are muslims and learing from abu hanifa(ra) more not we have the Quran of Allah and Sunnah of our Prophet (pbuh)

that is enough.

[ScimitarXEdge]

there is a deobandi influence, but as Mujib said, Afghans have their own body of scholars; they're mainly Hanafi Madhab

[ScimitarXEdge]

You could claim to be a hanafi...but hardly many of you know what aqaaid do hanafis differ from shafi or maliki or even jaffari.

Apparently neither do you; aqa'id and fiqh are two different issues entirely

shafi'i and Hanafi don't necessarily differ on 'aqa'id, you can abide by any madHab, you can be 'Ashariyah, Maturidiyah, or 'Athariyh you can even be a Mu'tazili; in fact many of the traditional Scholars of Hanafi and Shafi'i MadHab were also Mu'tazilah in 'Aqidah.

[Afghanistan2010]

But they are near to the teaching of Abi Hanifa (rah) of Darul Uloom Deoband and Haqqania than to the brevlis,because Afghans are pretty anti-shia and sects,shias are allies of brevlis.

[ScimitarXEdge]

actually the Hanafi Ulama of Syria, Egypt, Turkey and Iraq all consider the Deobandis more akin to Saudi Wahhabis, and they view the Barelwis as misguided than actual followers of the traditions of Abu Hanifa

since Abu Hanifa never expressed hostility towards the Shi'a

[Michin Khel]

But they are near to the teaching of Abi Hanifa (rah) of Darul Uloom Deoband and Haqqania than to the brevlis,because Afghans are pretty anti-shia and sects,shias are allies of brevlis.

Bareilvis say that hazrat mohammad p.b.u.h was noor not bashar , . They kind of worship hazrat mohammad p.b.u.h like shias worship hazrat ali.

[Michin Khel]

actually the Hanafi Ulama of Syria, Egypt, Turkey and Iraq all consider the Deobandis more akin to Saudi Wahhabis, and they view the Barelwis as misguided than actual followers of the traditions of Abu Hanifa

since Abu Hanifa never expressed hostility towards the Shi'a

People of punjab think that pashtuns are wahabis.

[ScimitarXEdge]

People of punjab think that pashtuns are wahabis.

People of KP think Punjabis are Barelwis; when in fact there are more or as many Deobandi Madrassas there.

Lal Masjid was associated with Deobandis.

[Alchemist]

My Theology is Mu'tazilah

but my MadHab of Fiqh is Unified between Hanafi an Shafi'i from the Syrian, Iraqi and Yemeni Mushrab.; but most importantly, logical and rational understanding based on evidence we can determine from science, mainly anthropology, biology and sociology

Anthropology and sociology are not Sciences. Maybe pseudo sciences. Your speciality.

And your not even a mu'tazali. You are something else.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Sure perhaps if someone thinks real Science is believing in blind dogmas, everything outside of that would in turn become pseudo science. Perhaps Sandwich making is more of a "real science" in your eyes

and how does one determine who to be a Mu'tazili, enlighten us please.