Hazrat Khalid Ibni Walid the Sword of Allah

[mastan]

My muslim brothers and sisters, I am a young muslim born in the West. My parents belonged to Bangla Desh. I want to know about my muslim faith and history. I have read some Muslim history. The character that fascinates me is Khalid Ibn Walid. But when I read more about him, I find him controversial. He is said to have killed another Muslim and married his wife on the same day when the deceased was killed. Below is a debate about him between Shias and Sunnis.

http://www.ansar.org/english/q&a.htm
http://www.answering-ansar.org/answe...d/en/chap2.php

Even if we accept that he killed Malik Ibni Nuwayrah by mistake, it cannot be justified that he married the wife of the deceased within 24 hours both Islamically and from moral point of view. In Islam, one cannot marry a woman before 3 months of the death of her previous husband. Besides, how can one sleep with a woman whose husband and family have been killed just hours before? She must have gone through devastation and deserved some time to regain mental peace.

I hope that brothers and sisters explain this in a satisfiable way.

[Dreamer]

^already addressed in my thread

[Dreamer]

so far no proper answer.... anyway u shld be careful.... the hardcore sunnis while unable to give a satisfactory answer will probably accuse u of being a shia and start shia bashing... its really funny reading the defence posts on characters such as khalid and Muawiyya 2name but a few

[Fahd]

hahahahhahhah i don't have time to childs !! and i see how u make shiite happy hahahahahahahaha thank u haider bangsh u shouldn't thank him like that and show u hate sunni hahahahahaha

0ops sorry but u always make those theards !! and when someone start with u u hide like last time when u get mad and i apologized about it
should i post or keep ignor u !! hmm post or ignor

lol i post it ;p

[Dreamer]

hahahahhahhah i don't have time to childs !! and i see how u make shiite happy hahahahahahahaha thank u haider bangsh u shouldn't thank him like that and show u hate sunni hahahahahaha

0ops sorry but u always make those theards !! and when someone start with u u hide like last time when u get mad and i apologized about it
should i post or keep ignor u !! hmm post or ignor

lol i post it ;p

please post your understanding of Khalids actions... I am eager to hear

[Fahd]

hahahhah not just mutah
there is something much much much much much biger hahahahahahahahhahaha
he knows
anal !! is halal for shiite hahahahha
hmm and dreamer don't have any problems with gays marry !!
!!

[Dreamer]

I wonder why shias are so concerned regarding this issue.

shias have 10minutes marriage ... shia ayatollahs love these one night stand marriages.

Why this seems so un ethical to you?

@dreamer

You better stick to "what is mutah" thread.

not part of what is being discussed.... you slag shias off constantly that they curse sahabas please please defend his actions of your great "hazrat" khalid bin waleed

[Dreamer]

To me as a Pashtun there is no morality in shiaism.

No doubt no Pashtun can send his sister to one-night-stand marriage.

and yet u can call a rapist hazrat... great morality u have

[Dreamer]

anyway this isnt a shia/ sunni thread its abt Khalids actions! either defend him or say nothing and make ur own thread abt muttah

[Fahd]

hey u ignor my post
why :p

[Haider Bangash 2.0]

hahahahhahhah i don't have time to childs !! and i see how u make shiite happy hahahahahahahaha thank u haider bangsh u shouldn't thank him like that and show u hate sunni hahahahahaha

0ops sorry but u always make those theards !! and when someone start with u u hide like last time when u get mad and i apologized about it
should i post or keep ignor u !! hmm post or ignor

lol i post it ;p

Mara khabarai pela zda ka bia shiite shiite kawa. Alif bey na khabar ye na aw tho ham mo tha "post or ignor" kawe, mara chena yaara pa arom.

[Dreamer]

hey u ignor my post
why :p

SIT DOWN... take a deep breath and read the topic of the thread... if you can answer in relation to it then post if not than dont ... simple as

[Haider Bangash 2.0]

To me as a Pashtun there is no morality in shiaism.

No doubt no Pashtun can send his sister to one-night-stand marriage.

Confusing Nikah Ul Mutah with Halala and misyaar? Don't worry I will straighten up your facts for you.
Yes, no Pashtun send their sisters to one-night-stand "marriage", but its a shame that Pashtuns like you like to send their sisters for 1 minute stand so to make them "halal" for their previous husbands.
According to Sunni Fiqh, if a man pronounces divorce three times [at once] on his wife (even in anger), then she becomes haram to him until she marries another man, has sexual intercourse with him, and then divorces him. This practice is known as halala. If the woman marries the second man with no other intention except to have intercourse with him once, and then obtains a divorce him, is she being treated like a normal, permanent wife? Yet the Sunni fiqh is not only unanimous on the permissibility of such an act, but on its obligation in certain circumstances.

Misyar marriage in practice
In addition to the preceding cases, wealthy Arab men sometimes enter into a Misyar marriage while on vacation, in order to have sexual relations with another woman without committing the sin of zina. They usually divorce the women once their holiday is over.
Nikah Misyar - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Which one of these two do you practice esapzi?

[Dreamer]

now now bro... lets keep things on track

[Fahd]

hahahhahhahahhaahha the theard f up :p
ahhahah dame im a sunni smart :p i just change the topic :p without shiite know hahahahahha :p jk jk