What do you guys think of a partition of Afghanistan?

[UnknownUser]

Afghanistan is mishmash of two major populations. In teams of linguistics and culture IT can be divided into half Persian, the other half mostly Pashtun.

Both groups Seem hindered due to being divided into several countries. Farsi speakers being divided into Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Afghanistan. Meanwhile Pashtuns divided into Pakistan and Afghanistanistan.

Naturally it would seem most logicall if both these populations united with their brothers in the other countries.

What are pros and cons for a partition for All sides involved?

Yes I am Indian. No need to point IT out to me. But I am curious. Hope u dont mind my question.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

Ignore this Indic Troll everyone, he has nothing to contribute to us.

[UnknownUser]

I am No Troll Iblis.

Just been wondering.

Pashtuns identity and culture might prosper without Indic and Persian influence, in a Pashtunistan.

For Farsi speakers, their identity and heritage is bit by bit stolen by Iran on one side and supressed by non-Farsi speakers on the other sides. A central Asian farsi speaking country (Persian parts of Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Persian Half Afghanistan could in theory work. Being landlocked is what Central Asia had always been so No difference in that part.

Again this is No Troll attempt. Just a fair honest and Humble harmless question.

[maneatinglizard]

This question is one that only springs up in the minds of non-Afghans. Afghans understand that the Pashtun and Farsi-speaking populations of Afghanistan are not distinct entities, and so separating them is neither possible nor sensible.

A partition of Afghanistan on ethnic or linguistic grounds is impossible.

[Pakhton]

why should a indian troll for parsi and parsi imperialism?you parsiwans tried to divide afghanistan you remember what happend with you! the same is trying the usa with no success.if the usa leaves we will see how fast afghanistan will be united again lol
parsi and iranism has no big role in afghanistan

[Ironhide]

HAHA.. you AFGHANISTANIES are very biased.. See we pakistani pashtuns have no problem with punjabies either as you are comfortable with Tajiks.. both sides have to understand this... Pashtuns in Pakistan have to stand up for their rights and vice versa in case of pashtuns of Afghanistan...

[Pakhton]

HAHA.. you AFGHANISTANIES are very biased.. See we pakistani pashtuns have no problem with punjabies either as you are comfortable with Tajiks.. both sides have to understand this... Pashtuns in Pakistan have to stand up for their rights and vice versa in case of pashtuns of Afghanistan...

Pakistanis? you hazaras are funny folks

[Firdousi]

This question is one that only springs up in the minds of non-Afghans. Afghans understand that the Pashtun and Farsi-speaking populations of Afghanistan are not distinct entities, and so separating them is neither possible nor sensible.

A partition of Afghanistan on ethnic or linguistic grounds is impossible.

I believe the main problem with the partition of Afghanistan is that its not really an ideal solution to our problems. The very nature of the Western nation-state is behind our fail. Afghanistan will always be a failed state. Won´t work. Never worked. But I do not know how creating more nation-states will improve our situation.

Nationalism is extremely dangerous. Now there seems to be a consensus between non Pashtun nationalists against Pashtuns. But once Pashtuns are gone, they will start killing each other. Its a divisive and dangerous ideology. We need to unite under some more universal and unifying ideology. Honestly speaking other than Islam I can not think of any other unifying ideology right now.

[UnknownUser]

I believe the main problem with the partition of Afghanistan is that its not really an ideal solution to our problems. The very nature of the Western nation-state is behind our fail. Afghanistan will always be a failed state. Won´t work. Never worked. But I do not know how creating more nation-states will improve our situation.

Nationalism is extremely dangerous. Now there seems to be a consensus between non Pashtun nationalists against Pashtuns. But once Pashtuns are gone, they will start killing each other. Its a divisive and dangerous ideology. We need to unite under some more universal and unifying ideology. Honestly speaking other than Islam I can not think of any other unifying ideology right now.

Pashtuns or others are not the problem. They are our bros. Closest to us in terms of genetics and looks.

I will say we are all in the same boat. Actually I would say our misery is caused by bigger fishes from far way oceans. Wether you go back to to Alexander the Gay, Arabs, Mongols, Turks, and now Western hegemony. All these cockroaches have roamed our lands without an invitation.

[Pakhton]

dont worry parsiwan you and your accounts will soon see good old afghanistan wait for it just a little bit longer you parsiwans have to give the afghans a little bit time to bring the usa down from you modar i mean did the afghans not freed your modarland tajikistan uzbakistan half mongolia from soviets did they not freed you from britania and than if this work is finished the afghans will show you good friendship cant wait to see that

[UnknownUser]

dont worry parsiwan you and your accounts will soon see good old afghanistan wait for it just a little bit longer you parsiwans have to give the afghans a little bit time to bring the usa down from you modar i mean did the afghans not freed your modarland tajikistan uzbakistan half mongolia from soviets did they not freed you from britania and than if this work is finished the afghans will show you good friendship cant wait to see that

I love you too bro. You can come to my home we will have a good party, remeniscing the good old times. A good atan is a must. You must practise already. Dont dissapoint.

Edit:

Dont insult modars. We all have them.

As far as I know we all know Americans too busy in taliban dominated areas. So much that even first Afghan prnstar has come from those areas. Your pride has been tainted. Your too busy with parsiwans, your women are flocking to west to ride white men in front of cameras and proudly making pakhto an international language by the force of pr0n. Lol

[Pakhton]

I love you too bro. You can come to my home we will have a good party, remeniscing the good old times. A good atan is a must. You must practise already. Dont dissapoint.

dont worry i will be there hope you have also a place for my brothers hazaragak lol

[UnknownUser]

dont worry i will be there hope you have also a place for my brothers hazaragak lol

Give me your and your bros adress, so that I can send invitation cards, bro.

I will make sure it will be the biggest saussage party in history. Alexander and his Greek armies would be envious. Hope you like saussages lol.

[Pakhton]

Give me your and your bros adress, so that I can send invitation cards, bro.

I will make sure it will be the biggest saussage party in history. Alexander and his Greek armies would be envious. Hope you like saussages lol.

we already visited you many times in your hiding place parsiwanak did you forgot it? hahahaha

[UnknownUser]

we already visited you many times in your hiding place parsiwanak did you forgot it? hahahaha

Yes, I remember. It was good times. We must get back at it again. Too long time has passed. Lol

We should never fight darling, I love you too much.