3% of ANA is Pashtun

[Elite Pakhtun]

Is this true?

Twitter

[Firdousi]

Is this true?

Twitter

As usual this is pure Pakistani propaganda for uneducated brainwashed Pakistanis.

Seven years ago Pashtuns made up 30% of ANA´s ethnic composition.

POLITICS: Tajik Grip on Afghan Army Signals New Ethnic War | Inter Press Service

Either way its none of Pakistanis business. When will Pakistanis realize that we don't want them to stick their dark noses into our internal issues? :D

[Elite Pakhtun]

That's from Vice media. That's US.

Your url is legit though. Still underrepresented relative to their population.

[marwat]

Is this true?

Twitter

this bhittani is some sort of kunii and gandu, who never tire to kiss some black ass. he has no self respect. he used to write article as how paksitan should capture wakhan corridor. or capture the whole afghanistan. he is active on defence.pk

Af-Pak - Destined For Conflict

Wakhan Corridor...An opportunity!

[Friends of Baloch]

this bhittani is some sort of kunii and gandu, who never tire to kiss some black ass. he has no self respect. he used to write article as how paksitan should capture wakhan corridor. or capture the whole afghanistan. he is active on defence.pk

Af-Pak - Destined For Conflict

Wakhan Corridor...An opportunity!

These pakis are so cringe i cant stop laughing at them while shaking my head at the same time. Its too embarrassing i couldnt finish reading all of these paki comments.

Flicking through the cringe fantasies of those 'pindi wala' on that dravidian forum leaves you feeling dirty for exposing yourself to their pakiness. And these are supposed to be the elite and "educated" pakis that have learned English and are connected to the establishment. Imagine the millions of stinking pakis that dont even know how to read or write let alone speak anything other than Urdu or Punjabi.

[Iblis_Efreetzai]

leaves you feeling dirty for exposing yourself to their pakiness.

This needs to be put on a T-shirt or bumper sticker.....or in the very least a meme.

[marwat]

[MENTION=19566]Elite Pakhtun[/MENTION]
here an old paper

The ANA, in particular, is plagued by ethnic and
regional imbalances and fissures that dampen
unit cohesion. Command positions within the
ANA are disproportionately filled with individuals
from the northern regions of Afghanistan, Tajiks
in particular. ISAF has made a substantial effort
to reduce the Tajik domination of command
posts. In 2008, approximately 70 percent of Afghan
commanders were Tajiks. As of 2012, that
number had been reduced to 40 percent. This
move was intended to appease ethnic Pashtuns
in Afghanistan, although even within the Pashtun
ethnic group there is an imbalance: the ANA has
disproportionately recruited Pashtuns from the
northern and central regions, with very few emanating
from the south (ibid.).

ref: (Smith et al., 2013; Jones and Crane, 2013: 7)
from the paper "The Afghan National Security Forces Beyond 2014: Will They Be Ready?"

[Elite Pakhtun]

[MENTION=19566]Elite Pakhtun[/MENTION]
here an old paper


ref: (Smith et al., 2013; Jones and Crane, 2013: 7)
from the paper "The Afghan National Security Forces Beyond 2014: Will They Be Ready?"

Ignore who posted the video in question. However, you and Firdousi both appear to be concurring that there's Tajik over-representation in the ANA.

Even your excerpt says the Pashtuns recruited are rarely from the south. Pashtuns are being bullied in the country where they are a majority. Very miserable situation.

[marwat]

Ignore who posted the video in question. However, you and Firdousi both appear to be concurring that there's Tajik over-representation in the ANA.

Even your excerpt says the Pashtuns recruited are rarely from the south. Pashtuns are being bullied in the country where they are a majority. Very miserable situation.

it says that the majority pashtun are recruited from the central and northern pashtun districts.

[Jamal120]

Ignore who posted the video in question. However, you and Firdousi both appear to be concurring that there's Tajik over-representation in the ANA.

Even your excerpt says the Pashtuns recruited are rarely from the south. Pashtuns are being bullied in the country where they are a majority. Very miserable situation.

You're reaching hard for this one, so now they have to be from the south?? You do realize Southern Pashtuns are generally more rural? obviously they're going to be less likely to join the ANA. Plus have you ever thought of Kuchi's, who are a nomadic people? Pakis so desperate knowing there has not been a single real Pashtun leader in Paki history, Ayub Khan was a Hindkowan btw so don't try to bring him up.

[Friends of Baloch]

Pashtuns are being bullied in the country where they are a majority. Very miserable situation.

I dont think so. More like Pashtuns and all other Afghans are bullying only the paki invaders and their collaborators.

[Charsi Malang]

This needs to be put on a T-shirt or bumper sticker.....or in the very least a meme.

Hahahahahahaha sareyo laga guzara ukkayee. Lol.

[Kakar-Wardak]

Why should they join a ****ty army, Under the command of a midget tajik and gay uzbek like dostum.

[Firdousi]

Ignore who posted the video in question. However, you and Firdousi both appear to be concurring that there's Tajik over-representation in the ANA.

Even your excerpt says the Pashtuns recruited are rarely from the south. Pashtuns are being bullied in the country where they are a majority. Very miserable situation.

So what? Whats is wrong about that? Tajiks are proud Afghans. They are dying for their land. So are Pashtuns. Afghan Army was under "Pashtun control" for most of history. Now its under "Tajik control". Nothing wrong about that.

Pashtuns are not oppressed in Afghanistan. Our current president is Pashtun. Our defense minister is Pashtun. Our national anthem is in Pashto. Non Pashtun Afghans are in Pashtun provinces fighting and dying in order to protect their Pashtun brothers and so on. Please stop spreading lies.

[Friends of Baloch]

Why should they join a ****ty army, Under the command of a midget tajik and gay uzbek like dostum.

Dostum has had no position in the ANA since 2013. He commands his own militia.