Pakistan to expel old Post-1951 Afghan immigrants from the country

[Smarty]

I can't believe you have no concern for your own people. It may be easy writing this as a kid who probably spent his entire life outside of Afghanistan. Do you have any idea how bad things were during the '90s? They're refugees who had nowhere to go. When you have a family, you have to make such difficult decisions. And most of them are still loyal to Afghanistan, I have no idea where you got those ideas from.

There is absolutely no justification for what the government is doing to these poor people.

In fact these Afghans whose citizenship is getting cancelled, are not war refugees but the ones who settled in Pakistan between 1951 and 1979, mostly nomad tribes. This makes it very outrageous. These families are established in Pakistan for as long as 6 decades and yet they are getting humiliated and expelled..........This is a thorough anti-Afghan policy and reply to Ashraf Ghani's friendly gestures

[tripledouble]

I read your entire comment. All you did was tell me about how some Afghans are rich punks. In the same way I can tell you about all the hard working, decent refugees I've met who faced some of the worst forms of discrimination. Just because you have a few bad apples doesn't mean you can target an entire community and constantly harass and degrade them.

so tell me, do afghans not look down on pakistanis since 1947, are they not conspiring for resurrection of Afghan empire?so why shouldn't pakistan not take notice of this creeping expansionism?today a refugee camp,tomorrow your neighborhood, the next day the border areas, then one province go down, then the next, before you know, we are living in Abdalis empire

so yeah, give them human right, give them citizenship, give them everything, i do not worry, but i won't give them the country

[Yousufzai]

so why shouldn't pakistan not take notice of this creeping expansionism?today a refugee camp,tomorrow your neighborhood, the next day the border areas, then one province go down, then the next, before you know, we are living in Abdalis empire

I don't even know how to respond to this, man. This is just extreme paranoia. We're talking about refugees and nomads, not some superpower.

so yeah, give them human right, give them citizenship, give them everything, i do not worry, but i won't give them the country

How is making sure they're not discriminated against and expelled collectively for no reason "giving them the country?"

[tripledouble]

I don't even know how to respond to this, man. This is just extreme paranoia. We're talking about refugees and nomads, not some superpower.



How is making sure they're not discriminated against and expelled collectively for no reason "giving them the country?"

bro you're being decieved by thos rosy cheeks and blue eyes, once they become powerful, they will play buzkashi with our heads like all the invaders of past......ofcourse you will be fine because you're pashtun, as a hazarewal, i am vary

[Yousufzai]

bro you're being decieved by thos rosy cheeks and blue eyes, once they become powerful, they will play buzkashi with our heads like all the invaders of past......ofcourse you will be fine because you're pashtun, as a hazarewal, i am vary

That is racist and ridiculous. Your fears are based on events that took place centuries ago.

[tripledouble]

That is racist and ridiculous. Your fears are based on events that took place centuries ago.

and they are not racist,........ wow

[Smarty]

That is racist and ridiculous. Your fears are based on events that took place centuries ago.

I doubt our ancestors played buzkushi with heads of Punjabis......... I want to share an interesting historical fact here. Rohilkhand region or katehr which is located in UP, was a Hindu majority region full of jungles before 18th century and islam didnt penetrated much into this area during times of delhi sultanates and mughals. It was conquered by Yusufzais in early 18th century and they turned it into a very agricultural zone by clearing the jungles and introducing their agricultural reforms and effective adminsitration. Not only Pashtuns got settled there but they also allowed large number of muslims from other communities to settle on their lands. Due to these Rohillas, the Rohilkhand turned into the region of UP with highest concentration of muslims. In 19th century Rohilkhand produced two school of thoughts of hanafi in south asia, Deoband and Bareilwi. Its the case also in rest of India. Highest concentration of muslims in India are found in those districts which were colonized by Afghans. Its because Afghans or Pashtuns, unlike Turks, set themselves as Jagirdars of rural areas and were source of strength and protection for muslim minority of india which had converted from Hinduism. Same is case in Punjab. In Hindu and Sikh majority portion of Punjab i.e east Punjab, only those districts had sizable muslim community which were colonies of Afghans. In fact Maler Kotla of East Punjab is still a muslim majority area. These desis owe a lot to Afghans but they wont admit it.

[Bengal_Tiger]

Luffy the highest number of Muslims in India are first in Kashmir and then in West Bengal.

[Smarty]

Luffy the highest number of Muslims in India are first in Kashmir and then in West Bengal.

The first muslim rulers of Kashmir , were swati pashtuns (not to be confused with yusufzais) from swat. Shah Mir Swati. They spread Islam in Kashmir.

[Bengal_Tiger]

The first muslim rulers of Kashmir , were swati pashtuns (not to be confused with yusufzais) from swat. Shah Mir Swati. They spread Islam in Kashmir.

I mentioned West Bengal having the highest number of Muslims on the Indian mainland (Kashmir is isolated and is a cultural extension of Pakistan)....


[MENTION=3580]asad71[/MENTION]

[Yousufzai]

and they are not racist,........ wow

Two wrongs don't make a right.

[Khostai]

I can't believe you have no concern for your own people. It may be easy writing this as a kid who probably spent his entire life outside of Afghanistan. Do you have any idea how bad things were during the '90s? They're refugees who had nowhere to go. When you have a family, you have to make such difficult decisions. And most of them are still loyal to Afghanistan, I have no idea where you got those ideas from.

There is absolutely no justification for what the government is doing to these poor people.

This poor people destroyed Afghanistan, they supported Pakistan in mindless jihad killing of inocent Afghans, I am sorry if I have no symphaty for traitors.

[Khostai]

Two wrongs don't make a right.

It does even now this people are the main source of suicide bombers. What goes around comes around.

[Yousufzai]

This poor people destroyed Afghanistan, they supported Pakistan in mindless jihad killing of inocent Afghans, I am sorry if I have no symphaty for traitors.

You seem to have a real problem distinguishing between the actions of a tiny minority and the entire community, I've noticed.

[Khostai]

You seem to have a real problem distinguishing between the actions of a tiny minority and the entire community, I've noticed.

I have met several Pashtuns from pakistan, the couwards that could not go and do jiahd all supported those animals openly and even made jokes about how they subdued people in Afghanistan and taught them real Islam. The real Islam for them is stoning and executing people in stadions. If that is not enough they all approved suicide bombing and said it is justified, suicide bombs were inocent people die even today.

Till this day I have never met a Pashtun who grew up or went to Pakistan that condemnd taliban and the suicide bombers, not one single I have met that said that suicide bombers in Afghanistan is a bad thing.

So no, I am not going to feel sorry for them.

Even the ones that did not do the crimes support the animals that come to Afghanistan and kill my people.