Why Afghans hate Pakistan

[DSM0305]

One will not go one day without hearing Pakistani ask ''why do these ungrateful Afghans hate us, we do so much for them''. The question isn't why Afghans hate Pakistanis, but rather why shouldn't they... Now let me explain it by making a comparison with recent event.

The Peshawar school attack that occurred recently is one of Pakistan's deadliest attack so far. Look at how angry people become in Pakistan, and what kind of emotional reaction came from the people.

Now my question is, have you Pakistanis ever thought about what Afghans feel... The Peshawar attack is Afghan daily day. Every day in Afghanistan these kind of attacks happens. For the past 14 years, this was what Afghan felt.

Now imagine Pakistanis say ''good Taliban and bad Taliban''. Basically calling people who conducted attacks similar to Peshawar attack 'good people'. Have you ever thought what Afghans felt when a mother lost her child, or child losing his parent, and the child had to take care of his 5 siblings at age 10... Then suddenly Pakistanis shouting and telling people that those people who did this act was good people....

Can anyone in his right mind wonder why Afghans hate Pakistanis... Mothers losing her children and husbands, children losing their parents, and to put salt in the wound, people in Pakistan telling everyone that the one who killed them were good people...

To make the matter worse. Pakistani establishment/military harboring the Taliban and recruiting poor children for suicide attacks... basically creating a circle of misery.

It does not help when you shout Pashtun slogans and pretending to supports Pashtuns in Afghanistan, because you're doing the exact opposite.
Lets review what Taliban does.
- Attacks only in Pashtun dominated areas
- Preventing only Pashtuns from joining the army or the government
- Preventing infrastructure to be build in Pashtun dominated areas.
- Increase the drugs in Pashtun dominated areas and making their income dependent on it
- Destroying what ever little infrastructure there may be in Pashtun areas.
- Preventing investment in Pashtun areas
- Lowering the marked value in Pashtun areas
- Preventing Pashtuns from education

Basically Pakistan have been putting Pashtuns down economically, socially, militarily, educationally and politically. All those areas which under normal circumstance Pashtuns would have dominated. Empty slogans of 'supporting' Pashtuns aren't helping them, but rather your action of supporting Taliban have undermined Pashtuns in every way.

So Pakistanis, think for yourself for a moment and ask yourself, is the hatred toward Pakistan justified or not.

- Being bombed by USA/nato
- Being bombed by ANA
- Being bombed by Pakistani army
- Being bombed by Taliban

All that due to your support of Taliban, and your 'good and bad' Taliban policy.

Despite all you have done against Pashtun in Afghanistan. I have to add, Pashtuns in Afghanistan doesn't hate you or despise you. They simply want to live in peace once again.

[kunar1990]

I agree with most except the last line

[ghumbasa]

One will not go one day without hearing Pakistani ask ''why do these ungrateful Afghans hate us, we do so much for them''. The question isn't why Afghans hate Pakistanis, but rather why shouldn't they... Now let me explain it by making a comparison with recent event.

The Peshawar school attack that occurred recently is one of Pakistan's deadliest attack so far. Look at how angry people become in Pakistan, and what kind of emotional reaction came from the people.

Now my question is, have you Pakistanis ever thought about what Afghans feel... The Peshawar attack is Afghan daily day. Every day in Afghanistan these kind of attacks happens. For the past 14 years, this was what Afghan felt.

Now imagine Pakistanis say ''good Taliban and bad Taliban''. Basically calling people who conducted attacks similar to Peshawar attack 'good people'. Have you ever thought what Afghans felt when a mother lost her child, or child losing his parent, and the child had to take care of his 5 siblings at age 10... Then suddenly Pakistanis shouting and telling people that those people who did this act was good people....

Can anyone in his right mind wonder why Afghans hate Pakistanis... Mothers losing her children and husbands, children losing their parents, and to put salt in the wound, people in Pakistan telling everyone that the one who killed them were good people...

To make the matter worse. Pakistani establishment/military harboring the Taliban and recruiting poor children for suicide attacks... basically creating a circle of misery.

It does not help when you shout Pashtun slogans and pretending to supports Pashtuns in Afghanistan, because you're doing the exact opposite.
Lets review what Taliban does.
- Attacks only in Pashtun dominated areas
- Preventing only Pashtuns from joining the army or the government
- Preventing infrastructure to be build in Pashtun dominated areas.
- Increase the drugs in Pashtun dominated areas and making their income dependent on it
- Destroying what ever little infrastructure there may be in Pashtun areas.
- Preventing investment in Pashtun areas
- Lowering the marked value in Pashtun areas
- Preventing Pashtuns from education

Basically Pakistan have been putting Pashtuns down economically, socially, militarily, educationally and politically. All those areas which under normal circumstance Pashtuns would have dominated. Empty slogans of 'supporting' Pashtuns aren't helping them, but rather your action of supporting Taliban have undermined Pashtuns in every way.

So Pakistanis, think for yourself for a moment and ask yourself, is the hatred toward Pakistan justified or not.

- Being bombed by USA/nato
- Being bombed by ANA
- Being bombed by Pakistani army
- Being bombed by Taliban

All that due to your support of Taliban, and your 'good and bad' Taliban policy.

Despite all you have done against Pashtun in Afghanistan. I have to add, Pashtuns in Afghanistan doesn't hate you or despise you. They simply want to live in peace once again.

We too ve bombings on daily basis...masjids being blown up,people killed on friday,markets etc..All done by black water and its alleys that has bases in afghanistan..So we can ask the same question but we dont coz its not important.Some ways are better to be parted.

[Friends of Baloch]

Every day in Afghanistan these kind of attacks happens. For the past 14 years, this was what Afghan felt.

It is even more than 14 years. Taliban is now 20 years old and before that Pakis were pushing Hezb-e Hekmatyar to create chaos in Afghanistan.

In the 1990s Paki establishment openly praised Taliban rule would bring stability to Afghanistan but this same Paki establishment has always been staunchly opposed to this very same Taliban style "stability" and rule for their own country, especially for Punjab.

Why these pakis say it is OK for for Taliban law and rule over Afghans but are against such law and rule for pakis?

Pakis wanted Afghans to live without television, music, dance, culture (Taliban banned all these in 1990s) but for Pakis they wanted to have their mujra, paan, bhangra, heera mandi and all else for so-called "Islamic" pakistan.

B_stards.

Hypocrite pakis have played Islam card one time too many. Now they finally are being punished for it and will be destroyed.

[ghumbasa]

It is even more than 14 years. Taliban is now 20 years old and before that Pakis were pushing Hezb-e Hekmatyar to create chaos in Afghanistan.

In the 1990s Paki establishment openly praised Taliban rule would bring stability to Afghanistan but this same Paki establishment has always been staunchly opposed to this very same Taliban style "stability" and rule for their own country, especially for Punjab.

Why these pakis say it is OK for for Taliban law and rule over Afghans but are against such law and rule for pakis?

Pakis wanted Afghans to live without television, music, dance, culture (Taliban banned all these in 1990s) but for Pakis they wanted to have their mujra, paan, bhangra, heera mandi and all else for so-called "Islamic" pakistan.

B_stards.

Hypocrite pakis have played Islam card one time too many. Now they finally are being punished for it and will be destroyed.

And western puppets play ethnicity card.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Sir,you have followed my post in the past 2 years,and you must have atleast come to know that i don't even consider talibs as human,let alone supporting them to kill innocents in Afghanistan.

Yes once,back when i was kid,i used to defend talibs and i regret why had i done so even as a kid.

I know that not pakistani,ISI,NDS or anyone else has given more damage to pashtuns than talibs have done.

Sir,i also don't care who hates us,it doesn't matter infact hate is common between neighbours.

As an example just look at India or Pakistan hate,China and japan hate,Germany and the rest of the europe,russia and the west,iran and gulf countries,israel and the muslim world.

so hate doesn't matter.atleast i don't care who hates us.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Now why i think afghan hate Pakistan?

Because somehow Pakistan got the KPK,FATA and northern Balochistan,which indeed was afghan territory.

i believe this is the primary subject of hate.Not supporting the talibs as majority of the pashtuns in afghansitan support talibans,infact even those living in Pakistan

[Khostai]

Now why i think afghan hate Pakistan?

Because somehow Pakistan got the KPK,FATA and northern Balochistan,which indeed was afghan territory.

i believe this is the primary subject of hate.Not supporting the talibs as majority of the pashtuns in afghansitan support talibans,infact even those living in Pakistan

Not true, most Afghans don't care about FATA and KPK, becuase it was made clear to us that those people don't want to join Afghanistan, so we let that dead horse go. And we hate taliban as much as we hate dirty porkistan. And we hate Pakistan for its hypocricy, you support taliban, a subhuman group in our country and send terrorists on daily basis. Now you got what you did to us for many years, I hope you learned your lesson and will stop your terrorist activities, but knowing pakis, I am sure you will never change, unless somebody destroys your un-holly land.

Pakistan is like Mordor of the Lord of the Rings with Imran Khan as Saruman. :P
Your army of filthy orks (the talibs) are now rebeling and eating your own people.

[ghumbasa]

Not true, most Afghans don't care about FATA and KPK, becuase it was made clear to us that those people don't want to join Afghanistan, so we let that dead horse go. And we hate taliban as much as we hate dirty porkistan. And we hate Pakistan for its hypocricy, you support taliban, a subhuman group in our country and send terrorists on daily basis. Now you got what you did to us for many years, I hope you learned your lesson and will stop your terrorist activities, but knowing pakis, I am sure you will never change, unless somebody destroys your un-holly land.

Pakistan is like Mordor of the Lord of the Rings with Imran Khan as Saruman. :P
Your army of filthy orks (the talibs) are now rebeling and eating your own people.

Army has sold out generals...some...not everyone.Many tries to protect people.Besides seeing their good and bad sides both...i dont generalise them.Had i not seen both sides i would ve believed propaganda propagated here...

You guys do ve itch about kpk and fata ...evident by your last paragraph.

[Khostai]

Army has sold out generals...some...not everyone.Many tries to protect people.Besides seeing their good and bad sides both...i dont generalise them.Had i not seen both sides i would ve believed propaganda propagated here...

You guys do ve itch about kpk and fata ...evident by your last paragraph.

You can have KPK and FATA, Afghans don't care, like really its all yours, those people are already porkified and useless to us, they woudl only be a burden on Afghanistan.

Its funny how you don't generelise on your filthy amry of orks, but do discriminate on whole of Afghanistan. You are such racist and a nationalist, you are trully disgusting creature.

[ghumbasa]

You can have KPK and FATA, Afghans don't care, like really its all yours, those people are already porkified and useless to us, they woudl only be a burden on Afghanistan.

Its funny how you don't generelise on your filthy amry of orks, but do discriminate on whole of Afghanistan. You are such racist and a nationalist, you are trully disgusting creature.

My thinking are mirror image thinkings of the likes of you....the moment you change it positively...we too ll.But i vnt seen ANA serving pashtuns...nope.

[Loy Afghanistan]

You can have KPK and FATA, Afghans don't care, like really its all yours, those people are already porkified and useless to us, they woudl only be a burden on Afghanistan.

Its funny how you don't generelise on your filthy amry of orks, but do discriminate on whole of Afghanistan. You are such racist and a nationalist, you are trully disgusting creature.

Grana wroor! Ignore these porkis/punjabis aka actors who play Pashtuns! I have them on ignore list. Just debate with true Pashtuns, don't waste your time on trolls. These people are not even Pashtuns, in their blood its porki-punjabi blood. In ours its just pure blood!

[jankhan]

The people of Afghanistan are suffering from these incidents for the last few decades. Pakistani people have just seen a glimps of it where kids were killed brutality and inhumanly and mothers were deprived.
Actually Pakistani nation as a whole was taking these incidents in Afghanistan light and considering just stories but when it happens on their own land, now they are feeling the pain. But still the establishment is blind, deaf and cowardly acting and stubborn.
Please don't interfere others' matter.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Not true, most Afghans don't care about FATA and KPK, becuase it was made clear to us that those people don't want to join Afghanistan, so we let that dead horse go. And we hate taliban as much as we hate dirty porkistan. And we hate Pakistan for its hypocricy, you support taliban, a subhuman group in our country and send terrorists on daily basis. Now you got what you did to us for many years, I hope you learned your lesson and will stop your terrorist activities, but knowing pakis, I am sure you will never change, unless somebody destroys your un-holly land.

Pakistan is like Mordor of the Lord of the Rings with Imran Khan as Saruman. :P
Your army of filthy orks (the talibs) are now rebeling and eating your own people.

Sorry but i had already told you as to why Afghanistani hate pakistan.

It is true that Pakistani pashtuns has cared about Afghanistanis pashtuns but not anymore.atleast not after the peshawar attack when #indiawithpakistan was trending in twitter,the afghanistanis on internet were celebrating with joys,yes it is true that not all of them celebrated but most of them celebrated.

Just compare the treatment of Afghan refugees in Pakistan and than in iran.

In iran,they are not allowed to study alongside the iranians,they are being forced to even eat bathroom dirt and hell public parks has placard mentioning Afghans are not allowed.

In Pakistan,they are treated equally with exception of few cases and the treatment is not only limited to pashtun regions but even in Punjab and the rest of Pakistan,they are treated equally(may be a exception exist),they can study in our institutes,hell even the top university in Pakistan has reserves seats for Afghanistanis.

Anyway i will also start a thread as to why people of Pakistan now hate Afghanistan

[Karachi]

who doesn't hate pakistan, i guess that is a better question