DEBATE: Islam isthe root cause of backwardness in Pashtun society

[Nadir Shah]

You have to visit rural Afghanistan and talk to Pashtuns. Make sure you tell them you are a Marxist.

You will find out where taliban hail from.

Malgariya, the Marxist Khalqis were predominantly from Loya Paktiya. Are all the people of Loya Paktia marxists?

[erlangner]

Americans are shoving big sticks in the rectum of random innocent Pashtuns in Bagram. And your type of secular ghani khan worshiping Afghans are willing to fight Mullahs.

Proves where your priorities are.

I am a realistic person, wrong is wrong. This aazab on Afghanistan is due to mullahs, and all this world came here, because we had this and that bloody terrorists and jihadis of the world.
When it will so, then americans will come and will do what they want, they are nemies, but what to do with the mullah, who is destroying the country himself.
I dont know your philosoph. But perhaps Allah created your creed for destruction.

[شمله ور خراساني]

Malgariya, the Marxist Khalqis were predominantly from Loya Paktiya. Are all the people of Loya Paktia marxists?

How many of those Marxist can walk without American escort now?

Go to Wazi Zadran, Tor Khel, Said Karam, Zurmat, Jyani Khel and see how many marxist there are.

I know most khalqis and parchamis personally. Holland and germany are filled with them.

They are a small minority in Paktia. They are children of rich people who studied in Kabul. Or they are children of tribals who are taken from their homes by force during Zahir Shah's rule to attend military academy so they become officers in service.

But in the academy, and in University of Kabul, many Marxist preachers were brainwashing them. This is how they became Marxists.

But back home, they have no place.

Take Manukai Mangal as an example. He was a Parchami general. He killed thousands of people in 1988-90 in Nengarhar.

He cant go back to Paktia. His own tribe will skin him alive and drag him all over the area.

[شمله ور خراساني]

I am a realistic person, wrong is wrong. This aazab on Afghanistan is due to mullahs, and all this world came here, because we had this and that bloody terrorists and jihadis of the world.
When it will so, then americans will come and will do what they want, they are nemies, but what to do with the mullah, who is destroying the country himself.
I dont know your philosoph. But perhaps Allah created your creed for destruction.

You have memorized poetry of an alcoholic pervert and you keep repeating his nasty sexually tinted poetry glorifying fornication, sodomy, alcohol and shirk.

And you are telling me that my creed is created for distruction?

[شمله ور خراساني]

Quite a few other things, holy books and holy lives are sexually tinged. You should tread carefully here.

what are you trying to say tavarish marxist?

[Nadir Shah]

what are you trying to say tavarish marxist?

Malgariya, I think you know perfectly well what I am trying to say here.

[شمله ور خراساني]

Malgariya, I think you know perfectly well what I am trying to say here.

no i dont. speak up.

[شمله ور خراساني]

Malgariya, I don't see how any of us can learn from this. I just think you should respect Pashtun figures more than Arab imperialists.

If a Pashtun figure writes poetry about fornication, alcohol and shirk, then I invoke allah's wrath on him.

[erlangner]

Mr Sangar, It is a reality we are seeing brutal mullahs with AK47 every time on their shoudlers, killing, slaughtering, using suiciders, and during their peace era, beating women, sexually abusing young boys at madrassas, and which crime they did not do. therefore we observed the destruction. But it is a pitty that they claim to be the wakeel of Allah on this arth, although things are opposite.

[شمله ور خراساني]

Mr Sangar, It is a reality we are seeing brutal mullahs with AK47 every time on their shoudlers, killing, slaughtering, using suiciders, and during their peace era, beating women, sexually abusing young boys at madrassas, and which crime they did not do. therefore we observed the destruction. But it is a pitty that they claim to be the wakeel of Allah on this arth, although things are opposite.

you are lying.

[Nadir Shah]

If a Pashtun figure writes poetry about fornication, alcohol and shirk, then I invoke allah's wrath on him.

Malgariya, If you do not want to follow Ghani Khan's words, you are at complete liberty to do so. But there are others who consider his words one of the best pieces of poetry. They have the right to follow him/it. No?

[erlangner]

you are lying.

Ya you are the only one telling the truth, and all other are telling lies.
Dear face the truth.

[شمله ور خراساني]

Ya you are the only one telling the truth, and all other are telling lies.
Dear face the truth.

I have no interest in lying. Because Allah is my witness at all times. Why should I lie? I believe in the hereafter, therefore I dont want to be punished for telling lies.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

you are lying.

Dear Sangar

Your from Holland, What do you know what is going on in Pakhtunkhwa

Why dont you visit Pakhtunkhwa and ask the locals and they will tell you the same.

Of Course boys are molestered in these Madrassahs. I thinks its very arrogant of you to call others liars when you yourself havnt even been to Pakhtunkhwa.

Young boys are molestered, especially those who are sent for suicide bombing missions, they are drugged and brainwashed psychologically, you watch these Alqueda and Taliban videos like a American watching his hollywood movies and you think thoese children are sincere in what they do????

As I said so many times to you, go to Pakhtunkhwa and see the reality youself.

I guess your faith in yourself and beleifs has prevented you from seeing the truth which i couldnt be bothered about, but the day you see it you will as usual ignore it and cover it up.

Kind Regards

[شمله ور خراساني]

Malgariya, If you do not want to follow Ghani Khan's words, you are at complete liberty to do so. But there are others who consider his words one of the best pieces of poetry. They have the right to follow him/it. No?

no they dont. They should follow Islam. Because Islam will save them from hell fire. Ghani Khan will only seduce them to join him in hell fire.