Amirul Mumineen Mullah Omar Mujahid (hafidhahullah) tells his lifestory in his own vo

[JAMALUDEEN]

go through the checklist and present it... it would be good to learn something new.

i keep an open mind..

my dear brother.

[کیش]

That's proof enough? We dont even know if "said relatives" even exist, you're presenting what is called hearsay.

What makes your statement not biased?

It's not white-washed and made for media.

You want some bad press for Taliban too?

Once my brother-in-law was in school during the Talib regime. They were in their lunch break, when a student (teenaged) complained about the food. A Talib came by a shot him point blank, for protesting.

How about the accounts of all the people I know who worked with NATO in their remote fire bases, and FOB's, and the ones who talked with recently arrested Talib's? For the new Talib generation?

[ScimitarXEdge]

Ok how about this I'll make it easy for you .....here's a list of possible sources nd references

You type "yes or no" next to what you would accept as authentic or not authentic respectively.


Photographs
Video footage
Human RIghts Report
Researched Books about the topic
Human Rights Organization reports
Testimonials of women in print
testimonials of women in video
testimonials of women recorded



which ones would be authentic for you?

[JAMALUDEEN]

They could all be authentic or not, if you go through the checklist.. i presented my dear brother..

[ScimitarXEdge]

It's not white-washed and made for media.

You want some bad press for Taliban too?

Once my brother-in-law was in school during the Talib regime. They were in their lunch break, when a student (teenaged) complained about the food. A Talib came by a shot him point blank, for protesting.

How about the accounts of all the people I know who worked with NATO in their remote fire bases, and FOB's, and the ones who talked with recently arrested Talib's? For the new Talib generation?

But we dont know we have NO way of knowing anything you say exists Like I said it's hearsay.

[ScimitarXEdge]

They could all be authentic or not, if you go through the checklist.. i presented my dear brother..

which ones would you accept as authentic and how would you go about corroborating them "brother"

[کیش]

People say the Taliban are filled with Pakistani Pashtuns. They can get any more wrong then that.

I know someone who served 3 Years in FOB's and fire bases all over Kunar and Nuristan. He said majority Talib's are Afghan Pashtun, then the ones over the border. The remaining <1% are Arabs, Chechens, etc

Scimitar you have no knowledge of Afghanistan. Hearsay whatever, Its still more authentic then whether you get your info from.

[JAMALUDEEN]

which ones would you accept as authentic and how would you go about corroborating them "brother"

My dear brother, i don't cherry pick.. types of sources as long as they follow the guidelines presented in the checklist..

[ScimitarXEdge]

You also know the tooth fairy, Santa Clause and Elvis I'm sure. Anyone can say they know some people who know some people.

what documentation do you have?

[ScimitarXEdge]

My dear brother, i don't cherry pick.. types of sources as long as they follow the guidelines presented in the checklist..

Great we're gaining ground; how would you determine which evidence is legit or not .....explained what you would do when presented with evidence and what sort of efforts you would make to verify it is real.

[Ghundal]

Watch out guys his about to show you video footage - the falsified CNN video (Soldats favorite) which has been disproven on several levels

He has been reluctant to post it due to the weakness, but his ... About to

[Ghundal]

My dear brother, i don't cherry pick.. types of sources as long as they follow the guidelines presented in the checklist..

I hope you enjoy a very long and circular/redundant debate.

You might even start debating about the type of cereal you eat

[ScimitarXEdge]

Not at all, I just know my environment; I know how stupidly obsessed with protecting Pashtun pride people like Jamaluddin are that he thinks it's impossible for a Pashtun male to rape women, it makes people like you and Jamaluddin feel uncomfortable so to ease your own conscience you invent some excuse to evade the moral repercussions of such information

[کیش]

You also know the tooth fairy, Santa Clause and Elvis I'm sure. Anyone can say they know some people who know some people.

what documentation do you have?

Lol, you said earlier I have relatives working with ISAF, and here I am giving you first hand accounts of their observations and ignoring it.

You are living at the North Pole my older brother.

[ScimitarXEdge]

I hope you enjoy a very long and circular/redundant debate.

You might even start debating about the type of cereal you eat

then why are you here? run along and let men handle the discussion sissypants.