Fake and real future MAPS of Pashtunlands

[graveyardofempires]

^
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahha
this guy is from tajikistan who is desperate

[ComradePashtun]

You just need open your eyes, dear brother. No matter what Tajiks are. Today they are one nation. They live in Afghanistan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan. Every Persian-speaker in Afghanistan is known beeing a Tajik or Persians or whatever, except Hazaras. That´s all and you can´t change facts.

Listen brother, stop banging on some non-entity which I refude to recognise and I certainly wont pay it any tribue. Tajik is not an ethnicity or a nation. Facts will remain to be facts about who Tajiks originally are which I have desrcibed them to you, so accept that. Tajikistan is not even a country, in Uzbakistan Uzbak nationalism is more coherent and makes sense, in Afghanistan Badakhshi and Heratis are are differnt as Uzbak and Hazaras.

I am not the one chaning facts, it is you who is doing that.

[Albani_Rahmat_Kabulzada]

^
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahha
this guy is from tajikistan who is desperate

The population of Herat numbers approximately 397,500.[19] The exact figures on ethnic groups is unavailable but most sources state that Persian-speaking Tajiks are the main inhabitants of the city, and are roughly the same as the Persians of eastern Iran.[20][21] According to a 2003 National Geographic suggested estimate, Tajiks form about 85% of the city population.Pashto-speaking Pashtuns come second at 10%, followed by Shia Hazaras at 2%, Uzbeks at 2%, and Turkmens at 1%.[22]

http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/ngm/0311/feature2/images/mp_download.2.pdf

The population of the province is estimated at 1,762,157 people. Persian-speaking Tajik form the majority.[3] 98% of the population speak Dari Persian[4] others speaks Pashto, Turkmen or Uzbek.

http://www.mrrd.gov.af/nabdp/provincial%20profiles/herat%20pdp%20provincial%20profile.pdf

[graveyardofempires]

in Afghanistan if you call them tajiks they will feel discriminated and when they do refer to themselves the clearly say they are tajik and people from tajikistan are tajikistani.
so piss off mr tajokistani

[ComradePashtun]

How can that be? In Herat you won´t be able to find any Pashtuns speaking Pashtu. Only some Pashtuns in some isolated villages do. The Pashtuns population in Herat is lesser than 12% brother. Herat is not only a tajikficated city but also a Tajik province. Or call it a Farsiwan province.

Listen you joker, your types have barely been aourd Afghanistan or know what is what. You should go and visit Herat, I say this because I have a large family and relation with the provice. No less than 80% of the province is Pashtun, I am not talking about the city. Farsiwan Heratis don't consider themselves Tajiks, Tajik is a non-entity.

[Albani_Rahmat_Kabulzada]

So what are their ethnicity than if not Tajik? They are no Pashtuns and no Hazaras. Who are Saleh, Husseini, Abdullah, Qanuni?

[graveyardofempires]

So what are their ethnicity than if not Tajik? They are no Pashtuns and no Hazaras. Who are Saleh, Husseini, Abdullah, Qanuni?

traitors!

[Albani_Rahmat_Kabulzada]

traitors!

What if they would be Pashtuns? And why traitors? Because there is no other nationality allowed in Afghanistan except Afghan as citizen?

[ComradePashtun]

Abdullah is claiming to be a Pashtun. Take him, he is a non-entity as the very derogatory word "Tajik". lol

[ComradePashtun]

Graver, stop being .... let the guy talk.

[ComradePashtun]

Why do Tajiks like Abdullah and Karmal claim to be Pashtuns?

[graveyardofempires]

What if they would be Pashtuns? And why traitors? Because there is no other nationality allowed in Afghanistan except Afghan as citizen?

they are Afghans and if they were pashtuns they would be traitors as well.

[ComradePashtun]

Instead of fighting with each other, various communities in the South-Central Asia (Afghanistan, Pakistan, other CA states probably) should find a way to resolve the political issues affecting their relations and a regional order/contract that would be to the benefit of all.

No one is fighting. Relax

[graveyardofempires]

Why do Tajiks like Abdullah and Karmal claim to be Pashtuns?

i was in Afghanistan and saw his election capagne picture next to Mirwais Hotak ,now thats called desperate.

and all up sudden he became pashtun for votes.

[Albani_Rahmat_Kabulzada]

Why do Tajiks like Abdullah and Karmal claim to be Pashtuns?

Karmal never claimed that. His father did it because non-Pashtuns were not allowed to go for ministries, army, police officiers etc. But such people also overthrow the old system and it is even thought they used the Khalqi party against Daud and his family.