Fake and real future MAPS of Pashtunlands

[ComradePashtun]

Why should Pashtuns who aren't happy with Pakistan give up their land, and move west to Afghanistan. Doesn't that show defeat to the Punjabies?

Peshawer was also used as a capital for Afghans.

Panjabis own them any way. It is beyond defeat, but a colony.

[KingKhan]

They are even a burden on Pakistan, they contribute less than they take from Pakistan, they are just a strategic liability just to keep the rest of Pakistan intact. But for Afghanistan they are of absolutely no value.

No value? KP/FATA is Afghanistan, the other half of it. Peshawer was a capital for half the year, and it's a burden now?

It's a good thing only fools have this opinion.

[graveyardofempires]

^
refrrain from non sense
we love our brethern from pukhtunkhwa and LOY AFGHANISTAN belongs to all.

[ComradePashtun]

first of all take those poor afghanis suffering in pashtunkhwa camps then the rest will follow.
why would someone leave his land to its enemies?
can a true pashtun do this?
pashtunkhwa is ours and we live and die here.You can call it pakistan to please your friends but for us it is pashtunkhwa nothing more.

You are 200% right, we need to take those reugees back. Lets pray that the war ends so we can take them back soon. Inshallah it wont be an issue.

The rest is good for you, good luck.

[ComradePashtun]

No value? KP/FATA is Afghanistan, the other half of it. Peshawer was a capital for half the year, and it's a burden now?

It's a good thing only fools have this opinion.

Ok, you tell me, what value does the FATA/KP have? One of the main reason the British Indian authority chose to not let it be independant was because it could not sustain itself economically and hence could be a strategic threat and could threaten the rest of India.

As for the capital, it had more or less to do with the kings enjoying warmer wheather there in winter. That is why it was called "winter" capital, not literal capital.

[KingKhan]

Ok, you tell me, what value does the FATA/KP have? One of the main reason the British Indian authority chose to not let it be independant was because it could not sustain itself economically and hence could be a strategic threat and could threaten the rest of India.

As for the capital, it had more or less to do with the kings enjoying warmer wheather there in winter. That is why it was called "winter" capital, not literal capital.

What value does it have? Are you serious. It's home to 25 million Pashtuns that's what value it has. It constitutes half of the real Afghanistan.

[ComradePashtun]

I didn't ask you for the number of people, what strategic and economic value does it have? Exactly, with little economic base those 25 millions contribute less to Pakistan than it takes from it, that is why cities like Karachi is swamped by migrants from KP and as a result there is economic civil war that is threatening the security and economic wellbeing of Pakistan itself and its financial hub.

[KingKhan]

I didn't as you for the number of people, what strategic and economic value does it have? Exactly, with little economic base those 25 millions contribute less to Pakistan than it takes from it, that is why cities like Karachi is swamped by migrants from KP and the whole economic civil war etc.

Your views are not important, and nobody has this opinion (unless their Parsiwaans).

25 million people is a lot, If they get proper education and are not second class citizens skies the limit.

"Afghanistan has prospered so much in the last decade"
Yea in the drugs, corruption and Bacha Bazi market

Afghanistan will keep falling, until they wake up and recognize that they were stronger/smarter when KP/FATA were with them.

[graveyardofempires]

sog jarey aw ka khandey
Loy Afghanistan

[Nokia_Apridy]

Pa naseb ma shaa....ror

[Naveed Safi]

You will die for a 'motherland' where your people barely represent 12% of the total population and 88% are foreigners? Tajikistan is also Muslim, why don't you consider Tajikistan your homeland if you think that all Muslims are one nation? Your adopted 'motherland' is bombing your actual motherland and is spreading fire in it.

Open your eyes.

i am sorry to say that you have a very poor knowledge we represent 97% of our country population. in our country there is no pukhtun sindhi punjabi and baloch we are all pakistani and we r proud of it.

[ComradePashtun]

King Khan!

Yes call it what ever you want. Only some areas of Afghanistan are as bad as FATA. The rest has so much to offer and has prospered alot. Things are moving at breakneck speed in Afghanistan, all we need is security. Above all, Afghanistan's potential is as a country, with its strategic location being the land bridge and abundance of resources and relatively less population.

25 millions is alot of people for a region that has nothing to offer. That is why I said it is a strategic liability for Pakistan, look at the economic civil war in Karachi.

What value does number have? Forget about telling me if they could be educated in the future.

[Naveed Safi]

Willing to die for nationalism, what a shame

it will be a shame for u but for me its a pride

[ComradePashtun]

A shame and haplessness faked as a pride. lol

[Toramana]

I think instead of fighting here with each other, we Pashtuns from Pakistan and Afghanistan better separate. It would be a good idea if Pakhtunkhwa Pashtuns move to www.pukhtun.com or any other forum (is there any forum out there?). That also has a good forum. At least, it will reduce some friction we see here.