Rally against reconciliation/compromise with Taliban

[ghundal]

this was mostly a bunch of criminal leaders attempting to stoke ethnic divisions in the country. Nothing results from such a silly protests. It appears these clowns are begging for civil war- a civil war that WILL not happen Too bad for them.

[MDresden]

well pashtun make the biggest tribe about 40% - 44% a conservative estimate, tajiks (parsiwan) 25% - 27%, hazara, 9%, uzbek 6% - 8% and there are other minorities like nuristani, turkman, baloch and others.

normal refer to themselves only as afghan, but when asked further then they might talk about what tribe they are from.

Don't know the individual tribes mentioned, but thanks for the clarification.

[MDresden]

this was mostly a bunch of criminal leaders attempting to stoke ethnic divisions in the country. Nothing results from such a silly protests. It appears these clowns are begging for civil war- a civil war that WILL not happen Too bad for them.

Why are you poking fun at Afghans, especially after them voicing their opinion. I think this is a big deal for them.

[ghundal]

do you think the ordinary citizens of balkh, herat and other northern and western provinces are pro taliban? is ismael khan a bad person? what about atta? how can you speak on behalf of other afghans?

Resistance to foreigners has reached the North in fact, so what does that say. Recent scholarly work by Dr. Schuerer points towards a non-Pashtun element of the resistance which is essentially has the same goals of independence.

Dr. Schuerer is an expert, and a former CIA operative.

[MDresden]

Ghundal seems to me to support the opression of the Afghan people by the authority and ruthless acts of those people claiming to be Taliban.

[ghundal]

Why are you poking fun at Afghans, especially after them voicing their opinion. I think this is a big deal for them.

Saleh and Abdullah Abdullah have pocketed huge sums of money, and committed massive fraud. They also empower criminal war lords with US support.

They have defeated their own objectives by their own actions.

[khyaal]

Ghundal seems to me to support the opression of the Afghan people by the authority and ruthless acts of those people claiming to be Taliban.

He is a Paki.

[ghundal]

Ghundal seems to me to support the opression of the Afghan people by the authority and ruthless acts of those people claiming to be Taliban.

All Afghans are opposed to foreign presence. Stop being a moron.

[MDresden]

He is a Paki.

Ahh, I understand. Still supporting opression isn't a good thing.

[MDresden]

All Afghans are opposed to foreign presence. Stop being a moron.

WAIT HOLD UP.

So you are stating before that the people voicing their opinion will cause nothing to happen.

Now you state Afghans are opposed to foreign presence.

Putting this together seems to make me believe you support the opression of Afghans by the Pakistans (namely the Taliban) and are only here to say "we attack Afghans and there's nothing you can do about it."

[ghundal]

He is a Paki.

and so do you think the whole Southern and Eastern Afghanistan are Pakis?

US reports, I can show the links if you want, show that there is increased support for the Taliban in Afghanistan, primarily in the Eastern and Southern parts. This is a US report fool.

Idiot LOL

[MDresden]

However, Afghanistan is building its economy and its education and its security. I believe Afghanistan will be able to keep Pakistanis (foreigners...in another country) out if they need to be out and take care of its own.

[ghundal]

Roadrunner,it is not even worth replying to you LOL

you repeat the same nonsense over and over.

[MDresden]

and so do you think the whole Southern and Eastern Afghanistan are Pakis?

US reports, I can show the links if you want, show that there is increased support for the Taliban in Afghanistan, primarily in the Eastern and Southern parts. This is a US report fool.

Idiot LOL

You are the fool. People are being polled in Afghanistan while those in Pakistan being polled are generally ISI/the government. If people are being polled in Afghanistan and that's their response they are probably voicing their opinion in fear of reprocussions.

May I also add that the Taliban come from Pakistan from Northern and Eastern Afghanistan? It's all making sense now.

Sorry Gundhal, but I despise you now...as a person and as one that supports opression of Afghans.

[khyaal]

Ahh, I understand. Still supporting opression isn't a good thing.

They overwhelm every Pashtun(afghan) forum as you can see here.