Why should I become a Secular Pashtun Nationalist?

[PakiPathan]

Neither

but definitely someone who didn't truly embody the words of the Qur'an.

who in your opinion truly embodied the words of quran in the opposing camp ?

[ScimitarXEdge]

[PakiPathan]

Sorry, I'm asking about the dominant personalities in the opposing camps of Abul Kalam Azad being president of the All Indian National Congress during the British era.

[ScimitarXEdge]

do you know what changing goal posts is?

[ScimitarXEdge]

anyways even though you changed goal posts

here you go.

[PakiPathan]

do you know what changing goal posts is?

I guess, I don't know.

[faye]

Alchemist has a right to question faye on that truly nonsensical question.
She might think to phrase a question better before opening up mouth /new post.

I pretended not to notice and refrained from saying anything, but better for her to
spend much more time reading and learning, not asking kindergartner questions
of these guys whose time is very valuable.
They are smart, each in his own way with his own talents.
Have some respect for them.

i laud you caty for taking the time and compassion to chastise and belittle me, for being so stoopid as to ask a question of muslims, about a muslim issue, on a forum of muslims, about a religion i am just beginning to learn about.
i know you, yourself must be very busy, utilising your vast talents, to help organise the protest against the war in afghanistan, and making sure the white light is keeping you protected from evil. thank you for your charity and kindness.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Catya, guns down she's not a Muslim

[Toramana]

Maulana Waheedudin Khan, Maulana Abul Hassan Ali Nudavi, Maulana Ubaidullah Sindhi, etc. all preferred a secular system over a theocratic one....

[ScimitarXEdge]

Maulana Waheedudin Khan, Maulana Abul Hassan Ali Nudavi, Maulana Ubaidullah Sindhi, etc. all preferred a secular system over a theocratic one....

I can't comment much on Waheeduddin Khan or Ubaidullah Sindhi but what you're saying about Shaikh Abdul Hassan Ali Nadwi is completely untrue.


He was actually a Pan-Islamist. much to your dismay,

[fzpz]

Neither was Sindhi. Keep trying.

[pir_Rokhan]

Neither was Sindhi. Keep trying.

Obaidullah Sindhi was a staunch secular nationalist with inclinations towards Indian National Congress [like Husain Ahmed Madani etc] , One of pioneers of "Reshmi Romal" movement and most authentic representative of Shah Waliullah's school of thought [Talfeeq bain al madhabil arba'a] whose philosophy enunciated the basic principles of secular state more philosophically in his Hujatullah Baligha , Al Buzurul Bazigha etc . [He was a person of the calibre that comparing , for example,a Saudi scholar like Shaikh Bin Baaz to Shah Waliullah will be comparing a KG child to a PhD scholar. He was given the honor of "Muhadith"]. For reference read Professor Mohammad Sarwar's compilations of Obaidullah Sindhi's works [on exegesis of the Quran] and his memoirs published by Sindh Sagar Academy.

[fzpz]

Like everything else you spew, its patently false tainted with your delusions. Read the works from Sindh Sagar Academy, never was there anything depicting a 'staunch secular nationalist'.

[pir_Rokhan]

I have read almost all of them about Obaidullah Sindhi and stand by my claim due to my majors in Muslim political philosophy. Like other pakis , you also love to spread lies instead of understanding and admitting facts.

[khyaal]

Subash Chandra Bose stayed for 40 days in hiding from the British with Haji Saib Turangzai. He kept him protected and helped him reach Germany via Afghanistan.