Union of Central-South Asian Muslim Republics (UCSMR)

[gadoonwal]

When I said a united Pak-Afghan Federation people over here laughed at me !!

This is the worst idea i have ever heard.
What your pakistan done for pashtuns?
the pashtun genocides,bombing schools,calling you terrorists etc.
Why you want a strong punjabistan where your people will suffer more under the ranjeet singh,s army.
The punjabis will sing the so called pakistani islam and the jahil pashtun will become their follower.
If you realy wants a better life for pashtuns then support the division of this punjabistan and free the pashtuns.
The best idea will be the pashtun-balcuh union into one country .A country free from the so called islamic republic of pakistan.
Pakistan is a big shame for the muslims and islam.
You see the suffering of pashtuns in karachi (where you live) with hands of mahajars and paki army.
wror jana cherta da isi dapara kho kaar na kai?
lag padi khpalo halqo tars wokhry .

[Badlun]

This is the era of nation states not confederations or merging borders and making new states. Yes economic unions like European union or ASEAN can be a success.

We should make SAARC, ECO , SCO strong and efective instead of having such utopian ideas.

[graveyardofempires]

Turkey is exactly the state that can lead us...I am not talking of any union of Muslim countries...UCSMR is a regional union...Turkey will be Mulsim lead nation in international politics....

Some fundo state cannot lead us...

How abotu we Afghans rule this Union.
people such as you are a margenalization of afghans.
Turkey in no way can/will or be allowd to rule the Afghans.
btw we afghans love arabs africans and asians so next time you think before making hateful remarks against arabs etc.

[graveyardofempires]

why not have a muslims Ummah and have Mullah Omar as the Amir? :P

[Karachi]

the current problem in pakistan is that almost all the adminstration is based in northern punjab, while Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan, Sindh and even southern punjab are left out for the most part, I am from Karachi and I wont mind being part of this kind of state

[BLS_1919v2.0]

This is the era of nation states not confederations or merging borders and making new states. Yes economic unions like European union or ASEAN can be a success.

We should make SAARC, ECO , SCO strong and efective instead of having such utopian ideas.

How many nation states are there in the middle east or South Asia? Majority of them are artificial post-colonial states. For what you say to have weight we have to redraw the geography of those aforementioned regions to proper "nation-states".

BTW Shehbaz khan we laughed because:
a) your source you got that article from
b) the situation of Pashtuns now
c) people tried that in the 1940s onwards, but even the so-called muslim-leaguers or jinnah poonjah saib wanted nothing to do with it. Joke from the start to finish.