Is it Haram to divide Pakistan?

[MazloomYarMasud]

I do not intend to offend anyone here or cause division but however one must accept that Pakistan is a 99 percent Muslim country, Pakistan has around 169 million Muslims while Afghanistan has around 29 Million Muslims, Islam is what unites Pakistanis as they have something in common, on what grounds would it be permissible to Divide Pakistan?

Afghanistan gave their lands to the British Raj and there was not a single battle fought for the reclaiming of the land(Daud is an exception).

When Pakistan went to war with India and in Bengladesh(East Pakistan) there was no objection nor any chance taken by Afghanistan to attack Pakistan and get its land back? May I ask why?

Even in the Kargil War, Pakistan received assistance from Afghans to fight India. There are 1000s of Afghans who are sent by their Parents to be educated in Madrassahs such as Darool Haqqania, Binoria(Karachi), Lal Masjid and many others.

Would you risk dividing yourself from other Muslims for the betterment of your land, is there any Islamic justification of taking land from other Muslims and claiming its solely yours?

Those who support the reclaiming Land can you guys produce forward your arguments and support of such actions that does not go against your faith and the faith of nearly 200 million Pakistani Muslims?



Kind Regards

(Disclaimer:-I am not trying to stir any trouble,hatred or anything, lets start a good debate).

[Dreamer]

I do not intend to offend anyone here or cause division but however one must accept that Pakistan is a 99 percent Muslim country, Pakistan has around 169 million Muslims while Afghanistan has around 29 Million Muslims, Islam is what unites Pakistanis as they have something in common, on what grounds would it be permissible to Divide Pakistan?

Afghanistan gave their lands to the British Raj and there was not a single battle fought for the reclaiming of the land(Daud is an exception).

When Pakistan went to war with India and in Bengladesh(East Pakistan) there was no objection nor any chance taken by Afghanistan to attack Pakistan and get its land back? May I ask why?

Even in the Kargil War, Pakistan received assistance from Afghans to fight India. There are 1000s of Afghans who are sent by their Parents to be educated in Madrassahs such as Darool Haqqania, Binoria(Karachi), Lal Masjid and many others.

Would you risk dividing yourself from other Muslims for the betterment of your land, is there any Islamic justification of taking land from other Muslims and claiming its solely yours?

Those who support the reclaiming Land can you guys produce forward your arguments and support of such actions that does not go against your faith and the faith of nearly 200 million Pakistani Muslims?



Kind Regards

(Disclaimer:-I am not trying to stir any trouble,hatred or anything, lets start a good debate).

was it halal to divide the muslims of India? ask urself that before bring up the topic of "Pakistan"

[graveyardofempires]

naming a country created by dirty people "pakistan" is haram
being slave of british is haram
being slave of america and zionists is haram.
attacking pashtuns is haram
killing/raping bengalis is haram
following an ismaili shia is haram



brothers and sisters this guy is no maseed,this is a pro paki propagandist.
he is delusional and thinks pakistan is full of pak/clean people and it is a muslim country built upon islam.

no country can be built on islam and not on other muslim country.
the best thing is to ignore this mentality disorderd person.
he needs help from a psychologists or a mullah to help him.

[Da_Kunar_Ghro]

Maseed wrora, one question.

Sometimes you are against Pakistan and sometimes you are for Pakistan, what's the deal?

[Da_Kunar_Ghro]

naming a country created by dirty people "pakistan" is haram
being slave of british is haram
being slave of america and zionists is haram.
Attacking pashtuns is haram
killing/raping bengalis is haram
following an ismaili shia is haram



brothers and sisters this guy is no maseed,this is a pro paki propagandist.
He is delusional and thinks pakistan is full of pak/clean people and it is a muslim country built upon islam.

No country can be built on islam and not on other muslim country.
The best thing is to ignore this mentality disorderd person.
He needs help from a psychologists or a mullah to help him.

zionist is not haram.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Why should Afghanistan ask for the land back? Do you guys want to sell it again to someone else? (Joking) As far as I have read about the Durand Line Agreement there is no such thing that Afghanistan will get this land back? Over

Who asked Afghans to travel to Karachi and study in there in a Madrassah?

Dividing Pakistan or any state/country is not Haram or Crime .. But for the betterment of whom it should be done? Only than one can think whether dividing that country is right or wrong..

Manana

[graveyardofempires]

zionist is not haram.

zionism is ****

[Shehbaz Khan]

brothers and sisters this guy is no maseed,this is a pro paki propagandist.
he is delusional and thinks pakistan is full of pak/clean people and it is a muslim country built upon islam.

no country can be built on islam and not on other muslim country.
the best thing is to ignore this mentality disorderd person.
he needs help from a psychologists or a mullah to help him.

I am not sure about him but you surely does, attacking the person with your lame comments ..

[graveyardofempires]

Why should Afghanistan ask for the land back? Do you guys want to sell it again to someone else? (Joking) As far as I have read about the Durand Line Agreement there is no such thing that Afghanistan will get this land back? Over

Who asked Afghans to travel to Karachi and study in there in a Madrassah?

Dividing Pakistan or any state/country is not Haram or Crime .. But for the betterment of whom it should be done? Only than one can think whether dividing that country is right or wrong..

Manana

you must be loving the british devide and conquer strategy.
we did do any agreement with pakistan,and it was done under pressure and by deception.

you call yourself pashtun?you couldnt spell it.
this pakistani pashtun story is getting old with no effect.
your reasoning is flawd.

[graveyardofempires]

I am not sure about him but you surely does, attacking the person with your lame comments ..

arguing with you is like taking water to the sea.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Shehbaz interesting statement, so when we look at Pashtun interests, I don't see Pakistan serving it. That is why we should opt for a new way.

[Shehbaz Khan]

you must be loving the british devide and conquer strategy.
we did do any agreement with pakistan,and it was done under pressure and by deception.

you call yourself pashtun?you couldnt spell it.
this pakistani pashtun story is getting old with no effect.
your reasoning is flawd.

You didn't say anything about my statement(s) on the topic. You just came back and told me something about me .. Kindly comment on my comments not on my personality.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Shehbaz interesting statement, so when we look at Pashtun interests, I don't see Pakistan serving it. That is why we should opt for a new way.

Agreed BLS but if we want to serve Pakhtun Interest why don't we make the situation perfect. Let's divide both Pakistan and Afghanistan and create a separate homeland for Pakhtuns

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Agreed BLS but if we want to serve Pakhtun Interest why don't we make the situation perfect. Let's divide both Pakistan and Afghanistan and create a separate homeland for Pakhtuns

Well that is what I keep asking you all. Why use Pashtunistan as a crutch? Why don't you advocate it from the beginning? See I disagree with toranama on this and believe in uniting Afghanistan and Pashtunkhwa, but we both agree on unifying Pashtuns. However you shehbaz wrora stay on pro-Pakistan and then you sometimes switch to Pashtunistan.....why don't you take that stand from the beginning?

[graveyardofempires]

Agreed BLS but if we want to serve Pakhtun Interest why don't we make the situation perfect. Let's divide both Pakistan and Afghanistan and create a separate homeland for Pakhtuns

devide afghanistan?hahahahahhahahaha
you moron,Afghanistan is a country while pakistan is created by british occupying Afghan land.
dont you ever dare to talk non sense.
we will not give up an inch of our land from Amu river till Atok.
there will never be a separate homeland just for pashtuns,its is Afghanistan,take it or leave it.

pakistanis have the same tactics as israel but the difference is israeli claim has more credibility.